Colm

I read somewhere that Adelaide are very keen on him and willing to trade up using 16 and F1st to get him. Would 16 be too late to get Pickett or Nairn ?

We weren’t going to be good enough to make the 8 next year. We’re less chance of making top 6. No way a club wins a flag that finishes outside top 6 now. Finishing 7th to 10th just pushes out Mad Monday for a week or two. Dilutes the finals series for me by weakening the chances of the 7th and 8th team.

A lot of junior footy played between July and November not to mention the combine. Lots of players develop and bit later in the season. Just look at Robey’s late season form. Others don’t kick on from where they were were I’d imagine all top recruiter list would change dramatically during that period. I’d also be shocked if any top recruiters list looked the same as each others as everybody sees it a bit different. Twomey gets more right than wrong over a long period of time

Also talk that Hawks want Pickett maybe not at pick 10 but are considering using their F1 and 22 to move up and grab him.

Narin would certainly be an interesting pick. I wonder would it mean sliding one of our picks back a bit?! Split 8 and improve 37 maybe and get Pickett and Narin? Problem is GWS have pick 12 and they often seem to identify the same players as us. I have complete faith in JT and think an even crop like this is where he will shine.

His ranking are just that. How he ranks that draft crop. He put out his phantom a couple of days before and he gets very little wrong in the first round.

Cal was suggesting that the club with pick 38( Richmond I think) would probably end up with a player they rate around 20 in the draft due to clubs ranking players very differently and I assume later picks coming in a bit. 37 could be nice spot for JT to find a gem.

I’ll back JT to make the calls. With no word on him resigning with the Dee’s beyond this year, the 2025 draft maybe his parting masterpiece.

I mean I suppose it wouldn’t be a shock if he went to St Kilda considering that’s where half the Irish start off at when they come out here( myself included). Be a shame though as it sounds like he has a lot of potential.

If we draft both Taylor’s ( which I wouldn’t be unhappy with) and they play a game together being called by BT, we will have two Taylor’s been drafted by a Taylor being called by a Taylor. Confusing

[censored] me. How the hell are we getting trumped by the Saints again?!

Just to add to that, just got in contact with someone very well connected at Kode’s county ( Mayo) level who’s opinion I have massive respect for. “just turned 18 , lightening fast , brilliant in the air and can kick with both feet … prob best prospect to come out of mayo ever” Very strong praise from someone who wouldn’t give it lightly. I’d be delighted if we picked him up🤞

Rumour over on Bigfooty( decide on the size of your pinch of salt) that we are offering GC first and pick 37 to move up and grab LSP.

That may be true but… Neither of those stadiums had to have a roof. Also the stadium in Tas will only have 7 games a season whereas Optus has 22 and MCG has god knows how many.

Interesting that we are now starting to be linked to a couple of players a bit further back in the pool. I wonder will we split 8. Also although Schubert links seemed mainly from random phantom drafts this link to a big key forward if from other clubs. Wonder if King want a big Gorilla as part of his set up.

Just been watching all his YT clips and interviews. He’s the one I hope we pick at 8. Perfect for that small lockdown role, good speed and kicking to exit defence. Seems to have heaps of upside which is something JT always likes. We could possibly slide back slightly to get him and improve our third pick at the same time to get Pickett. Would allow us to move Bowser up the ground.

As I posted earlier in this thread. There has been roughly a 25% population increase or 5 million people since GWS came in. About the population of the Republic of Ireland. That’s enough for another small comp never mind another team. The talent pool is there. The AFL and the clubs need to be asking themselves if they are doing enough to develop that talent.

If we took a WA prospect at 7 or 8 I wonder if that would be reflected in a future trade should they want to go home down the track. Going by all reports and now having watched highlights of most of the top prospects I would be delighted if we got someone of McVee’s level at pick 8 and yet we only got 24 for Judd which seemed fair value. Would we have got more if he was a high first round pick instead of a rookie ?

They are a very good starting point but we still need more A grade talent. For me we had Clarry, Trac, Max and May as A graders for our flag with Jackson and Kossie as emerging A graders, so 6 established or emerging.8 Max is still A grade as seen by his 8th AA but hasn’t got long left, Kossie is A grade and Langford and Lindsay are emerging. We’re still short a couple imv.

Not a draft watcher but I have read he’s spent live the contested stuff much and is more likely to stay a defender rather than spend time in the mid. Sign him up for some Viney jiu jitsu after we draft him.

Agree, I think we 2 more A graders and a few role players that are elite in at least one area. Hopefully with a coaching and development staff someone already on our list might come on and show more than expected. Normally I’m all for being aggressive with our future picks but the more I watch of this draft crop the more I think we should just go for role players with an elite skill or two and save our future picks and hopefully pick up a couple of A graders next year.

Gday Dannyz, any word of JT extending his contract?

Or we could do a deal that would enable us to get Robey and Pickett. I’ll be surprised if we go to the draft with our current draft hand.

Leaving aside the draft for talent verses needs debate. After our trade period what are the positions/areas that you feel we are still lacking enough quality heading into the draft?

Bi curious??