Kent

Figures are Petraccas' over 8 years Just saying him moving forward as suggested elsewhere is not necessarily going to produce more goals this season

Had the same problem at Adelaide by all reports I hope he takes his chances now at the DEES

Agree in the main Macca bit CPs 170 G 152 BH over 8 years is not gonna save us this year Needs to really kick some bigger scores when and if he goes forward

So what was the use of selecting him and then sacking him What actually happened as now we have no effective back up to Max when he is older and continually roughed up by the opposition I find it bizarre that the club haven't been transparent in this matter

Certainly was !

List spots are finite ? The club decides on the number There are two list spots that could have been available but the players concerned were on contracts a year longer tahn necessary in my opinion

Yeah maybe we should have thought of that before

Yes and our game plan relies on gawn We have learned nothing in two years so sad

Giddy up!!!

All very reasonable Macca But these two are now hanging around for year 3 Surely there is a limit

Agreed what possible upside is there carrying to crocks when we could be developing for the future

I can guess why ET

Off you go then names let's look at facts Criticism is healthy warranted or not

Are the snakes in the past or future Picket?

Who causes the flooding?

If Fullarton can play to his potential could surprise a few on here I know its a stretch His highlights show that he does possess the skill What is missing I don't know He would play an important back up role and impact when he comes on

Gee I miss Jackieboy

Even though the instructions may be suspect?

What happened to Harvey?

Two years is more than a form lapse I dont care whether you think its cool or not Fact is he was picked when he shouldnt have been is all I'm suggesting.

Lets hope you are right 2021 was exceptional followed by two years of averages less than half of2021 output clearly not fit/ injured should not have been an auto selection said so at the time! I like you, hope he returns to his best on the list since 2014 and been great for the club It is only my view that all has to go right for him to be auto selected I will continue to question if that is ok by you?

Good looking team as always Werridee If Salem doesn't get up who is likely to replace in your view

How would he look at 0 and 6 in 2024? my view is that Goodwins' gameplan is toast and if we are to figure in Sept it needs a major overhaul We make it so hard to attack because the players are too defensive minded and are chained to a style Needs to be more freedom in attack we have the players for gods sake.

I had a quick look at the available data Water tables looks closer to - 5.0 metres to me which could limit your excavation proposal Will have a closer look at available bore data

Yes Brilliant to play and injured out of form TMac Showed great creativity