58er

Yes really What about the character our players showed all last season ? very hard to please H !!!

Agree Tmac may even be a politician for his country region where he lived Edenhope !!!

Agree with AJ I think WJ said at the start he didn't pick Big Carl ! Any one remember? I can't recall all that way back.

Doesn't have to name another wingman in top 20. It's not a complete team but no but no doubt we will all have our go on that one. Reckon Stretch Sylvia maybe James Mac and possibly Stephen Febey could be a bit high. Reckon T Mac might be a bit low and Lingers is not in out top 20 Reckon Lingers will stand up well in our Top5 wingers from 1972 in a couple of years. Maysie is high snd really has only put together 2 years of great footy and hard to place in longevity compared with Stephen Smith as a longer term defender who undoubtedly was hampered by hamstring injuries for the last half of his career. Reckon we could almost pick the next 20 players but the order??? Stynes Todd and Jack Viney Robbie Flower Jeff White Mark Jamar??? Greg Wells Gary Hardemann Gary Lyon Whiz Gawny Trac Clarry Gerard Healey Neiter Schwarta Brett Lovett Jonesy. Brian "Wilow" Wilson. I have forgotten at least one other player probably a ruckman or midfielder. Anyone???

Totally agree NS and think that the Pride guernsey is fantastic in design and colour. Also in its meaning. Magnificent and totally blows the Pies token effort to bits.

Adelaide Brisbane Hawthorn and Richmond. You can't count threepeats of Lions and Hawks as two doubles!

Wrong horse backed ones a pedigree the other a speedy sprinter !!

Sorry I am inner city south in Brisbane !!!

Just took my 2019 and 2020 Demon scarves off the front walkway and drive side balcony this week. Still to finalise the in door photos and memorabilia.

I am presuming you regard Tayla Harris as a plus dl4e as IMO she will along with the improvement of most of the newer and younger girls plus If we can get Our Geelong recruit Purcell on the park early enough will make our forward and attacking moves far more potent and our scoring shots more accurate. Just look at BBB in the AFL and his influence and it's going to take a very good team to stop our girls with their strong and aggressive game plan and multi faceted options to score. Casey Fields is such a fortress now and no reason for that not to keep on happening.

Well that's a whole new game with some ovv TV those changes you favour FT. SOME will NEVER BE PART of AFL thankfully and are: 1. Throwing the ball away when correctly tackled does not reward the tackler and it's not part of Aussie Rules to introduce throwing the ball. 2. Reducing to 16. Seems like a good idea but we through our superb wingers can see the skill in their position say like Lingers who is unique and also a differing skill role by Angus superbly and courageously performed in the GF. Maybe a forward/back pocket like the AFLW could work but let's leave it while we have 30 plus good players!!! Fir so long we had 12/15 and struggled NOW we have more and better players on our list so don't fix anything if it's not broke. 3. Ball ups on the 15 metre line after a rushed behind will cause far too much more congestion. Not needed the rushed behind it has been sorted only SOME players need to learn the rules. Another skill our defence is so good at clearing or nullifying our opponents Don't meddle with it It ain't broke. CHANGE To last possession over boundary is fine like AFLW but not inside the 50m arc. LEAVE THE SAME BUT INTERPRET QUICKER. Holding the ball which is intended now to be a lot quicker ie not 2by 360 degree rotations but one or deemed prior opportunity far more strictly along with no genuine effort to keep the game moving. Actually one of the annoying things with AFLW is that so often the girls just curl up and hold the ball either standing or on the ground and make no effort to move the ball on. This results in about 10/12 ball ups each quarter FAR tOO MANY. Penalise the ball holders and the game will flow more. It's just lack of skill and a blight on the game!! Holding the ball and tackling are and always have been open to interpretation and the AFL are by these changes looking to solve the non decision and fastening the game so let's see how they go this year !! So really just add the intended holding the ball/ tackling rules judgements and time wasting plus maybe the last possession rule and that all that is needed to change. The other changes are too great for the fabric of the game and if played correctly are a bonus not a negative on the game. ie if it ain't broke don't fix it!!!

You have ignored the fact that Richmond lost nearly all the games that Martin missed at the end if the Year say 8 out of 10. Yes Martin was not at his best in 2021 but my point is that The Tigers were lost without him much more than earlier in the year.

Was not Rosman. Don't fret. Do you think Maxy or Clarry would look much good in the AFL half time sprint?

You are dreaming Radar please go back to sleep. There is a good reason Melky Chandler and Weid did not make the team and Bowey did , they were not up to it. I think most of our youngsters including Smith ( Joel) plus Even Majak and Dunstan could improve but to replace those 8 players would be impossible. Maybe make 5/8 th !! if all fit in Finals then another story!!

Who would you rather have been ? Tigers or us? They almost had our 2019 repeat. But they may not have the hunger or depth to climb that same mountain agsin.

Agree that some will emerge. Dogs Power and Lions are candidates and Giants and Swans plus Bombers are all possibilities that could test us if we are below our best.

Results don't even remotely back up your theory or opinion. They had plenty of others injured as well similar to us in 2019. Their backline especially and on ball groups were worst hit and are still the areas that hold the key to their fortunes. Old Father Time May also be the elephant in the room and their kids may need a year or two to prosper.

Well in a way they do. But it's in smaller doses. Look at the fourth quarter virtually every Melb player did something special. Right down to Pickett who had an almost day all teamed together but we know Clarry and Trac and Jack V were the ringleaders. Spargo and Harmesy did have highlights and actually ANB played his best game and was in our best half dozen I believe.

Jordon says hi !! Sparrow says gooday!!

You can if you want to when it's Covid free Book when tickets are first available !!! Where there is a Will there is a way!!!

Totally correct JCB Gawny became the hunted and all our forwards benefited from his prescience. Even when They swapped Jacko developed a presence with more goals due to his all round footy skills. Our totals each match were a revelation especially in the Finals.

The forward line was finally bonded together when BBB came back for his second stint and we never looked back after a couple of weeks working at patterns and coordination and also kicking the ball high to BBB when he was mostly isolated with only one opponent or shorter opponents.

But Goody was the next choice and to say Roosy didn't recruit Goody is palpably wrong and disengenuos to Roos (and PJ. )

I am excited about them all Dogga Kossie Riv Sparrow Jordon Petty Bowser Laurie Rosman JVR Howes Taj AZW Judd McVee Turner Bedford ? Deakyn Smith ? well May we look like that with our 22-25 yo champs running around in 2/3 years time!! Trac Clarry ANB Spargo Lingers Angus Salo Jake ( Rick) Jack V Weid ?J.Smith ? Hunty ? Harmsey

Good look Nascent yes 21 One to watch I reckon. Something special about this kids marking.