Everything posted by roy11
- Full Review of the AFL called for by Swans and Hawks
-
2020 Brownlow Medal
I echo the view of a lot of posts in this thread but will summarize my thoughts 1. Happy M Brown got in on the votes, was playing some good footy at the end of the year. Hope we can find a place for him. 2. Had money on Neale/Boak/Petracca trifecta - Winnings reduced 50% cos Jack Steele snuck it at the end to tie with Trac. So he is now my most hated player in the AFL. 3. I did not like Danger's suit. 4. Trac had polled 5 votes in 85 AFL games until 2020 where he polled 20 votes in 17 games. The finger has well and truly been pulled out and i look forward to seeing what he brings to the table next year. 5.Black should have given the award 6. Mark of the Year and Goal of the year were wrong - but who cares - Pickett will win them both next year. 7. Happy for Clay to poll well, hopefully all can be soothed going forward 8. Langdon unlucky not to poll, but he's only ever received 2x 1 votes in his career. (68 Games Freo, 17 games Melbourne). Maybe needs more end product for the umps to get attention. Had a look at some other wingers and Isaac Smith polled 25 votes in 210 games, Brad Hill 15 votes in 168. 9. The players in the Melbourne studio sitting there with the masks, raw end of the deal aha.
-
Jared Polec
Seems North have addressed the rumours on Rhyce Shaw that have been eluded to in the thread "We have been acutely aware of speculation regarding our head coach, but we have not been in a position to say anything as we are respecting the wishes of Rhyce and his family. Rhyce has asked for some time and space away from football and we have provided him support during this period. We thank the media for their ongoing cooperation and trust they understand we can’t make further comment at this time." from letter from the chairmen https://www.nmfc.com.au/news/826849/letter-from-the-chairman
-
Oliver Rumours on Footy Classified
Oliver's performance got better as the season went on, if he stays and and continues to improve then he won't have to worry about finishing below 3rd in the BnF. Coaches will always love players like Langdon/Viney who give all for the cause. Either way don't like the smoke here, big 12 months for the club on and off the pitch if we're to retain the Ginger Prince.
-
Neville Jetta
Life member and good bloke, if he's not in Goodwin's plan for best 22 then the club should help him move on for the extra years and trust the process with Lockhart etc Imagine if Jetta does go we'd retain Jones for leadership.
-
2021 - What excites you?
Jokes aside Ed Langdon running at the G
-
2021 - What excites you?
Leaving the house
-
Dual MCC/MFC Membership
this is what I do too, never had an issue.
-
Trade Targets
You'd assume he means Trac/Gawn/Oliver May. Have no qualms saying 4 in the best 50 but seeing May didn't even make 40 man AA squad (STILL AN UNJUST OVERSIGHT THAT MUST BE AVENGED) a bit too hard to argue.
-
The Soccer thread
there's a joke floating around that goes along the lines of Arteta can couch but has no money; Lampard has money but can't coach; Then there's Ole who has no money and can't coach. Ultimately, I think Lampard won't get the best out of the squad. I'm no Chelsea fan but that front 4 (when fit and all available) is worthy of a title challenger. I know Leicester a bit of an abnormality but they had a solid and not spectacular backline when they won the league. A back line of Chilwell Zouma Silva James is solid enough, give them time to gel - esp with the new keeper. it's been a crazy season so far, long may it continue - very hard to predict.
-
Isaac Smith
3 years is over the top but probably required to get him here. I assume the 3rd year would be on less coin either way.
-
Trade Targets
What do we think will happen to Mitch Brown?
-
Trade Targets
SEN reporting Carlton are "keen" on De Goey and have room for one more big name after Williams and Saad. What an efficient period that may be for them if they can get them all over the line. Although i am sure it would create some cap issues. Hopefully we can pull off another missing piece of the puzzle this period. Which teams below us on the ladder are you most worried about for 2021?
-
Yze is a Demon Again
https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/824053 He's back!
-
Development the Key for Luke Jackson
He also looks like he belongs in Brunswick.
-
Farewell Braydon Preuss
You'd imagine GWS would "want" him the most given the list they have. Sure the other clubs would want a #1 ruck but further away from the "window"
- The Kalani White Thread (F/S)
-
WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - BEN BROWN
Essendon? Dees? Bulldogs? Pies? Hawks? Essendon probably got the most $ to throw esp with Saad/Danniher on the way out.
-
Viney Signs Until 2025
Good news, not sure about the 5th year but hopefully he proves me wrong. Happy he remains a demon for life.
-
Crows Attempting to Poach Darren Burgess
-
Tom McDonald
Happy playing Tmac up forward if he gets his body right. If we're chasing goals late in a game dont mind switching him and May who can use his strength etc.
-
Petty, Sparrow & Smith Re-Sign
https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/821186 Three Demons sign on Tom Sparrow, Harry Petty and Joel Smith have agreed to new contracts
-
Tom McDonald
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2020/10/01/melbourne-defender-expected-to-depart-club/ Article by Sam Edmund about Oscar Likely leaving. has the below on Tom "Oscar’s brother Tom McDonald has also been the subject of trade speculation, but is set to stay at Melbourne where he still has two years to run on a contract. It’s believed Tom has vowed to change his body shape in a bid to recapture the form as a key forward that helped the Demons make the 2018 preliminary final. In an attempt to add strength and avoid getting pushed off the ball, he lost his athleticism and gut-running ability to get up and back. He will now work to strip weight over summer."
-
Isaac Smith
Result/Performances aside he's played in a Grand Final, the furthest any of our crop have gone! He didn't really impact games at GWS, just plays his part. We're shambolic in a shambolic year, i'll hold all my judgment off until 2021 is completed.
-
Isaac Smith
@DeeSpencer Would you call Tomlinson an update on Frost/OMac at least?