bobby1554

Should never play another game for MFC again. Find another club son

We just have too many ordinary footballers. No way we are winning a flag this year. Typical Melbourne, pump up your tyres, then deflate you when the crunch comes. So disappointing.

Keep hoping mate. It ain’t gonna happen. And if you are seriously comparing him with Tom Hawkins, you sir, are a fool. Just for the record, the stats DO back up my immature and embarrassing assertion. He hasn’t fired a shot, other than a final in 2018. Averaging a goal, whoopee do!

Wow! All that to average under 8 disposals a game. The problem with Sam then, and again now, is that he does not impact the game.

Well if that’s the case, then it is a damning blight on him. Been in the system for 6 years, hasn’t played 50 games yet, and around 50 goals total. With the hot competition for a spot in the 22 at the moment, if work rate is an issue, then goodbye. Strikes me as the sort of player who will go to a second club, fail to fire a shot there, and give it away. I don’t think his heart is in it.

Seriously? The whole point of the fortress scenario is that we have the majority of support in the crowd. If the crowd is zero, there ain’t no fortress. If the AFL/Vic Govt decide there can be no crowd at the G on Queens Birthday, there is absolutely no point bringing the players back to play there

In the same league as Oliver and Petracca? Make your your own calls

Ordinary footballer at best. Never going to hurt you. A great example of why stats are sometimes meaningless

Based on my observation of him. He lacks mobility. And those other key forwards have one thing he doesn’t, they can get the ball when it hits the deck

His performance in the VFL did not warrant selection. Funny how just a couple of weeks ago everyone was saying we had a nice dilemma with our plethora of forwards. And here we are wondering again. The brutal truth is Weideman has shown nothing at AFL level to say, yep he’s the one we pin our hopes on going forward. And I suspect Browns best years are behind him. His movement appears limited, which is more than likely that knee issue. Don’t forget, North were happy for him to leave. we will get beaten easily tonight

Yep

Won’t matter who comes in and goes out. We are not getting within 6 goals of them

Still ridiculous?

Predictable response from someone who knows the writing is on the wall. Beginning of the end for the Tigers

I like it. Weid needs to be given an opportunity to show what he is capable of. Brown was the only out for that scenario. All of those posters against Melksham inclusion, he is a quality footballer. Sure, may not be impacting games as much as he did, but at this stage is a better prospect than Chandler

Come on pal, do you honestly think we have served up better than that this year? If you do, you are in dreamland

Yep

Noted. That’s what a forum is for, to share opinions.

We are nowhere near the Dogs, they are a class above us

Tom Lynch is a spud.

Don’t you just love that vision of Hardwick head in hands, without a clue. Smug p....k

Which is probably the reason Longmire said we are the best side in it at the moment.

Money well spent in my book. If it tells the rest of the competition that S. May is breathing down your neck, win win

Copped a massive corkie in the last play. Would be extremely doubtful next week

Just as Daisy Pearce has said, very similar situation with our game. Will be very interesting to see the Geelong response here. We know how we handled the early heat