waynewussell

Have to agree with previous posters, made an ordinary team under immense pressure look half ok. Any anxiety from match committee to play Trengove, Dawes, Dunn & Grimes should now be put to sleep.

Disappointing, to say the least Tyson was obviously not over his illness. Oscar is no way a better option than Dunn at this stage. Newton and Neale Bullen did not take their opportunity Petracca's worst game Midfield did not work despite Gawn playing well Kennedy had a bad one Harmes had a bad one

only if our injured list hits 23 on 4 to 6!!!! On the cusp of the 8 and we're resorting to whim and fancy! Dawes will fill CHF as soon as he dominates the position for Casey. He's getting there, but not quite yet. Oscar, H, Grimes, Dunn, & White would all be ahead of Dawes as a backman.

I knew Vince would get off the first time I watched the replay! Vince knew he would get off as soon as he was reported and he told the ump as much. Vince tried to avoid forceful contact to the head. He was moving through at pace and then checked himself when he made contact to Wallis' upper shoulder so that he wouldn't crunch him on the jaw... only incidental, accidental contact that was inconsequential and the adjudicators got it right. Several Demonlanders hung Vince before the trial!

Can't see why Vince will get suspended for a bump on the shoulder and no real impact on the player he supposedly hit 'high'. Gawn was well beaten alright... by the maggots! The umpires continually let the Bulldog ruckman impede his run at the ball while allowing Bonts to have a clear hit as third man up. Contrast this approach by the maggots to the free against Hickey for impeding Goldstein! Oliver's minimal impact had him top 5 for handballs and around top 5 or 6 for tackles! Apart from that DemonLAd5, I reckon you're pretty close!

If we can find someone else (whose name rhymes with a drawing instrument) to give Gawn a chop-out, then we can switch Pederson to CHB when needed. Dunn for Garland after his good showing at Casey for the past two outings.

6 - Jetta 5 - Viney 4 - Tyson 3 - Watts 2 - Stretch 1 - Kennedy

Jack's performance throughout the introduction to the panel was an insight into this young, emerging MFC leader. I saw a side of his personality and skill set that belied the 'bull at the gate' impression he creates on the field. His performance gives me great confidence in the future at MFC if he becomes Captain when Jonesy hangs up the boots!

Ok Django... so you're calling me out! I didn't say Jack was getting as much exposure as Sam... and you obviously missed the segments I referred to. Keep my comments in context... I was giving Jack the thumbs up as a guest. Think about the guest's role on the FS. and while I'm on those two letters, FOR F S, ALLOW YOURSELF TO READ SOMEONE ELSE'S POST WITHOUT FEELING COMPELLED TO MAKE AN ILL-INFORMED CORRECTION!

This is the funniest Footy Show I have seen for some time... and most of the fun has been generated by our Jack! I'm pretty sure that he will become a regular. His comments about Tod's view of young Jack being named as a sex symbol were hilarious and his snippet on sex after a game was, well.. boom boom! Either he has an exceptional writer or he is a natural!

I'm bemused that some on here still don't get what we've got with Tyson! He is only 22 (ANB is 20). Recruiting him is only marginally shaded by the Vince deal, and he has at least six more years with MFC after Bernie retires!

6 - Gawn 5 - Viney 4 - Jones 3 - Jetta 2 - Harmes 1 - Vince

6 - Gawn 5 - Harmes 4 - Jones 3 - Jetta 2 - Viney 1 - Bugg

17 of this 22 played in our win over GWS. Missing from that game are Salem, Vandenberg, Matt Jones (all injured) Frost and Oscar (emergency tomorrow). Replacements are Petracca, Michie, Wagner, Hunt & Stretch. I look at it this way... Petracca for Vandenberg, Stretch for M Jones, Michie for Salem, Wagner for Oscar Mac, Hunt for Frost. Given that it is a twilight game in dewy conditions I don't see why there is such hostility about selection

I'm of the opinion that TMac couldn't get to his designated zone position through injury and not because of tardiness.

Don't be surprised if you find that TMac was carrying an injury on Saturday. Hopefully he is 95-100% fit for the trip north as we need him firing. The other scenario is that he will need to be replaced (not dropped) this weekend.

When asked what my Petracca pass mark would be in his first game I said 15 disposals. He exceeded my pass mark!

32 v 13 16 minutes into second Q

Smith OOB on full from 25m. Oscar and Terlich getting mentioned

Broadcast on Essendon VFL Radio Brayshaw was taken to the rooms... still not sure if he will come back on. Oliver doing quite well. ANB, Michie and Garland getting regular possessions. Windy Hill is windy and wet.

6 - Hogan 5 - Jones 4 - Viney 3 - Tyson 2 - Vince 1 - Pederson

I can only think Petracca for Frost... Oliver to Casey. I like what Frost is bringing, but maybe at Etihad v Saints we need a mid more than a tall. Oliver is a clearance specialist, but the thinking may be give him a less pressured game at Casey before working him back into the team. Gus looked a bit stuffed at times on Sunday, but he still had a lot of deft and important touches inside. Matt Jones would be stiff to be sent to Casey, but selection is now that tight.

6 - Viney 5 - Gawn 4 - Garlett 3 - Kent 2 - Tyson 1 - McDonald

Dwayne lays claim to the same 'I have played at the highest level and been a success' territory that Matthews, Dunstall and Brereton trade on. I bring up his stats to emphasise how far he fell short of that sort of credibility.

Jack won't have to worry about making the Hawthorn team this year... they will drop out of the top four to be followed by a drop out of the top eight two years down the track!