At the break of Gawn

Was anyone else disappointed with Goodwin’s post match presser? I felt he didn’t really address the core of the issue. He pointed the finger at indiscipline for 3 50m goals, and not executing fundamentals in the front half etc We haven’t beaten another top 4 team this year. We can’t seem to get our game going at the MCG, and we just lack avenues to goal when Kozzy and Fritsch aren’t getting 6-8 between them. Gawn is not and will never be the answer as a forward. We also can’t have guys like Melksham playing a negating forward when he can’t even kick a set shot or even keep his feet. I’m in two minds whether we just go in with no changes and see if we can replicate what we did to Brisbane two games ago and then change things up for Geelong. Surely Gawn has to play 80% ruck against Fort and absolutely dominate him. Got no confidence whatsoever we’ll be there PF week. It wasn’t just that we lost it was the way we lost. It was the worst of us all bundled into one game. I feel like we’re the Port Adelaide of 2021. 2nd on the ladder was a massive over achievement for a team who can’t beat the teams around them. Our 2nd spot on the ladder almost feels fraudulent.

Real danger of going out in straight sets. Yesterday I thought we had great insurance playing the Lions if we lose, but honestly that’s as bad as we’ve looked all year and I’ve got real concerns that Fritsch and Kozzy are going to save us again.

If we lose to Sydney and then lose to Brisbane, it'll have nothing to do with Brisbane but everything about us.

To be fair it just around the McStay discussion. It's very risky against us but they would be ok going with him against Sydney.

Insurance policy locked in. Can’t see us not being in a prelim now.

I’ve read conflicting reports on Hibberd. Cleary is saying he had gastro symptoms, however the Fox Sports person reported that he’s just under the weather and The Age has said he’s unwell but not actually gastro.

I think the bye will help us. Two of our best finals performances last year came off a bye week. Swans have won their past 7 so this puts a circuit breaker on that which can only be a good thing.

Was yesterday the players day off? Hopefully it’s just contained to Goodwin.

It was a miracle really that May didn’t go off during the PF after his hamstring. Can you imagine if that happens again and the game is a lot tighter compared to the Geelong game? Smith coming in to give us that flexibility could be crucial.

Melksham will definitely go to one of the McCartins as a negating forward. I suspect Paddy as he seems the better intercept player. Goodwin will try and stretch their defence and force them to put Rampe on Gawn/Jackson leaving Fritsch to get Fox.

Not sure why Watts is even doing this regular segment. From the sounds of it he didn’t even watch the AFL awards night which he’s asked to pass comment on and I doubt he even watches a whole heap of footy.

80% of the players don’t even watch enough footy to properly vote in this. The coaches award and probably the rising star award is the only award with integrity.

Agree! Demonland is my therapy.

Surely the 10 ticket limit will be restricted come PF week? If we're playing someone like the Pies then it really should be 1 ticket per 1 membership.

I wanted 4 Cat 3 level 4 seats that was lowish in the stands. All exhausted so chose Sydney Members and there were plenty available.

I think Cripps might get it if he’s named as a starting mid, but if not, surely Max. Witts has had a better pure Ruck season but Gawn’s around the ground stuff places him well above him.

Unless we have some unforeseen injury or Covid issue, I’m almost certain it’s going to be: Out: Bowey In: Salem Sub: JJ Key matchups: Buddy vs May Mcdonald/Reid vs Petty Hayward vs Lever Papley vs Hunt Heeney vs Hibberd. Sydney have won 7 in a row and I reckon we’ve got them at the perfect time. They’ve had some really soft kills lately and their last game at the G was against Essendon which they lost. I’m not giving any weight to the round 12 game. We didn’t have May, Petty got injured half way through, Sam Reid played the game of his life and we got killed by the umps. There’s no way that happens again.

That’s stuffed.

Geez even the Umps are trying for an SCG final.

Say what you will about Richmond, but they definitely can put a big score on you.

Swans at the MCG is the ideal scenario. Our home crowd advantage will really help and I think we match up better with them. We really should have won that round 12 game.

I think you’re also missing the North v Swans game at Marvel recently which was 88-126. That won’t get the job done for them.

Saints biggest loss this year at Marvel has been 41pts (to Freo) and have won most of their games at Marvel this year. I’m pretty confident this won’t be a blow out.

The Saints defence has actually been pretty decent the last 5 weeks. Only conceded 100 pts to Geelong and surely you think they score at least 70 at Marvel. The 9 goal margin will be in the heads of the Swans and I actually think because it’s so large it’ll distract them.

I think about 10 goals