Jump to content

Mach5

Members
  • Posts

    3,014
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Mach5

  1. Must be. Strangely I've never heard him say a bad word about any player. Ever.
  2. He's nothing like Tapscott. About 10cm taller too.
  3. I think Henderson is underrated. Don't want him at MFC though.
  4. Crows for Motlop. Wouldn't waste our time & resources.
  5. Why would Henderson request a trade though? I was under the impression he was a RFA.
  6. Geelong were hopeful last time I asked (about 2 months ago) but thought he'd stay at Carlton. They'll be licking their lips now. Plenty of cap room with Enright, Johnson, Kelly, Stokes, McIntosh, Simpson and others all out the door.
  7. I think GC are trying to salvage some of his value. Fattening him back up for market before they make his ongoing welfare someone else's concern. I don't mind if that ends up being us. Having said that, I'd guess Wallet is just musing.
  8. Coming in he was compared mainly to Colin Sylvia. The prosecution rests.
  9. People's thoughts on Stanton? I think most people think he's rubbish, therefore he's a bit underrated. Not a world beater, but would fit in our 22.
  10. Would be disappointed recruiting Melksham as it would feel like treading water, but he must be a tiny step ahead of having to select Bail or Matt Jones.
  11. So you liked a bunch of obviously good players, and some ordinary ones. Great. Tucker isn't even a mid, let alone ready made. And Selwood was drafted later due to repeated issues with dodgy knees during juniors, not because of a lack of form. His top age form was good when he played.
  12. Great. You like him, we get it. Barely anyone else is convinced though.
  13. Curnow too. I also believe that if we keep our picks, we'll be going for upside if possible.
  14. A reason why I'm I favour of any efforts to get Bennell. Inside Geelong they were licking their lips at the prospect of offloading Varcoe for something meaningful, despite a gaggle of issues. Obviously in the right environment they dont necessarily have to stop a player from flourishing.
  15. No, stupid audience by the looks of it.
  16. Why? You think these symptoms are felt by Melbourne supporters alone? Wake up.
  17. Jetta was visibly struggling with flu like symptoms more than most, and I think Jones was too. I'm reasonably fit and young, but if they had the flu anything like I've had, I'm astonished they managed to play. And it has hung around for about 2 weeks so far, in various guises.
  18. Not enthused by picks 65 or 85. Every recruiter will be looking to recruit another Vandenberg and pick the eyes out the mature brigade come pick 60.
  19. You could say that Harley is a gamble, but I've personally witnessed future-HOF Geelong players "experimenting." It's about how bad the problem is, how committed he is to his footy, and what support network is put around him.
  20. More importantly, is olisik demonland material? Sadly the answer appears to be yes...
  21. Somehow I doubt that we'd recruit both of Lynch & Tomlinson. Very happy to do so however. Lynch for a 2nd rounder, Tomlinson for Howe and our 1st rounder for an A+ mid? Not sure. Maybe we'll venture as far as selling a future pick this year.
×
×
  • Create New...