Watts the matter

Watched it again and it looks like Higgins gives Wagner a real cheap shot in there. Might be the reason Salem reacted the way he did, which seemed very out of character. PS. The AFL are outrageous and are trying to claim it wasn't a 50m against Jeremy Cameron, he ran 5 meters over the mark.

The statement was he was very good today. He took NONE of his chances, therefore, his game was pathetic.

How can you come to this conclusion? I can recall 6 attempts at goal for a return of 4 behinds. He was horrific.

Has been poor defensively every game he has played at half back this year except last week, is good with ball in hand but anyone with a bit of speed will lose him on the spread. More frustrated at his cheap shot which was lucky not to get reversed and will see him miss a week or two. Similar to Rance on Watts.

No surprises there. Same old [censored]. We are crap at the MCG. Kent and Bugg disgusting performances. Salem stupid and slow. Will be suspended. Watts played like the old Watts. OMAC is OMAC, so so slow. Garlett poor, normally goes missing in the middle of the season. Vince is done, tag or bust. Riewoldt knows little about football (which surprised me), said he would tag Vince against Melbourne. Then talked about Tyson going in and roughing up the opposition to fire us up (like that would ever happen).

My understanding was that Jurrah didn't drink before coming to Melbourne? I can't remember Sambono kicking a drop punt in that highlight video.Reminds me a little bit of Jeffy.

Melksham going to sneak into the team or have they just stuffed up the graphic?

When was this?

Just on this, Petracca is 2nd in the league for goal assists. Oliver is 10th.

His tackling was a big improvement and a highlight, but he was still average at best tonight. Two holding the balls when he should have easily got a disposal. However, he didn't let Talia have much of an impact which was also a positive considering what Hurley and Rance did to us.

Couldn't believe that 30 second replay of a kick out that showed nothing instead of the actual play.

There is a difference between what you are saying and what I said. I responded to a comment saying an in form Brayshaw is in our top 10 players. He showed a lot of potential in his first season but has never been the same player since the West Coast game in that season.

Maybe on potential but definitely not based on anything he has produced at AFL level this far.

Played a great game and was super clean but he was dropped to the VFL just a few weeks ago. I think the reason he is good is quite simply because he is clean and a fast decision maker with the ability to use both hands and feet. The lack of basic skills of most draftees these days is astonishing.

I thought he was average (by his standards) tonight and Yeo got the better of that contest.

The TV commentators said he started on the back of the square as an extra.

Personally, I think this is a myth. He is a fantastic kick. Fluffed a few in the grand final and all of a sudden he can't kick.

Strange, given that Mahoney was interviewed during the first week and said he thought he was a good chance to play that week,

Just to get this back on track and if the club reads this. Very happy that they have started putting the videos up on the YouTube channel again. Living overseas and have all kinds of playback issues through the AFL websites.

The first one very similar to Charlie Cameron, who got a fine (can they please both just be rubbed out?). The second one is hard to see.

Not according to the media. 750K is the expected offer from GWS. From what I can remember, Melksham is on 400, Lumumba was on 500, and Bernie Vince got a lucrative deal for 2017. Josh Kelly is easily worth 800. Prestia is on about that and Kelly is a thousand times better than him (which I guess you have now figured out ) But it's clear North rate him a lot higher than we do, we have passed him up two times and they have publicly said they tried to get the mini draft pick we used on Hogan to draft Kelly.

Once I don't have to watch Bugg and JKH, I will.

If you are going to try and give me an English lesson at least do you research. The only difference here is between what I actually said and how you incorrectly interpreted it.

Not sure if being serious or sarcastic, so I'll remind you anyway. Tried to pass it to Hannan and messed it up.

And then what happened? He played a nothing game and didn't threaten or make our attacks dangerous. To not kick a goal from 30m out summed it up.