Jump to content

Dr evil

Members
  • Posts

    414
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    7

Everything posted by Dr evil

  1. Can't say I would be disappointed if Essendon got a kick in the guts and a nice bill to remind them of it.
  2. I know mad essendon supporters who claim to have inside info that Simon told the club his intentions to move on today, apparently impressed at his final interview and has entered negotiations
  3. Has apparently put talks on hold, speculation Melbourne has offered picks 2,3 and toump for Dangerfield and pick 9 and offered to pay the last year of his contract with the crows
  4. Ron they would have taken toumpas Norwood royalty
  5. Tom Mitchell used to live with roosy
  6. Saints will still take mccartin pick 1, I reckon they would even take Wright over petracca
  7. Would be interested to see how they would go if viney played for port and wines played for mfc
  8. Because at the time 90% of the football industry thought toumpas was better picket fence.
  9. Why is the rating system different for O'Rourke and Jacksh to Mitch, Mitch finds his best footy and he's absolutely worth a first round pick, but he may not. O'Rourke and Jacksh develop well and they should be worth that, but they may not, it's all a gamble, none of the three are certainties by any standards, only Mitch we know has played A grade footy before and been AA, the other two have never done it
  10. Incorrect, watch Jacksh and O'Rourke move for first round picks despite showing SFA in their first couple of seasons, that's based on potential and MFC need to play hard ball for Mitch, if we allow him to walk for a deal like that and he plays well we will feel like [censored] especially if Harry is only average, if we can snag a couple of good players, say Harry and Tom Lamb at pick 28 it won't be so bad
  11. every draft has high quality mids, not every draft has key talls like McCartin and I think that will be where their decision is made, the rebuild is going to take time, talls take time and quality mids are a lot easier to find, I think they would regret it if they passed McCartin up for a mid
  12. If the rumours of a trade to Collingwood are true i'd push for Mitch Clark & pick 57 for Harry Lamumba and pick 28, Mitch injury free is a better player than Harry so I think the pick upgrade is warranted and if he never comes good we win out with a solid B grade player and pick 28 could get a good player that slides through a little bit
  13. Disagree, I don't care what anyone says the Saints will not pass up a key forward prospect like Pat McCartin for a mid, there are good mids in the draft every year, key forwards are a lot harder to find, the only way Petracca goes pick 1 is if the Saints trade the pick. i'd happily trade pick 2 and 3 though, if someone offers up something good, I wonder if Peter Wright would tempt the dockers enough to throw up Neale or a couple of good players,
  14. Unethical? like the use of performance enhancing drugs... or when your day comes to answer the show cause notices going straight to court to get off on a technicality... or re-hiring the senior coach who oversaw the whole situation and has not shown a sign of remorse... should I keep going?
  15. I watched that game and sat there closing my eyes wishing we had taken Wines and it was all just a bad dream.
  16. I agree, it's a big risk, but I think Saints take McCartin mfc take Petracca GCS take Lever/ Durdin Lions take Wright Dogs take Durdin Blues take Marchbank mfc take Brayshaw there is a chance the teams above us will all feel the need for key position players is much higher than the need for Mids, and the 2015 by reports is chock full of quality mids which is a consideration
  17. Trade pick 3 for pick 7 and 15 and brayshaw could well slip to 7 anyway and we get Liam Duggan as a freebie
  18. I reckon port will beat hawks
  19. I think Picket Fence, WYL and a couple of other posters might have posters of Ollie on their walls, serious man crushes going on, just remember to put socks on the door handles while you guys are in there so no one walks in
  20. 2015 Jimmy needs to be holding down a regular spot in the senior side or he is gone imo, having said that the comparisions to Wines are pointless, it's like watching your ex girlfriend and new partner, feeling just get hurt, especially after he took freo apart last night in a big final. I still believe if Jimmy is given a really good pre season and a great run at it next year and can hold down a spot in the senior side he can develop into a good player for us, or if we decide to trade him we might get something alright in return, and he might blossom over in SA
  21. Last year when we were shopping around pick 2 the crows asked what would you want in return for pick 2, we said Sloane, B.Crouch or Dangerfield, the offered Vince and Mckernan
  22. Heard today that garland is up for trade if the right offer came along.
  23. Simon Goodwin has presented to the Melbourne football club board, no news on how it went but our board is making the decision on if he will be our New coach
  24. Imagine if Mitch was a Collingwood player, retired and then said he wanted to go to another club, just imagine what Eddie would do.
  25. It's all just opinion but I think like Anthony Miles he is a lot better than GWS think he is
×
×
  • Create New...