SPC

Over the last few weeks he has been.. Terrible kick and runs around in circles.. He is the worst player i have seen in a Melbourne jumper over the last 20 years. Big shout out to Shane Valenti.

Sorry for the question if it has been answered before- but was he playing any good before he was injured?

Yes you are

Aren’t they paid actors.. employees of Gil??

2 boys who missed with concussion are in.. as is Weid. Smith, Wagner and Stretch out

It’s a no for me...

It was a good fight after half time.. we are clearly undermanned and they are a class above.. it could have been 100 points. Some perspective needed. Year is done, so positives with Baker, Hore and Lockhart. Thought Fritch and Petracca played well.

Let’s be fair, we have 12 guys who shouldn’t be praying seniors out there today

Sign us up for 3

Have we got 9 players to come straight in

It’s attitude

Brayshaw VFL please, not chasing and tackling.. non negotiables

We have a spot for both of them. Both still poor one on one.. Frost is quick and keeps body contact, Hore reads it well in flight and kicks well.

Would like him as an assistant at Melbourne. He loves his players, is tactically sound, has done okay with some really poor lists.

If Salem doesn't play I will spew up.

He is good mates with Billy Stretch and probably just helped him keep his spot..

His form in the preseason game (I think against Brisbane) was poor. He didn't deserve a game.

Are we in 'no change' territory this week?

I like the new injury update format on the website.

No to Lever.. have we not learnt anything...

Appears limited as a footballer.. on another note, he can dunk and has a killer cross over dribble!

We have too many playing out of position IMO, some through necessity, some not too sure why..

Agree with the post. I have also conceded this year and want to build now for the next year and snag some good talent at the draft to complement the list. Minimal off season surgeries..

The midfield and forwards ruined his debut, turned the ball over in dangerous spots time and time again and left him exposed. He appears a very solid player.

Stretch played his last game for the club.. he will go out for Wagner.. no other change unless required.