DubDee

Freo are no doubt trying to negotate for something extra for Neale like a second rounder. good news is that every argument they use with Brisbane we can throw back in their face with Hogan

fair enough. I agree with all that - aside from trying Frost fwd again! ? not the end of the world in terms of our depth, but it is significant in terms of our high end talent

we didnt kick one goal in the first half! and the entire team played terribly. arguably the midfield was the worst on the day and cost us the most goals.

Pruess is a speculative pick. played 8 games for 5 goals and is apparently slow even for a big man. hopefully he can come on but we should not be banking on it

I'd prefer to keep our advantage we have up fwd rather than be like other teams

WC won every game this year when Kennedy/Darling played. They lost 6 when they didn't.

Yeah it is a worry but T Mac is pretty hardy aside from the foot issues. We played our best footy with 2 tall fwds and and I love that strcuture and flexibility we had up front. whichever way you slice it, losing Hogan would be a massive loss. from age 24-30 I reckon he will dominate the comp

Very highly rated junior 5th in the rising star in year 1 2nd bnf in year 2. Certainly better than his bro. He would excel in a good team imo

typical the FA starts working for the poor teams when we become good again!

When did May become a 'big fish'. The media are talking about him like he is Silvani good solid defender.

I don't think he is pivotal to our success, we are just a worse team without him in it. For example, his running/link play, field kicking. Weed/Tmac do not cover this. no doubt our defence needs work but not at the expense of our fwd line. I reckon he would kick 60+ over the next 7-8 years. we need to do everything we can to keep him but if he wants to go, not much we can do

Wait, say that again.

him playing in the 22 is a bit of a giveaway

Someone in the Sun asking is May worth 2 first round picks?!? has the world gone mad!? dont have a link, it was on the home page of superfooty

what is that 10+ players now that are out of here?? we better get busy in trade week! pick 121 might be getting used at the draft

fact or opinion? would love the cats to get screwed over and hit bottom

I don’t care what the BS manager talk is, no way he goes to north. Wtf would he? im confident he will come to us if we want him

can one of you accountants open a separate Tax thread on the general board for the love of all things holy!

didnt work for Rivers, Chip or Garland though. oh god they were dark times in all seriousness I think if O Mac builds up his body over the next 2 years he could make a decent fwd. better skills than Tom

once you factor in a mortgage, private health insurance, grocery prices, he won't have much left!

we are fked. Suddenly O Mac is training with the forwards!! :-0

if he wasn't injured he would have likely kicked 60 goals for the year and I would expect 70+ next year Weid showed very little in his first couple of years and played one great game a couple of decent games. He now shows promise but we cannot bank of him playing 22 games next year, he could be anything or a flash in the pan losing Hogan will have some short term pain for sure.

Anyone else worried about recruiting May? Everyone says he is proven but I don't think you are really proven until you have played for a decent side and have played in pressure situations - big crowds. May has done neither.

I agree, I don't think many want to trade him but it seems he wants to go back to WA so we are dealing with this potential reality

you do realise all of our best players have come from the draft? aside from Lever. if we can pick up another Oliver/Gus/Hogan then why not do it. they do not take long to have an impact and will extend our time at the top. our recruiting team have been amazing the last few years.