Demonsone

I wish someone could ask why no ruck contest in our f50 On 4-5 occasions??? Can he explain the disaster of the Grundy trade & why he wasn’t played whilst T Mac blew up & a fresh Shache sat on the pine, thanks for another unwanted record of 2 back to back straight sets exit!

Grundy would have been a great sub, very poorly handled

Unbelievable been @ Casey all season honestly Goody lost the plot

If they bomb it in we lose! Need to play trac fwd! The Grundy situation is embarrassing and feel for him, should be playing or what was the point and will go down as the most botched up trade ever. Club has gotten most trades right and can’t question the talent from late picks but this one will hurt & tarnish a few as it’s backfired

I thought Grundy was valued at our club??? Those words will haunt Goodwin & could go down as the biggest flop of a trade & only Melbourne could manufacture this! Can’t help injuries but if Gawn is on one leg who will be out back up ruck???

Just would luv to see them lose the prelim or gf

Was he on footy classified, hope he was roasted by Wilson

What a disgrace carrying on, people applauding, regardless of the afl decision shows no respect for Brayshaw!

Afl hidden agenda, makes a mockery of the match review as they took the deciding process away. A guilty verdict would have meant an appeal & would have suffocated the finals.

Most footy shows have shown the bombing issue in particular on the couch, ignoring going short to players with space, not using the corridor, also highlighted Gawn should look to handball out of the ruck as most of his kicks go to the opposition . Are they so obsessed on the defence game that they rather go long down the line as they can defend it? You need to kick goals win flags! This will cost them winning x other flag if they don’t change

This will/ has cost them winning another flag

On the couch analysis was spot on, the predictability of going long and ignoring shorter to players with space just allowed the defenders to line up, they continue to ignore the corridor and bang to a 1 vs 2, or 3 defenders. This surely isn’t Goody’s game plan, yet it’s been a nemesis of our team each season and yet they can’t fix it. Good observation about Gawn should look to handball to an on baller rather than kick which always goes to an opposition, a clip was shown an Oliver standing free waiting for the ball and Gawn kicked it & Oliver dropped his head probably saying Max I’m herd mate .

If Grundy isn’t played, then it reinforces the biggest trade blunder , he should have played against the pies over T Mac Io compete against Cameron & Cox and would have know their style.. must be played if you rolling the dice would you go with Grundy or Turner

Grundy has plenty of work ahead of him

One of the Toughest defender I’ve seen wear our jumper, the moment he took of with the cup… gold

Unfortunately this has been happening for a long time blazing away… not sure how this continues to happen with, it’s either dumb decision or our game plan is flawed

The crappy loses to Freo & Gws cost us 2nd spot …plus the continued bombing to 1 v 2, 3,defenders honestly own worst enemy

That’s more like it as Gawn said post match really felt like a typical Melbourne loss…

Brown is gone…. His knee is gone hasn't played at any level. Grundy will get picked with JVR missing

Yep Goody has been here before in 2022 and was a straight sets exit. May sound negative & sure always a change to beat Carlton as we do have the skill, but unless we get good quality inside 50s vs the bombing the result want change

Can’t look past next week against the blues but if we get through the lions will be a tough ask

Saints look gone but they should be playing at Marvel have given up home ground advantage, would the Afl make GWS to play at a different stadium if they were hosting a home final???

Bedford whilst given some opportunity in 22 along with many others from Casey were ignored in particular after the 1st final loss to the Swans & made no changes to play the Lions Hogan was gone mentally hence why Freo moved him on & Penny finally dropped & out pick 6 got May & rest is history

Injuries impacted but the bottom line is the bombing we do is suited for power fwds which can contest & either mark or bring to ground which we don’t have, we have hybrids trying to compete on 2vs1 and need to lower their eyes. The amount of times leads were ignored and free players is frustrating yet both Goody/coaches can’t get them to change this BS.

It’s our game plan, for multiple fw50 entries regardless of how good they are, we don’t have a power fwds the likes of the lions, cats, blues & expecting a young JVR and hybrids to take marks is unbelievable. Watching the game again and the continued ignoring of leads & free players to just wanting to bombing it in us simply dumb football . An issue which Goody can’t ignore & hasn’t been able to fix. It’s one thing to have a defence & contest mindset which is great but to not execute fw50 entries and not lower your eyes is simply poor … don’t want to hear how well we played as we didn’t!