samcantstandya

If I was Goodwin I'd drop him on tonight's performance. He can't pick and choose when he will go for the ball. The times he squibbed it, it wasn't as if he was going 2 get crunched. It's a bad look & he did it at leat twice in the last quarter. Trade or delist at end of year. He will let u down in big games. Players either are 100% committed or they're not & he isn't.

He only had 6 possessions last week. This week he kicked a couple but it's what he misses and doesn't do that irks me. He doesn't go when it's his turn. Gee compare him to Viney or Hunt who get clobbered. I'd trade or delist him he is 2 flakey In fact I'd get rid of JKH 2 he gets very nervous when he thinks contact is coming his way. Although strangely he loves 2 tackle. OMac either is tried as a forward or goes in2 the gym he gets ragdolled far 2 much.

Tom McDonald has gone from hero to zero in half a season.

Garlett dropped that mark in the pocket in the last quarter because he sensed that he might get contact he didn't & we missed an opportunity 2 get an easy goal. I am over him squibbing it. There was another time he didn't want 2 pick it up because he doesn't want contact. I feel JKH is the same. Tim Smith missed his goal because of pressure. Weed because he got 2 close 2 the man on the mark.

He is like a rabbit in headlights. That kick in2 the man on the mark - it was waist high. Earlier in the game had a snap from 35 & it fell 10 short. He lacks penetration with his kicking ways has. People criticise Spargo ' s kicking but Spargo is a better kick.

The only knock on Hannah is his set shot routine he needs 2 slow it down & keep it simple. Otherwise I like him he gives us that x factor in the forward half.

Someone like Hogan maybe???

Vanders needs 2b able 2 get on the park or else retire. Can't carry someone is permanently injured.

I'd wouldn't trade or delist him he'll be another Hunt in the 4ward line. It'd be madness 2 get rid of him when we have so many NQRs who offer nothing.

He is not above the team. He is fast becoming a liability on the field. He fumbles a lot and kicks blindly. He needs 2 earn his spot or play @ Casey.

I was 2. Jones needs to go 2 Casey

Names

We need 2b more composed letting Kennedy get that last goal breaks your heart in the last 90 secs. Oscar shouldve gone back on him. Jones & Garlett have fluffed so many kicks it's like Jones is purposely picking out West Coast players. If only them & Tom could kick straightforward

He got off last week when he shouldn't have, - now he's done it again - let's see how they get him off this time. Def a protected species like Dangerfield.

Bennell from WA

Sorry but I disagree with your assessment. JKH is pedestrian & o's like a deer in headlights. Has been a list clogger & unless he finds his niche position asap then he's goneski

We will be a better side when Lewis & Wagner r out. I would've dropped Wagner 4 Neal-Bullen.

Hawthorn moved him on so y is he still being gifted games. He said himself that this year he's prepared 2 play @ Casey so if the selection committee had any balls that's where he should be next week. I saw him also choose not commit when the ball was virtually at his feet - very disappointed with him at least Jones has a go.

Very wise words.

Can't wait 4 him 2 come back. Think he'll b that x factor we need in 4ward line. Him & Hannah can take screamers. He will b a gun as long as he stays fit

Time to become a line coach Jordan

Saw him choose to not tackle or harass on the boundary just let the opponent run past looked very casual no desperation even though the Dorks were surging into their forward 50 looked disinterested I had binoculars on it

That was blatant. The ump blew the whistle then a second later the Dork kicks it away but no 50m

I thought that he shouldve gone for a score

It happened right in front me. The umpire blew the whistle everyone man & his/her dog could c it was a free for incorrect disposal by hand by Scully yet as the umpire runs in the Hawk hero kicks a momgrel punt down the ground but no 50. The ump deneied us a certain goal. But earlier Oscar is a ml off the mark & Gunston gets a 50 from the wing a charity goal. Could've cost us the game.