samcantstandya

He will get stronger & be what Kennedy is 4 West Coast a reliable key position player.

I think u r right on the money Sherlock.

Frost 2 the wing.

Why is Hannah not under scrutiny?

The way I c it. 2019 was always going 2b a bust. More than a dozen preseason surgeries coupled with a late start due 2 finals. No prelim review & the new 666 rule. How we draft & recruit along with a change in game plan will determine our 2020. I think we will be a real threat next year if not then a rethink and a rebuild.

No. Petracca is a keeper.

Don't mean to be too critical but Hannan could've sealed the game by instead of having a bomb that just fell short he could've handballed the ball over the top to Brayshaw who was in the clear. Btw I reckon Gus got to it first & was denied the winner. That was def a review that should've been called.

Agree with u Red. JKH is like a deer and struggles 2 kick more than 30m. I've seen him fluff so many gettable goals & opportunities over the years. He's been on the list for more than 5 years & played 30 odd games. He is not quick & shirks contact. Gets beaten one on one 2 easily. Trade 2 Carlton.

Not AFL standard good VFL that's where he should stay not physical enough.

Y did they send him back on? Smacks of potentially another Joel Smith blunder.

T Smith will be kept.

Jones was ill-disciplined, we were about to receive a kick 4 goal. They ended up kicking one instead. Sure fly the flag but what he did was dumb.

Thought Tom showed promise would like 2c get games 4 his development. Jimmy (Hannan) looks underdone & Wags is not best 22, 2 slow & 2 vanilla.

Someone like Hogan

I would've kept Kent and delisted any combination if the 3. JKH & Garlett don't like contact & ANB can run but poorly skilled.

We should experiment & try some of our fringe players in different positions. OMac was a forward as a junior it might help me reignite his career.

May

How old is Josh???

Sorry but the team is bigger than the individual. I barrack for Melbourne players come & go. Whilst I'd b rapt 4 Jones 2 get 300 games & join Nieta, but only if his form warrants it. I don't want him gifted games. This year I've seen him fumble and run in quicksand. If he relinquishes the captaincy & concentrates on his own form he might be able 2 reinvent himself otherwise Casey or retirement beckon.

Right there on my tv

Best side 4 the year. Only missing arguably 5-6 players. Milkshake, Vanders, Jetta, maybe ANB, Preuss & J Smith (the x factor in 4ward half).

These r the reasons y I don't think Garlett should b in the side going 4ward. If he played the percentages & drew the player I would happily have him, but he will never do it so 4 me I'd rather play someone else who would. Garlett would break 2 many hearts if we ever made a Granny.

Agree on most, but thought Brayshaw & Petracca were ok. Harmes should've kicked that goal needs more composure.Someone needs to tell Hunt to slow down a couple of strides when on the run he'd be less eratic.

Summed up perfectly

JKH never wins a one on one contest. When he could of cleared the footy from the back pocket he looses his feet & they score an easy goal. He lacks composure he is VFL standard not AFL.