samcantstandya

Still a possibility that North beat Suns in Tassie.

Left field how about MacDonald at CHB at Smith forward

Contracted for 2024 I believe

Dorks would choose from Duursma, McKercher or Watson and we'd have a pick of the other 2 as I can see Freo's pick landing just after Dorks

Laurie is a great kick and very accurate when shooting for goal. I'd like to see him play HFF/FP

We would still get a very good quality player at 6 eg Nick Watson or a Caddy. Then at 18 & 23 we will get another good players think Rivers etc...

JJ is not impacting at all. For mine he is outside our best 22/23.

My kid played there last week, nice ground

The best player I ever saw. Great mark, brave and fair. Watching him run and bounce the ball was a thing of beauty.

Egan played 1 game for us, but happy for him to associated with Tigers especially if he's done shady stuff

So in effect we'd have to pay $200k to save $400-450 for a wasted trade. Then if Gawn gets injured we are stuffed.

Not so sure, if he was wanting to come to us, why did he sign on to 2025.

Like it

I think what we need is a contest and second and third efforts. Unfortunately Brown doesn't offer much if he's not marking the ball and last week he had zero marks in the F50.

We don't want Grundy to go unless we get a Godfather deal, because if Grundy goes Collingwood save $$$$$$$$.

Our recruitment team are one of the best in the league.

Brown, Tomlinson, Harmes & Laurie are contracted so they'd need to be traded or paid out.

Maybe Liam Henry (Freo) out of contract

Your opinion not mine. It's not bizarre at all. Brown is not performing. Smith can take a contested mark whereas Brown goes up with one arm half the time. Perhaps you should go to the game and watch it live.

Bowey in, Jordon out

Yep. He has an enormous vertical leap and will at least contest. Sure Brown is a very accurate kick, but he didn't take one mark in the F50 whereas Smith took one as soon as he got into position. Can't play on rep, must select on form.

Brown had a lot of opportunities but couldn't mark even when he was one on one. He was a liability, had he not been subbed off we would've lost.

Disappointing that Smith wasn't on at the start of the 4th. We lost our 4 goal buffer in the first 5 mins, before belatedly taking Brown off who was ineffectual. It was a very slow reaction and we can't afford to let the foot off the pedal in a final. We need to be more professional, Brown was the obvious change as Smith could play his role and mark, which he did as soon as he came on. Smith contested, Brown could not.

He didn't take a mark in the forward 50, but did have a goal assist. Disappointingly he goes up one handed too often when going for a mark and the ball rebounds too quickly.

If we could somehow trade to 1, great we take Reid. However, I really like Mckercher and one of Watson & Curtin if we can't trade up, but somehow trade into the top 10.