Brad Miller To Swans

[BlackBart 0]

Does our club have some sort of disease where they can't see how bad Miller is? It looks like sacking our coach can't even get the job done. Seriously he has NO football brain/ability unless u like indecisive and unreliable CHFs who slow down all your momentum, never kick goals and turnover the ball 9 times out of 10. I just hope that he gets traded...for ANYTHING or ANYONE. Otherwise we really are the MFC - Miller Football Club

[CURTIS 0]

Does our club have some sort of disease where they can't see how bad Miller is? It looks like sacking our coach can't even get the job done. Seriously he has NO football brain/ability unless u like indecisive and unreliable CHFs who slow down all your momentum, never kick goals and turnover the ball 9 times out of 10. I just hope that he gets traded...for ANYTHING or ANYONE. Otherwise we really are the MFC - Miller Football Club

2 examples, nico! and brent grirgc or whatever!

[beelzebub 23,313]

"required player " is my definition of football politics. Given that he's uncontracted, if CAC stated that he's on the market, the player feels unloved, and could put himself in the PSD. MFC get nothing for him.

couldnt agree more

[Gorgoroth 12,921]

As some one who had a lot of faith in miller, i must admit it has not been a good year and a bit for the man, he has not developed as well as i and many others expected, if we could get buchanen for him, i would take it.

On the other hand if he stays i would not be unhappy but would be expecting a major improvement off the man.

[Yze_Magic 3]

Goodbye Miller and Johnstone

Hello pick 11 and Amon Buchanan

[Grand Old Fox 0]

Miller needs to be off loaded before his market value reaches zero. He hasnt the skill to play as a marking forward and we all know how useless he is as a defender - apart from one lucky game on Barry Hall.

Potential is a dirty word and cannot be applied in Brad's case given the opportunties we've given him.

So long, [censored] truck...

[beelzebub 23,313]

To me the single biggest problem for Miller is he's a one trick pony...all he seems capable of doing is leading out ( and a long ways oout..lol ) to take a mark in a position which puts the forward line to disadvantage as its just slowed it all up !! Very mono-dimensional. The novelty of these has well passed its expiry date. Now maybe Bailey has something else to teach him.. ( but is he capable of learnig it ? )

I'd rather another team took that chance !!!

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Aaah. I think you misinterpreted. I think what I meant was that I'm annoyed we put six years into a guy who won't be as good as we'd hoped. I still think he could be Perrie-like... he certainly has the work ethic... but when you have the potential he had and you have 6 years and end up going backwards, it's just a sad state of affairs.

What else is he gonna say he's a piece of crap if you want him you can have him?

This is true. I think I expected him to just say nothing. It's the required player part that surprised me.

ok so we draft miller at pick 55, he proves he is a dud, and we get pick 27 for him? i'll be reasonably happy. i'll also be happy if he comes on at sydney because its obviously a lot between the ears down here.

Yes, we get a second rounder for a late pick, that all sounds fine and dandy, but we're also trading a KPP player that we developed for 6 years. Effectively we're giving them a known entity, and a grown man... I think the trade is fair personally. KPP players that have played the footy Miller has are thin on the ground.

[Yencks 8]

have a read of this, i hate to say it, i dont think miller is going anywhere..hopefully he will prove ppl wrong

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/Season2007/N...px?newsId=52109

[Grand Old Fox 0]

This is true. I think I expected him to just say nothing. It's the required player part that surprised me.

Yes, we get a second rounder for a late pick, that all sounds fine and dandy, but we're also trading a KPP player that we developed for 6 years. Effectively we're giving them a known entity, and a grown man... I think the trade is fair personally. KPP players that have played the footy Miller has are thin on the ground.

I love it how you dissect a mans post, Dan.

[beelzebub 23,313]

a little bit of tyre pumping I think you'l find !! ( adds to his value )

[Yencks 8]

Goodbye Miller and Johnstone

Hello pick 11 and Amon Buchanan

i'm all for this and i have stated that. CAC if you're watching!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i'd even be happy to get amon buchanan and a later draft pick

[deanox 9,897]

lest we forget the ties between miller and the new coach...

[Jaded No More 68,867]

lest we forget the ties between miller and the new coach...

No ties.

If you read the article on the website, it mentions nothing of Bailey ever coaching Miller at Mt. Gravat.

[beelzebub 23,313]

that was then...THIS IS NOW !!

[Pello 1]

I think the Miller detractors will eat their words. Putting aside our dearth of KPP's Miller is clearly a player who has lacked confidence in the past 2 -3 years. Previously he was aggressive and used his body to have a physical impact on the game. A couple of reports and loss of form resulted in his confidence going. This year he showed snippets of taking good pack marks and kicking long goals. I also think his decision making is improving.

I agree he has been deplorable down back. He is a forward and he needs to be coached well and once he regains his confidence and starts hitting the packs hard again you will see a different player.

Bailey is supposed to be a good teaching coach. Miller has the raw talent and potential to develop into a good CHF so the challenge is there for him. If he goes to the Swans and has success there will be a lot of red faces at the MFC.

I agree he has not developed as much as we thought he would and I think Daniher has a lot of explaining to do in that regard. He persisted with him in the backline where he was clearly out of his comfort zone. I would give him a one year contract (not two) and give him and Bailey a chance to resurrect his career. What is the worst that can happen - he has another bad year and is in and out of the team. Is that so bad given the potential upside and the fact that we have few KPP's anyway.

And on TJ - what is wrong with you guys? I can understand him being up for trade in an attempt to get Judd. But with a new coach and hopefully an attitude change to match TJ could be anyting. We have all been waiting for it to happen - the challenge is there to him and Bailey to achieve and not let another club benefit.

[deanox 9,897]

No ties.

If you read the article on the website, it mentions nothing of Bailey ever coaching Miller at Mt. Gravat.

he was senior oach at mt. g from 1997-1998. miller was drafted at the end of 2001. does anyone know how many years miller played seniors at mt.g? and is it possible that they had some contact with miller playing in the juniors?

[beelzebub 23,313]

au contraire..

I think the Miller detractors will be unfortuantely vindicated ( should he still be here for 08 )

what can he do 1)... lead out to the middl e of nowhere.. he's really good at that....nett effect.. slowing of attack..defocusses forward thrust. value 1/10. and the one is only because we have the ball !!

what can he do 2) he goes in all argy bargy ,head hunting...all Grrrr grrr and neanderthal !!.. ..net effect.. gives away frees, fronts tribunal. Value 0/10 and we dont even have ball.. well done !! lol

he cant ( or wont ) kick for sh!t.. has no dimensioanlity to his game..

on the upside...he has room for improvement...LOTS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Demon Disciple 12,064]

Goodbye Miller and Johnstone

Hello pick 11 and Amon Buchanan

I hear ya big time :D

But if the Swans are that stupid, why not throw Bruce in instead of TJ

[praha 11,234]

Wait a minute...we offered Miller a new contract?

[Yze_Magic 3]

Wait a minute...we offered Miller a new contract?

Nope

CAC said this to trick Paul Roos into thinking that Brad Miller has some value

Smart man

[Rodney Grunter 0]

It is widely known that we have a shallow draft approaching, and people want to trade Miller for 27? What a fu*king waste!

Might as well tie him to a deal for something constructive.

Personally, I think Miller has safe hands and can find the ball, he just has no ability to dispose of it. His kicking has let him down for so long, his reaction now is to instantly handball to the closest red and blue jumper (and often to trouble). I dont mind trading him, but you're a peanut if you want pick 27 in a rubbish draft.

[jacey 333]

It is widely known that we have a shallow draft approaching, and people want to trade Miller for 27? What a fu*king waste!

Might as well tie him to a deal for something constructive.

Personally, I think Miller has safe hands and can find the ball, he just has no ability to dispose of it. His kicking has let him down for so long, his reaction now is to instantly handball to the closest red and blue jumper (and often to trouble). I dont mind trading him, but you're a peanut if you want pick 27 in a rubbish draft.

27 for Miller.

I'll take that any day of the week. Hell i would even take 30's pick, even 40's.

[brey9186 102]

miller and 3rd rounder for amon buchanon

do it already

[Billy Baxter 0]

just opened the mfc website and the headline that jumped out at me is "2008 is Miller Time" WTF? Couldn't be bothered reading it........

Quote from the article Its Miller Time...."It’s only been four weeks, I’ve been taking it easy and putting the feet up.” he said.

“Probably over the next month it will get a bit more serious.”

WITH DEAN BAILEY ANNOUNCING PRE SEASON AT THE END OF OCTOBER AND THAT PLAYERS BETTER TURN UP FIT AND RARING TO GO, NOT QUITE THE COMMENT I WOULD HAVE EXPECTED. LOL