Was definitely a NO for the Dees 

But Cats will manage him and only need him on occasions!!! 

5 hours ago, old dee said:

Average player when fit. Out all of this year and probably a lot of 2025. Let's move on. 

Disagree. Elite with ball in hand. Has a good fitness base. He is our Myers if he can stay on the park. He's best 22 for mine.

So now Geelong have Martin, Stengle, Close and Miers.

 It looks like a new, post-Hawkins game plan to me.

21 hours ago, Demonland said:

 

Lucky to get a 2 year deal, I would have only offered him 1 year.

16 hours ago, Adam The God said:

Disagree. Elite with ball in hand. Has a good fitness base. He is our Myers if he can stay on the park. He's best 22 for mine.

If he can stay on the park? If you are not get on the park you as useful as me. 

1 hour ago, No. 31 said:

Lucky to get a 2 year deal, I would have only offered him 1 year.

Some people get 2 year contracts, some people get 4 year suspensions. It's a funny world.

Glad he's set at Geelong because I was genuinely anxious about him coming to Melbourne, providing close to nothing on field and continuing to be an off-field swamp at a third club.

12 hours ago, Little Goffy said:

Some people get 2 year contracts, some people get 4 year suspensions. It's a funny world.

Glad he's set at Geelong because I was genuinely anxious about him coming to Melbourne, providing close to nothing on field and continuing to be an off-field swamp at a third club.

Will be interesting to see if he can get fit and get a solid patch of consecutive games at Kardinia Park. Certainly has talent, not sure his body will hold up though.

Every time I read his name, I’ve got Rodney Rude’s voice in my head saying “Ray Martin, Ray Martin!”

On 01/11/2024 at 17:05, Adam The God said:

Disagree. Elite with ball in hand. Has a good fitness base. He is our Myers if he can stay on the park. He's best 22 for mine.

His career does not indicate he would be in our best 23 (not 22). He had the earmarks of a younger MacAdam all his career with some bad luck no doubt.
Needs to get really fit and hope for luck at a Club that seems to do the right thing by its players . 

1 hour ago, 58er said:

His career does not indicate he would be in our best 23 (not 22). He had the earmarks of a younger MacAdam all his career with some bad luck no doubt.
Needs to get really fit and hope for luck at a Club that seems to do the right thing by its players . 

Spargo is like McAdam? What are you talking about?

1 hour ago, Adam The God said:

Spargo is like McAdam? What are you talking about?

I am no fan but Spargo is way better than McAdam. McAdam is a sometimes reasonable VFL player. 

Edited November 4, 20241 yr by old dee