17 minutes ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

I'd rate Goodys tenure as

One great season - 2021

One good season - 2018

Three underperformed seasons - 2017, 2022-23

Four bad seasons - 2019-20, 2024-25

Two seasons out of nine where we went above par is not a good strike rate (especially considering he wasn't coming in at the start of the rebuild like most coaches do).

Forever thankful for the flag but besides the 2021 season I don't think he's got the most out of this list.

That’s a very fair summation Dr.

1 hour ago, SadDee said:

Heard that Goody is being discussed high up the table and it’s do or die…

Promise ?

Asking for a friend....

I also wanna know 😆

1 hour ago, Sir Why You Little said:

No we weren’t. Our accuracy was abysmal

Thank god that's changed .......

5 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Thank god that's changed .......

Incredible isn’t it….

2 hours ago, beelzebub said:

Promise ?

Asking for a friend....

I also wanna know 😆

🤞

14 hours ago, SadDee said:

Heard that Goody is being discussed high up the table and it’s do or die…

too late a s usual for MFC Damage done!

Talk about misery loving company.

This thread must in some way be cathartic for you guys ‘cause I’m reading the same shiite over and over and over and over again.

Either that or you just luv sticking the knife into anything MFC related. But that cannot be right because we all love the Dees don’t we!?

Please tell me what your intentions are next year when (if) Goody is still coaching us. Is this thread going to keep on keeping on for another year? If so I won’t be reading it. I value my sanity too much.

16 hours ago, Previously known as LITD. said:

Dropping out of two sets of finals without firing one due to poor kicking and aging fwds was bad enough.

Then eleven wins last year with still no improvement in the previous issues.

And this year will see even less wins with the same problems.

Definitely time for Goody to go and quite a few others including players.

We are tending down each year and on our way to a wooden spoon.

Bad enough to blow two years of double chances but what we have been serving up this year has been both sublime and atrocious.

Sadly mostly atrocious with our tallest forward averaging a hearty seven goals out of ten games with maybe a total of 17 for the year. Wth?

Oh but you can't say a bad word about our coach because some nuffy will come after you

1 hour ago, Neil Crompton said:

Talk about misery loving company.

This thread must in some way be cathartic for you guys ‘cause I’m reading the same shiite over and over and over and over again.

Either that or you just luv sticking the knife into anything MFC related. But that cannot be right because we all love the Dees don’t we!?

Please tell me what your intentions are next year when (if) Goody is still coaching us. Is this thread going to keep on keeping on for another year? If so I won’t be reading it. I value my sanity too much.

The Goodie acolytes will keep their Conga line going while those that care about the Club will work for what's best for the team.

11 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

Oh but you can't say a bad word about our coach because some nuffy will come after you

I do appreciate that he was good enough to win us a flag.

But we should have won two.

I believe that losing Melksham and Gus was a significant factor in both years.

That's not on Goody's head.

But our lack of depth of fwds and inaccuracy which contributed to our finals losses is.

And they have been ongoing for over three years now reflecting our current status.

We need an infusion of proactive coaching which involves making hard calls in cutting players and staff.

I don't feel Goody is mean enough.

In any case we will be lucky to string together 8 wins this year so surely a new coach can't hurt.

If something isn't done we will miss finals for a third year in a row.

19 hours ago, DubDee said:

we’re pretty much bottom 4.

i think people get it

No, Dub. People clearly don’t get it and that’s why we are reminded of it every five [censored] minutes. Oh and did you know we went out in straight sets in two consecutive years?! I know right… lucky for us this gets mentioned a million times a day or we might forget it. Happy clappers (like me) who luvs them a loss need constant reminding of the sad situation our club is in, and how Goody should be hanged, drawn and quartered.

Why do grown-[censored] people think that repeating something ad nauseam effects change? This is the domain of toddlers and old folks with dementia.

@Ghostwriter, you are banned from this thread - mainly for your own sanity - but also because every “happy clapper” that comes on here helps generate more of the same recycled shiite we’ve seen for the last 183 pages.

Enjoy your day.

1 hour ago, Neil Crompton said:

Talk about misery loving company.

This thread must in some way be cathartic for you guys ‘cause I’m reading the same shiite over and over and over and over again.

Either that or you just luv sticking the knife into anything MFC related. But that cannot be right because we all love the Dees don’t we!?

Please tell me what your intentions are next year when (if) Goody is still coaching us. Is this thread going to keep on keeping on for another year? If so I won’t be reading it. I value my sanity too much.

I value my sanity to the extent that if Goodwin is still coaching our club, I will retire from posting in this thread ,at the very least!

1 minute ago, Neil Crompton said:

@Ghostwriter, you are banned from this thread - mainly for your own sanity - but also because every “happy clapper” that comes on here helps generate more of the same recycled shiite we’ve seen for the last 183 pages.

Enjoy your day.

Problem is this, NC: if the disparagement of Goody was confined to this thread alone I’d be more than happy to eschew it. But just like the insidious disease that it is it’s spread to pretty much every thread thereby rendering this one no different to the others. Even the NON-MFC thread is contaminated every single week.

Edit: cue a post from the broken record (above)

2 minutes ago, picket fence said:

I value my sanity to the extent that if Goodwin is still coaching our club, I will retire from posting in this thread ,at the very least!

Do you promise????

3 minutes ago, Ghostwriter said:

Problem is this, NC: if the disparagement of Goody was confined to this thread alone I’d be more than happy to eschew it. But just like the insidious disease that it is it’s spread to pretty much every thread thereby rendering this one no different to the others. Even the NON-MFC thread is contaminated every single week.

Edit: cue a post from the broken record (above)

Haha See what I mean @Ghostwriter , they even have you repeating yourself over and over again. For the luv of god get off this thread now!

2 minutes ago, picket fence said:

I value my sanity to the extent that if Goodwin is still coaching our club, I will retire from posting in this thread ,at the very least!

I'm taking another sabbatical should Simon reign in 26.

That'll please many

Just now, beelzebub said:

I'm taking another sabbatical should Simon reign in 26.

That'll please many

First PF, now BB. Could today possibly get any better????? 🥳

Happy happy, joy joy 🎉

3 minutes ago, Neil Crompton said:

Haha See what I mean @Ghostwriter , they even have you repeating yourself over and over again. For the luv of god get off this thread now!

Ok I’ll get off this thread now. Both PF and Beelzebum have vowed to not post in this thread should Goody be our coach in 2026, which he will. I’m happy. 😁

25 minutes ago, Ghostwriter said:

First PF, now BB. Could today possibly get any better????? 🥳

Happy happy, joy joy 🎉

Be so much better if we just WON...and made it habitual.

Funny that many chide some for seemingly repetitive criticism...

And same folk gladly allow Goodwin to roll-out the same 💩 talk the same 💩 resulting in.... yep 💩

But that's fine.

Happy clappers might want to adjust their double standards.

I have one. Success.

31 minutes ago, Ghostwriter said:

Ok I’ll get off this thread now. Both PF and Beelzebum have vowed to not post in this thread should Goody be our coach in 2026, which he will. I’m happy. 😁

Ghosty.. i won't bother at ALL with dland if Goodwin is still coaching .

We'll be stuffed.

I am curious how season plays out and draft/trade. After that sayonara til he's gone.

Value my sanity and time more.

2 hours ago, Neil Crompton said:

Talk about misery loving company.

This thread must in some way be cathartic for you guys ‘cause I’m reading the same shiite over and over and over and over again.

Either that or you just luv sticking the knife into anything MFC related. But that cannot be right because we all love the Dees don’t we!?

Please tell me what your intentions are next year when (if) Goody is still coaching us. Is this thread going to keep on keeping on for another year? If so I won’t be reading it. I value my sanity too much.

Neil, you can continue to be positive about the same old team, not working, and losing.. some of us want to see change to hopefully come back up the ladder.

Ofc none of us enjoy this.

Once there’s a bit of success and we aren’t watching Groundhog Day, then we might be able to enjoy the team again, and won’t be required to rant about how many issues there are that seem to be swept under a rug.

37 minutes ago, Ghostwriter said:

Ok I’ll get off this thread now. Both PF and Beelzebum have vowed to not post in this thread should Goody be our coach in 2026, which he will. I’m happy. 😁

Don't worry I'm retired so I'll be happy to continue to post & hold Goodie the 🤡 to account.

7 minutes ago, SadDee said:

Neil, you can continue to be positive about the same old team, not working, and losing.. some of us want to see change to hopefully come back up the ladder.

Ofc none of us enjoy this.

Once there’s a bit of success and we aren’t watching Groundhog Day, then we might be able to enjoy the team again, and won’t be required to rant about how many issues there are that seem to be swept under a rug.

SD, don’t get me wrong. I think it’s time for a change - and I’ve said as much in this thread, and the reasons why. But I’ve only said it once. Surely that’s enough. Surely I don’t need to repeat myself over and over again, like so many on here do. This thread is Groundhog Day.

48 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Be so much better if we just WON...and made it habitual.

Funny that many chide some for seemingly repetitive criticism...

And same folk gladly allow Goodwin to roll-out the same 💩 talk the same 💩 resulting in.... yep 💩

But that's fine.

Happy clappers might want to adjust their double standards.

I have one. Success.

I for one will stfu if the team won games was competitive silenced the coaches bs press conferences and delivered a coherent game plan

Till then I will continue to push for change as soon as possible

If that's ok with HCs on here