I see a report Chris Burgess from GC has requested a trade to Adelaide....

1 hour ago, Travy14 said:

Could we do:

McAdam, Thilthorp

For

Sparrow, 2nd round?

A former pick 2 200cm KPF only 21 years old would command more at the trade table. McAdam is worth a third rounder. Thilthorp is worth a first. Sparrow and a 2nd is unders.

12 minutes ago, Lord Travis said:

A former pick 2 200cm KPF only 21 years old would command more at the trade table. McAdam is worth a third rounder. Thilthorp is worth a first. Sparrow and a 2nd is unders.

I agree with you, although I don't rate McAdam at all.

But they have asked for Sparrow, so might a good starting point to see how much.

Only issue is we look like losing a lot of midfield depth so adding Sparrow to that coukd leave us thin

If we got him we would have two former number 2 pick key forwards at around 200cm. Thilthorp leads left, Schache leads right and Petty marks in front.

3 hours ago, Travy14 said:

Could we do:

McAdam, Thilthorp

For

Sparrow, 2nd round?

To be honest Petty is the single best Hope we have of solving our forward line problems. 

I have no hesitation in saying he is/ will be a better player than McKsy Tilthorpe is still maturing and Lynch has been there done that. 

All our questions from D/Lers re Perry's injury should cool their jets and wait till he comes back. My opinion Harry is a better chance 7 years younger than Lynch at 31 with a season long foot problem. The karma of Tom  playing a Maynard role has come back to bite. 

No way should Harry be available for trade he is worth 2 of the Crows young forward flankers. 
 

2 hours ago, 58er said:

To be honest Petty is the single best Hope we have of solving our forward line problems. 

I have no hesitation in saying he is/ will be a better player than McKsy Tilthorpe is still maturing and Lynch has been there done that. 

All our questions from D/Lers re Perry's injury should cool their jets and wait till he comes back. My opinion Harry is a better chance 7 years younger than Lynch at 31 with a season long foot problem. The karma of Tom  playing a Maynard role has come back to bite. 

No way should Harry be available for trade he is worth 2 of the Crows young forward flankers. 
 

Petty is off limits.

And unfortunately I don't think he is our fwd line saviour.  As I think he needs to take May's position in the next couple of years.

Petty might have to do it for 12 months and then we have a crack at the plethora of key forwards coming out of contract next yr.

If only we had 2 fit Petty's

I love Petty Forward he is a natural, but somehow it seems to me that his body is not durable enough to play as a Key Forward for a whole campaign.

I would rather get a full season out of him as a CHB than a stop, start season as a Forward.

The option is there to swing him forward if the need arises.

8 hours ago, Robbie57 said:

I see a report Chris Burgess from GC has requested a trade to Adelaide....

supposedly to play key back with doedee leaving and murray off a knee, plus dragon himmelberg out the door, no idea how burgess goes as a back but fogarty walker and thilthorpe would still be ahead of him