Tj Injured- Broken Hand:

[Rivers Run Red 187]

I made a $150 bet with a mate that Melb would finish higher than Essendon on the ladder this year. Thought it was a safe bet at the time.

Did the same thing, Richmond and Essendon for 2 slabs each... :angry:

[Kiss of Death 755]

8 weeks for barts as well according to melbournefc...

[QueenC 74]

I made a $150 bet with a mate that Melb would finish higher than Essendon on the ladder this year. Thought it was a safe bet at the time.

You weren't alone in that opinion Gouga......

I made a very similar bet with my brother, who is a Bomber supporter and definite black sheep of the family !!!

There is quite a lot of beer on the line, with a monetary bonus for the winner when the two teams play each other.

[demon_fanatic 4]

liked the jumper Tj had on leaving the surgery lol hes such a dude ahaha... anyone know what it was... sure beats the metrosexual look brown riewoldt etc sport... and that mcphee

[Slartibartfast 17,625]

TJ is ok and seems set to play this weekend as reported in the Age.

[Bagdana 58]

Same deal for me. Beers on the line with a Essendon supporter. I'll just have to make sure that I get comfortable at his place until I get half of them back!!!

[classy dees 42]

Thankgod, first piece of good news for the season!

[Brocky For President 0]

it would be a good thing if he can play

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

TJ is ok and seems set to play this weekend as reported in the Age.

I'll believe it when I see it reported at mfc.com or on the footy show. The Age is often behind on these sorts of things.

[SJX 6]

They've updated that website:

Travis Johnstone hand injury Rnd 3 Rnd 4

Has been cleared of a fractured hand but may be in doubt for this week.

[Deestroy 0]

it would be a good thing if he can play

Nice avatar mate, I wonder where you got that from?

[Jaded No More 68,974]

I couldn't believe it when I read it this morning.

Thank god for that!

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

They've updated that website:

Travis Johnstone hand injury Rnd 3 Rnd 4

Has been cleared of a fractured hand but may be in doubt for this week.

Yep. Just saw it in the paper. Disregard my last post...

[Dreamin' Demon 10]

I made a $150 bet with a mate that Melb would finish higher than Essendon on the ladder this year. Thought it was a safe bet at the time.

I made a $100 bet with Hawks mate that we'd finish higher. I'm still confident.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,939]

MFC website says TJ has been cleared of a broken hand and is expected to play Sunday.

Sylvia (thigh) will be tested and could play his first game of the year for the seniors.

Suddenly things could be looking a little rosier.

Freo have M Johnson, Farmer, Peake, Schammer certainly out while Josh Carr and Headland are fronting the tribunal. Meanwhile Justin Longmuir is playing injured and Antoni Grover is a question mark as well.

Surely we'll be more competitive this week than Geelong.

[beelzebub 23,383]

it does beg the question.

if Trav has an injury to his hand...and he must otherwise why the scan etc... and others have noticed his concerns on play day. then are we ( well MFC ) risking exasperating this by playing him. is this an act of a prudent list mamangement ? or does it smack of desperation ? or is he suddently "all better" ?

For his own sake...id only want a reasoanbly fit TJ to play... no point making a bad situation worse.

[Gorgoroth 13,017]

i have a feeling he wont play, how often do we hear " he will play" but doesnt becuase the club is trying to keep the opposition guessing

i dont think he will play but im praying he is right and does play

[nomed 113]

Jared Rivers

Brent Moloney

Colin Sylvia

James Frawley

David Neitz

Brock McLean

Clint Bartram

Travis Johnstone

Russell Robertson

I wonder if we could come to the stage where we release some players from training and playing for the full year in order to completely recover.

You then tell younger players, right, you have 10, 15 or 18 rounds to learn the game and have a crack.

Or you line up Ooze, Bizzell, Holland, Wheatley, Ward, McDonald etal and say, right,its your last year, you are in for the season, give it everything you have.

Down sides:

Losing games

Over exposing young bodies and minds to rigours of senior football before they are ready

Damage player and team confidence

Bludging (players who know they are safe "coast")

Upsides:

Young players have the confidence to make mistakes, they learn from bad games

We get to see who has "it"rather than "potential"

Players with long term injuries get completely rested.

[QueenC 74]

Brent Moloney- Looks to either have suffered a strain or has had a recurrence of the soreness he experienced last season. Very unlikely to play this week.

Apropos and urrgh......

Moloney adds to Demons' wounded

By Greg Denham

April 18, 2007

AN epidemic of injuries is threatening to derail a winless Melbourne's season less than a month in.

The Demons' woes have deepened further with midfield player Brent Moloney likely to be sidelined for some time after aggravating his osteitis pubis.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/story/0,8659,2...4-23211,00.html

[Guest dee'viator]

Just heard that Tj has broken his hand... If this is the case were in more [censored] than a werribee Duck!!!!!

Johnstone given the all clear

1:07:00 PM Tue 17 April, 2007 | Back

melbournefc.com.au for Melbourne Football Club

News

Melbourne mid-fielder Travis Johnstone has been given the all clear to play on Sunday after undergoing precautionary on his wrist.

General Manager of Football Operations Chris Fagan said “He went in for an x-ray on the bottom of his hand and was given the ok. We expect him to line-up against Fremantle on Sunday”.

In other injury news for the Demons, Colin Sylvia will undergo a fitness test and is considered a chance to play his first game for 2007.

[Guest dee'viator]

Lets wait for some sort of official confirmation before we all go slash our wrists.

If proven to be correct, I'll be first in line.

:D confirmed that, Russell Robertsonhas a small crack

[Guest dee'viator]

Lets wait for some sort of official confirmation before we all go slash our wrists.

If proven to be correct, I'll be first in line.

:D confirmed that, Russell Robertson has a small crack

[Lord Travis 10,763]

Moloney out is a bad loss. He is just so passionate and has an impact out there even if he doesn't rake up 30 touches every week. Has been one of our best all year, even battling injury and fitness. Under-rated footballer IMO. With him, Brock, Sylvia, Pickett all out, TJ in average form and under injury cloud, Green not performing well in the midfield, Bruce not playing in the midfield, Junior having an average season....our midfield is really struggling. I marked it in as our strong point at the start of the year, but it is really being flogged. Has been beaten convincingly every match this year. Jones has been great for someone so young and inexperienced, winning a stack of clearances and making his presence felt. Apart from him, haven't been any other shining lights.

If TJ had been out for 6 weeks like originally suggested, I'd have said finals are gone. God I wish Brock was healed up already!