Jump to content


Recommended Posts

Posted

Rnd 12, 2020 Gabba - Demons vs Pies

Weighted Scores - Magpies

Player Score Rank
Brodie Grundy  3.900 1
Taylor Adams  3.725 2
Steele Sidebottom  3.500 3
Scott Pendlebury  3.075 4
Tom Phillips  2.925 5
Travis Varcoe  2.750 6
Darcy Moore  2.700 7
John Noble  2.575 8
Josh Daicos  2.300 9
Josh Thomas  1.950 10
Jack Crisp  1.925 11
Jack Madgen  1.900 12
Rupert Wills  1.550 13
Brayden Maynard  1.450 14
Jamie Elliott  1.400 15
Will H-Elliott  0.900 16
Callum Brown  0.900 17
Ben Reid  0.750 18
Darcy Cameron  0.675 19
Lynden Dunn  0.500 20
Trey Ruscoe  0.400 21
Brody Mihocek  0.000 22
Team Score 41.750  
Top 6 19.875  
Bottom 6 3.225  

# Hit outs to advantage not captured

Stats courtesy of footywire.com

Posted (edited)

Weighted Averages up to and including Rnd 12, 2020

Have included an extra column to show the adjusted performance from this year vs 2019 allowing for the 20% time reduction this season.

Player 2020 Weighted Score 2020 Rank 2019 Weighted Score % Change vs 2019 % Change vs 2019 w/ 20% time reduction 2019 Rank Change in Rank vs 2019
Clayton Oliver  3.986 1 4.643 -14.15 7.31 1 0
Christian Petracca  3.691 2 2.616 41.09 76.37 10 8
Max Gawn # 3.039 3 3.256 -6.66 16.67 4 1
Jack Viney  2.825 4 3.068 -7.92 15.10 5 1
Christian Salem 2.648 5 3.448 -23.20 -4.00 3 -2
Ed Langdon  2.605 6 - - - - -
Steven May  2.498 7 2.446 2.13 27.66 14 7
Angus Brayshaw  2.414 8 2.894 -16.59 4.27 6 -2
Tom Sparrow 2.338 9 1.075 117.49 171.86 37 28
Michael Hibberd  2.218 10 2.124 4.43 30.53 20 10
Braydon Preuss # * 2.150 11 1.521 41.35 76.69 33 22
Jake Lever  2.075 12 2.313 -10.29 12.14 17 5
James Harmes  2.052 13 3.850 -46.70 -33.38 2 -11
Nathan Jones 1.871 14 2.711 -30.98 -13.73 8 -6
Oscar McDonald 1.825 15 1.877 -2.77 21.54 26 11
Harley Bennell 1.790 16 - - - - -
Alex N-Bullen  1.683 17 1.984 -15.17 6.04 21 4
Tom McDonald # 1.654 18 2.150 -23.07 -3.84 19 1
Jay Lockhart  1.636 19 1.660 -1.45 23.19 31 12
Mitchell Hannan 1.625 20 1.325 22.64 53.30 36 16
Sam Weideman 1.614 21 1.818 -11.22 10.97 27 6
Bayley Fritsch  1.600 22 2.641 -39.42 -24.27 9 -13
Adam Tomlinson # 1.582 23 - - - - -
Trent Rivers 1.388 24 - - - - -
Luke Jackson # 1.354 25 - - - - -
Aaron Vandenburg 1.350 26 - - - - -
Neville Jetta  1.305 27 2.264 -42.36 -27.95 18 -9
Charlie Spargo 1.242 28 1.375 -9.67 12.91 35 7
Jake Melksham  1.182 29 1.931 -38.79 -23.49 23 -6
Joel Smith 1.158 30 - - - - -
Toby Bedford * 1.150 31 - - - - -
Kysaiah Pickett  1.142 32 - - - - -
Jayden Hunt 0.858 33 1.958 -56.18 -45.22 22 -11
Mitchell Brown * 0.625 34 - - - - -
Average Team Score -Top 22 49.837   59.623 -16.41 4.48    

# Hit outs to advantage not captured

* One match only, not an average

Stats courtesy of footywire.com

Edited by Rusty Nails

Posted

Road to Finals / GF - Triple Crown Update (to Rnd 12, 2020)

Vs the Pies

  • Meters Gained Differential (looking for + 200 or more) ? +628 ✔️
  • Marks inside 50 Differential (any positive is a win but the higher the better) ? +5 ✔️
  • Contested Possession Differential (looking for a +10 or greater) ? -2

Season Averages (the ones that count)

Get ready, get set, we are finals bound fellow minions!   :goody:

  • Meters Gained Average Differential (looking for an average of + 200 or more) ? +204 ✔️

Up from +162 last week and into +200 territory for the first time this season!  Retaining No.4 spot.  Cats replacing the Power at No.1 The Lions dropping out of 5th place moving to 7th, replaced by the Doggies.  The top five with current ladder positions in parenthesis below.

           Top five ? 1.  Cats 345 (3rd)  2. Port 317 (1st)  3. Tigers 298 (6th)  4. Demons 204 (8th)  5. Bulldogs 131 (10th)

  • Marks inside 50 Average Differential (ideally we need to see a top 6 ranking) ? 3rd ✔️

Holding at 3rd with a slight improvement from last week's +2.2 average to 2.5

           Top five ? 1. Cats  2. Lions  3. Demons  4. Power  4. Tigers

  • Contested Possession Average Differential (looking for +10 or more) ?  +7.7

This one isn't quite as strong as the first two in terms or correlation and somewhat of a bonus but we remain in the top 3 which is still a very good indicator we are on track on this measure.  Dropping one place to 3rd and still below the required pass rate but worth noting that no team has hit the required pass mark on this yet.  Down from +8.7 last week to +7.7 

            Top five:   1. Cats  2. Pies  3. Demons  4. Power  4. Kangas

  • Like 1
Posted

Cats are looking good on the field and in the stats.  They were still a hard-to-believe $11 for the flag after smashing the Saints, they've come in from that after bashing PA.  I'd like to get them in a final though, I think we scare them.

  • Like 2
Posted (edited)

Rnd 13, 2020 Metricon - Dogs vs Demons

Team score, allowing for this season's 20% less game time, was 8% off the 2019 season average and 18% lower than 2018's.

Clarry tops the statistical tables again with May not far behind.  Fritta down the other end for the first time this season punished somewhat by his turnovers exceeding effective possessions.  AVB not far behind and has been sitting at or near the bottom since his return against the Crows.  His best result 19th against the Roos in Rnd 11.

Turnover kings today were Viney with a whopping 9 followed by Tracc with 7.  On the up side Viney lead the score involvements with 6, closely followed by Melk, Clarry, Pruess and the Weid with 5 a piece.  As a side note Tomlinson had 14 effectives today at 100% efficiency with zero turnovers.  Not too shabby.  Lever topped the intercepts with 12, Harmes the next best with 7.

Player Score Rank
Clayton Oliver  3.750 1
Steven May  3.425 2
Angus Brayshaw  3.200 3
Jake Lever  3.150 4
Adam Tomlinson  3.125 5
Christian Salem  3.050 6
Ed Langdon  2.725 7
Christian Petracca  2.250 8
James Harmes  2.225 9
Jack Viney  2.125 10
Michael Hibberd  1.725 11
Jake Melksham  1.600 12
Braydon Preuss # 1.450 13
Charlie Spargo  1.375 14
Sam Weideman  1.300 15
Kysaiah Pickett  1.250 16
Tom Sparrow  1.150 17
Mitchell Hannan  1.000 18
Tom McDonald # 0.975 19
Jay Lockhart  0.925 20
Aaron Vandenberg  0.600 21
Bayley Fritsch  0.525 22
Team Score 42.900  
Top 6 19.700  
Bottom 6 5.175  

# Hit outs to advantage not captured

Stats courtesy of footywire.com

Edited by Rusty Nails
  • Like 1

Posted
10 hours ago, Rusty Nails said:

Rnd 13, 2020 Metricon - Dogs vs Demons

Team score, allowing for this season's 20% less game time, was 8% off the 2019 season average and 18% lower than 2018's.

Clarry tops the statistical tables again with May not far behind.  Fritta down the other end for the first time this season punished somewhat by his turnovers exceeding effective possessions.  AVB not far behind and has been sitting at or near the bottom since his return against the Crows.  His best result 19th against the Roos in Rnd 11.

Turnover kings today were Viney with a whopping 9 followed by Tracc with 7.  On the up side Viney lead the score involvements with 6, closely followed by Melk, Clarry, Pruess and the Weid with 5 a piece.  As a side note Tomlinson had 14 effectives today at 100% efficiency with zero turnovers.  Not too shabby.  Lever topped the intercepts with 12, Harmes the next best with 7.

Player Score Rank
Clayton Oliver  3.750 1
Steven May  3.425 2
Angus Brayshaw  3.200 3
Jake Lever  3.150 4
Adam Tomlinson  3.125 5
Christian Salem  3.050 6
Ed Langdon  2.725 7
Christian Petracca  2.250 8
James Harmes  2.225 9
Jack Viney  2.125 10
Michael Hibberd  1.725 11
Jake Melksham  1.600 12
Braydon Preuss # 1.450 13
Charlie Spargo  1.375 14
Sam Weideman  1.300 15
Kysaiah Pickett  1.250 16
Tom Sparrow  1.150 17
Mitchell Hannan  1.000 18
Tom McDonald # 0.975 19
Jay Lockhart  0.925 20
Aaron Vandenberg  0.600 21
Bayley Fritsch  0.525 22
Team Score 42.900  
Top 6 19.700  
Bottom 6 5.175  

# Hit outs to advantage not captured

Stats courtesy of footywire.com

Thanks, Rusty.  You know the sort of day it was when May, Lever and Tommo all are near the top of the pops. 

Posted (edited)
5 hours ago, buck_nekkid said:

Thanks, Rusty.  You know the sort of day it was when May, Lever and Tommo all are near the top of the pops. 

No Worries BN.  Just can't seem to take that step up to the next level above the shoulders eh.  They have some talent and decent players but far too often just fail to show up on match day once the opposition up the ante a little.  Some of those kicks yesterday, into the man on the mark multiple occasions and kicking scrubbers to the opp on others.  Fritta's inexplicable non-tackle on English costing us a goal.  Fritta playing on and kicking it to "someone" who just wasn't even an option or may have even been running away from him towards goal with back turned (i think), ball turned over and ends up in their forward line (can't recall if they scored or not).  Gus did something similar at one point.  No poise when needed, too many brain farts.  Amature hour stuff.

Smacks of a team that just isn't hungry enough right across the board and/or just can't handle AFL level pressure (with a few notable exceptions in general and on the day).  Too little left to too few far too often to take the next step also.  We are capable against the sub par clubs / teams but don't cut it so well against anyone from about 10th place upwards.

Really feel for blokes like Maxy, Clarry and Tracc.  Even May and Hibb this season, who give it their all most weeks but are continually let down by blokes who just can't seem to go (or maybe couldn't be bothered going) to the next level.  Then there's the coach & FD.  I'm sure they're getting alot right but i'm just not sure they're capable of getting the best out of this group.

After 3.5 seasons we keep getting beaten by teams who are fairly fast in general (but that's what AFL brings now and has for decades!) using a game style that sees them spread with skills / leg speed away from congestion and just hungrier for longer far too easily far too often.

And when are we going to learn that when we're on a good thing you stick with it!?? ie., Viney plays less time in the middle, more time forward bringing Gus into more mid field time?  Worked beautifully the week before.  But no, let's go back to Viney this week and stuff the whole balance / system up...and this is not the first time!  How many times have we thought we are on to a good set up / balance since SG started only to see it thrown out again a few weeks later....back to our awful type once again.

Then there's AVB & Sparrow on a wing.  Now i love ANB and certainly not expecting much from Sparrow given he's a rookie but come on.  We have to be better than this in a place on the park where you need mobile marking options with run and carry ability.

Not throwing the baby out just yet but it's very very close and i reckon this week is this group's final chance (under SG) to turn a corner and make a fist of it coming into finals in a strong way.  Lose this one and the spotlight's really gonna be on the Coach and FD as well as a bunch of players that just aren't able to cut the mustard.

Edited by Rusty Nails
  • Like 2

Posted
11 hours ago, Fanatique Demon said:

Thanks again, Rusty.

Interesting to see Weideman rated similarly to Spargo and Pickett. I thought he was far better than they were.

I saw that with interest, too.  I think it’s a case of different players needing different ratings, May was sensational, but midfielders who were average still beat him statistically.  Weids led and marked well, and kicked 2 goals.  Would say he did more than enough to be in the good books.  Spargo struggled to get involved, and Pickett had another ‘nearly’ game in q1, gave away silly frees, then tackled hard in the last.

statistics inform, but you only ever learn what you set out to measure.

  • Like 2
Posted (edited)
12 hours ago, Fanatique Demon said:

Thanks again, Rusty.

Interesting to see Weideman rated similarly to Spargo and Pickett. I thought he was far better than they were.

 

1 hour ago, buck_nekkid said:

I saw that with interest, too.  I think it’s a case of different players needing different ratings, May was sensational, but midfielders who were average still beat him statistically.  Weids led and marked well, and kicked 2 goals.  Would say he did more than enough to be in the good books.  Spargo struggled to get involved, and Pickett had another ‘nearly’ game in q1, gave away silly frees, then tackled hard in the last.

statistics inform, but you only ever learn what you set out to measure.

Agreed re Sam having a somewhat better match vs the other two when watching the game.  The weighted score does capture this (just) with Kozzie but not with Spargo (just).  As pointed out by BN, statistically things can come out slightly differently vs what actually occurs on match day in terms of the importance of a player's disposal / involvement / output and effect on the result.  Often it can be little things that don't even get picked up ie., some stats are either dubious or the publicly available ones don't / can't capture all of the nuances that we see take place.

Nonetheless, i have to agree with these two assessments and it could (probably was) the weakness of the model itself.

Taking a look at the penalty imposed for turnovers that goes in to the final weighted scores.  I've backed it off, marginally, and this may be the tonic needed without changing the core basis of the model nor the rest of the pecking order in a significant way.

Hey nobody's perfect and there's always room for improvement so thanks for the constructive scrutiny fellas.

The new weighted ratings table, including the above minor tweak, below. 

Player Score Rank
Clayton Oliver  3.800 1
Steven May  3.525 2
Angus Brayshaw  3.400 3
Jake Lever  3.250 4
Christian Salem  3.200 5
Adam Tomlinson  3.125 6
Ed Langdon  2.875 7
Christian Petracca  2.600 8
Jack Viney  2.575 9
James Harmes  2.325 10
Michael Hibberd  2.025 11
Jake Melksham  1.650 12
Braydon Preuss # 1.550 13
Sam Weideman  1.500 14
Charlie Spargo  1.375 15
Kysaiah Pickett  1.300 16
Tom McDonald # 1.175 17
Tom Sparrow  1.150 18
Mitchell Hannan  1.100 19
Jay Lockhart  1.075 20
Aaron Vandenberg  0.850 21
Bayley Fritsch  0.775 22
Team Score 46.200  
Top 6 20.300  
Bottom 6 6.125  

# Hit outs to advantage not captured

Stats courtesy of footywire.com

 

Edited by Rusty Nails

Posted
36 minutes ago, Rusty Nails said:

 

Agreed re Sam having a somewhat better match vs the other two when watching the game.  The weighted score does capture this (just) with Kozzie but not with Spargo (just).  As pointed out by BN, statistically things can come out slightly differently vs what actually occurs on match day in terms of the importance of a player's disposal / involvement / output and effect on the result.  Often it can be little things that don't even get picked up ie., some stats are either dubious or the publicly available ones don't / can't capture all of the nuances that we see take place.

Nonetheless, i have to agree with these two assessments and it could (probably was) the weakness of the model itself.

Taking a look at the penalty imposed for turnovers that goes in to the final weighted scores.  I've backed it off, marginally, and this may be the tonic needed without changing the core basis of the model nor the rest of the pecking order in a significant way.

Hey nobody's perfect and there's always room for improvement so thanks for the constructive scrutiny fellas.

The new weighted ratings table, including the above minor tweak, below. 

Player Score Rank
Clayton Oliver  3.800 1
Steven May  3.525 2
Angus Brayshaw  3.400 3
Jake Lever  3.250 4
Christian Salem  3.200 5
Adam Tomlinson  3.125 6
Ed Langdon  2.875 7
Christian Petracca  2.600 8
Jack Viney  2.575 9
James Harmes  2.325 10
Michael Hibberd  2.025 11
Jake Melksham  1.650 12
Braydon Preuss # 1.550 13
Sam Weideman  1.500 14
Charlie Spargo  1.375 15
Kysaiah Pickett  1.300 16
Tom McDonald # 1.175 17
Tom Sparrow  1.150 18
Mitchell Hannan  1.100 19
Jay Lockhart  1.075 20
Aaron Vandenberg  0.850 21
Bayley Fritsch  0.775 22
Team Score 46.200  
Top 6 20.300  
Bottom 6 6.125  

# Hit outs to advantage not captured

Stats courtesy of footywire.com

 

Absolutely not have it a dig at you Rusty.  I am so appreciative of what you do each week.  Highly valued.  Just calling out that any model measures what it measures.  It also doesnt take into account individual bias, television coverage or the BT drivel factor.  But I think your approach gives a grounded way to review performances and when the model is consistent, we can see changes between performances and discuss what we have seen. Cheers

  • Like 1
Posted
34 minutes ago, buck_nekkid said:

Absolutely not have it a dig at you Rusty.  I am so appreciative of what you do each week.  Highly valued.  Just calling out that any model measures what it measures.  It also doesnt take into account individual bias, television coverage or the BT drivel factor.  But I think your approach gives a grounded way to review performances and when the model is consistent, we can see changes between performances and discuss what we have seen. Cheers

Certainly didn't take it as that Buck.  Your feedback / input always valued.  No harm in posing the questions and having a healthy debate / discussion.  I'm also always looking to fine tune regardless, at least where/when i can see a pattern of anomaly arising and i think it was warranted here.

  • Like 1
Posted

Random question but is there anywhere that has the biggest range of stats with every stat possible? 

I was trying to find our what our record was with scoring from forward 50 stoppages and can't find it anywhere.  

Posted
On 8/24/2020 at 11:51 PM, layzie said:

Random question but is there anywhere that has the biggest range of stats with every stat possible? 

I was trying to find our what our record was with scoring from forward 50 stoppages and can't find it anywhere.  

There is Layzie but it's under Champion Data's copyright so no chance we will ever get stats that drill down to that level.  There's a little in the Hun on a Monday such as pressure acts and hit outs to advantage but otherwise nothing publicly available.

  • Thanks 1

Posted (edited)

Weighted Average Scores - Rnd 11 through Rnd 13, 2020

 

 

There are arguably better Zep songs out there than this.....but none more appropriate for our boy Clarry.  Rain, hail or shine, hat's off,  this bloke keeps delivering the goods.  Ok he's had his dinky handball phase and a few other question marks over his short journey so far.  But let's face it, we'd be struggling somewhat in the mid without this bloke's consistency and manic attack on the ball.  He's now adding another component to his game on the burst and getting to the outside seemingly with more damaging kicks happening.  Let's hope he continues on his merry way and he gets plenty of support from his mates coming in to finals.

Gus, Ed and Jake the snake all pushing up as well in this last block of three matches.  Yes only one match to go on but not a bad output from the two rookies Trent & LJ at this early stage.  Let's hope LJ can make it back firing in time for finals.

The team score in this block is off the charts compared to the previous block.  Yes there were two easy pickings among these numbers but you don't average 17% higher vs the previous season and approx 25% vs the previous block of three matches (from Rnds 8 to 10) without getting some major lift in form from a significant number of players.  We are also tracking the average 2018 team score in this block.

While there's no certainty in life and certainly none in footy i would say we are a very good chance, maybe 70% or so, of making finals here.  Being the 2nd highest scoring team behind the Cats in the second half of matches this season should help if we can get back on the winner's list this week.  Defence looking very solid also.  Big game coming up after the disappointment against the Dogs.

Player Rnds 11 to 13 Weighted Score Rank 2019 Weighted Score % Change vs 2019 % Change vs 2019 w/ 20% time adjusted 2019 Rank Change in Rank vs 2019
Clayton Oliver (3) 4.875 1 4.880 -0.10 24.87 1 0
Angus Brayshaw  (3) 4.033 2 3.131 28.81 61.01 6 4
Ed Langdon (3) 3.592 3 - - - - -
Christian Petracca (3) 3.492 4 2.843 22.83 53.53 9 5
Christian Salem (3) 3.450 5 3.658 -5.69 17.89 3 -2
Jake Lever (3) 2.775 6 2.519 10.16 37.70 16 10
Steven May (3) 2.758 7 2.618 5.35 31.68 14 7
Michael Hibberd (3) 2.583 8 2.339 10.43 38.04 19 11
Trent Rivers (1) * 2.550 9 - - - - -
Jack Viney (2) 2.275 10 3.258 -30.17 -12.71 5 -5
Luke Jackson (1) * # 2.275 10 - - - - -
Adam Tomlinson (3) # 2.250 12 - - - - -
Tom Sparrow (2.3) 2.192 13 1.275 71.92 114.90 37 24
James Harmes (3) 2.183 14 4.039 -45.95 -32.44 2 -12
Nathan Jones (2) 2.163 15 2.907 -25.59 -6.99 7 -8
Tom McDonald (3) # 1.917 16 2.297 -16.54 4.32 20 4
Sam Weideman (3) 1.917 16 1.895 1.16 26.45 27 11
Braydon Preuss (2) # 1.875 18 1.643 14.12 42.65 33 15
Charlie Spargo (3) 1.867 19 1.513 23.40 54.25 35 16
Jake Melksham (3) 1.650 20 2.181 -24.35 -5.43 21 1
Mitchell Hannan (2) 1.588 21 1.433 10.82 38.52 36 15
Bayley Fritsch (3) 1.550 22 2.809 -44.82 -31.03 10 -12
Kysaiah Pickett (3) 1.467 23 - - - - -
Jay Lockhart (2) 1.325 24 1.819 -27.16 -8.95 30 6
Aaron Vandenburg (3) 1.108 25 - - - - -
Average Team Score -Top 22 55.810   59.623 -6.40 17.01    

# Hit outs to advantage not captured

* Only one match played ie., not an average score

Numbers in parentheses = number of games played for this data set

Stats courtesy of footywire.com

Edited by Rusty Nails
Posted
9 minutes ago, Rusty Nails said:

Weighted Average Scores - Rnd 11 through Rnd 13, 2020

 

 

There are arguably better Zep songs out there than this.....but none more appropriate for our boy Clarry.  Rain, hail or shine, hat's off,  this bloke keeps delivering the goods.  Ok he's had his dinky handball phase and a few other question marks over his short journey so far.  But let's face it, we'd be struggling somewhat in the mid without this bloke's consistency and manic attack on the ball.  He's now adding another component to his game on the burst and getting to the outside seemingly with more damaging kicks happening.  Let's hope he continues on his merry way and he gets plenty of support from his mates coming in to finals.

Gus, Ed and Jake the snake all pushing up as well in this last block of three matches.  Yes only one match to go on but not a bad output from the two rookies Trent & LJ at this early stage.  Let's hope LJ can make it back firing in time for finals.

The team score in this block is off the charts compared to the previous block.  Yes there were two easy pickings among these numbers but you don't average 17% higher vs the previous season and approx 25% vs the previous block of three matches (from Rnds 8 to 10) without getting some major lift in form from a significant number of players.  We are also tracking the average 2018 team score in this block.

While there's no certainty in life and certainly none in footy i would say we are a very good chance, maybe 70% or so, of making finals here.  Being the 2nd highest scoring team behind the Cats in the second half of matches this season should help if we can get back on the winner's list this week.  Defence looking very solid also.  Big game coming up after the disappointment against the Dogs.

Player Rnds 11 to 13 Weighted Score Rank 2019 Weighted Score % Change vs 2019 % Change vs 2019 w/ 20% time adjusted 2019 Rank Change in Rank vs 2019
Clayton Oliver (3) 4.875 1 4.880 -0.10 24.87 1 0
Angus Brayshaw  (3) 4.033 2 3.131 28.81 61.01 6 4
Ed Langdon (3) 3.592 3 - - - - -
Christian Petracca (3) 3.492 4 2.843 22.83 53.53 9 5
Christian Salem (3) 3.450 5 3.658 -5.69 17.89 3 -2
Jake Lever (3) 2.775 6 2.519 10.16 37.70 16 10
Steven May (3) 2.758 7 2.618 5.35 31.68 14 7
Michael Hibberd (3) 2.583 8 2.339 10.43 38.04 19 11
Trent Rivers (1) * 2.550 9 - - - - -
Jack Viney (2) 2.275 10 3.258 -30.17 -12.71 5 -5
Luke Jackson (1) * # 2.275 10 - - - - -
Adam Tomlinson (3) # 2.250 12 - - - - -
Tom Sparrow (2.3) 2.192 13 1.275 71.92 114.90 37 24
James Harmes (3) 2.183 14 4.039 -45.95 -32.44 2 -12
Nathan Jones (2) 2.163 15 2.907 -25.59 -6.99 7 -8
Tom McDonald (3) # 1.917 16 2.297 -16.54 4.32 20 4
Sam Weideman (3) 1.917 16 1.895 1.16 26.45 27 11
Braydon Preuss (2) # 1.875 18 1.643 14.12 42.65 33 15
Charlie Spargo (3) 1.867 19 1.513 23.40 54.25 35 16
Jake Melksham (3) 1.650 20 2.181 -24.35 -5.43 21 1
Mitchell Hannan (2) 1.588 21 1.433 10.82 38.52 36 15
Bayley Fritsch (3) 1.550 22 2.809 -44.82 -31.03 10 -12
Kysaiah Pickett (3) 1.467 23 - - - - -
Jay Lockhart (2) 1.325 24 1.819 -27.16 -8.95 30 6
Aaron Vandenburg (3) 1.108 25 - - - - -
Average Team Score -Top 22 55.810   59.623 -6.40 17.01    

# Hit outs to advantage not captured

* Only one match played ie., not an average score

Numbers in parentheses = number of games played for this data set

Stats courtesy of footywire.com

on that you would think that Harmes Jones and Fritta are well below expectation and should be dropped

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Kent said:

on that you would think that Harmes Jones and Fritta are well below expectation and should be dropped

Harmes must be borderline but imv i just think he is being asked to play a role he just doesn't get this late in his career.  He's been a run with / part time mid / winger who pushes forward to stretch his opponent and mark/ maybe kick the odd goal in the past.  I would reset him this weekend on a shut down (not necessarily heavy lockdown) role on Steele who is presently the Saints most prolific ball winner.

This makes complete sense now with Sparrow out imo.  Rivers comes in to cover Harmes.

The only option i can really see if Fritta is dropped is Bedford and i'm just not sure he will be ready for such a big match.  If you are bringing him in for Fritta then i can't see him playing out Fritta's role in the air.  On the ground sure.  And he probably won't play the entire match out. It's possible but you will need others to drift forward and help out in the air like AVB, Harmes, Tracc and Clarry.  As well as on the ground once his tank peaters out probably about 2/3rds of the way through.  Maybe let Hannan & AVB share this role early.  Once AVB's legs are gone chasing....then bring Bedford in to cover the Saints defensive smalls in the second half with Hannan along with our other two smalls, Kozzy & Spargo.

Could even consider dropping AVB for chunk to play that same role in the first half as he appears to be in better form than AVB at the moment (subject to a fitness test of course).

Edited by Rusty Nails

Posted
3 hours ago, Rusty Nails said:

There is Layzie but it's under Champion Data's copyright so no chance we will ever get stats that drill down to that level.  There's a little in the Hun on a Monday such as pressure acts and hit outs to advantage but otherwise nothing publicly available.

That might have to do for now, cheers Rusty!

  • Like 1
Posted

Footy is about scoring. We seem to have a spread which is good but I’d love to have a key forward who kicks those vital goals in tough close matches. 
 

This year we have (after 12 games) 

Fritsch 17 goals

Weideman 16 goals 

Melksham 15 goals 

Only players in double figures. 
 

I know it’s a lean year but have to get more mids kicking goals or contributions from Pickett, Vandenburg, Bennell, Hannan etc. and Tom McSpud

Posted
On 8/9/2020 at 4:18 PM, Rusty Nails said:

G'day Nascent.  This didn't come up on my reply feed for some reason so apologies for the delay.

I have explained this once before already but it was some time back and i can't find the response.  Anyway, i've inserted the answers to your questions above ?  Hope this helps make a bit more sense of things.

I have said previously that it's a fantastic source and find your comments well considered.

I am reminded of the old "data is not information, information is not knowledge, knowledge is not wisdom, continuum" which confuses many arguments.

Posted
3 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Footy is about scoring. We seem to have a spread which is good but I’d love to have a key forward who kicks those vital goals in tough close matches. 
 

This year we have (after 12 games) 

Fritsch 17 goals

Weideman 16 goals 

Melksham 15 goals 

Only players in double figures. 
 

I know it’s a lean year but have to get more mids kicking goals or contributions from Pickett, Vandenburg, Bennell, Hannan etc. and Tom McSpud

If only we could find that magic bean SNS.  I'm still not sure it lies within the present list.

Posted
1 hour ago, dpositive said:

I have said previously that it's a fantastic source and find your comments well considered.

I am reminded of the old "data is not information, information is not knowledge, knowledge is not wisdom, continuum" which confuses many arguments.

Haven't heard that one Dp.  I've heard a few such as "rubbish in rubbish out" or "Some individuals use statistics as a drunk man uses lamp-posts — for support rather than for illumination".  Sometimes i'm a bit of a boozer!

  • Like 1
Posted

Weighted Averages up to and including Rnd 13, 2020

Player 2020 Weighted Score 2020 Rank 2019 Weighted Score % Change vs 2019 % Change vs 2019 w/ 20% time adjusted 2019 Rank Change in Rank vs 2019
Clayton Oliver  4.200 1 4.880 -13.93 7.58 1 0
Christian Petracca  3.821 2 2.843 34.40 68.00 9 7
Max Gawn # 3.194 3 3.437 -7.07 16.16 4 1
Jack Viney  3.030 4 3.258 -7.00 16.25 5 1
Christian Salem 2.852 5 3.658 -22.03 -2.54 3 -2
Ed Langdon  2.781 6 - - - - -
Steven May  2.721 7 2.618 3.93 29.92 14 7
Angus Brayshaw  2.642 8 3.131 -15.62 5.48 6 -2
Michael Hibberd  2.341 9 2.339 0.09 25.11 19 10
Jake Lever  2.269 10 2.519 -9.92 12.59 16 6
James Harmes  2.208 11 4.039 -45.33 -31.67 2 -9
Tom Sparrow 2.150 12 1.275 68.63 110.78 37 25
Nathan Jones 1.979 13 2.907 -31.92 -14.90 7 -6
Oscar McDonald 1.925 14 1.956 -1.58 23.02 26 12
Adam Tomlinson # 1.894 15 - - - - -
Braydon Preuss # 1.875 16 1.643 14.12 42.65 33 17
Harley Bennell 1.850 17 - - - - -
Alex N-Bullen  1.783 18 2.120 -15.90 5.13 22 4
Tom McDonald # 1.675 19 2.297 -27.08 -8.85 20 1
Sam Weideman 1.675 19 1.895 -11.61 10.49 27 8
Jay Lockhart  1.650 21 1.819 -9.29 13.39 30 9
Bayley Fritsch  1.640 22 2.809 -41.62 -27.02 10 -12
Mitchell Hannan 1.634 23 1.433 14.03 42.53 36 13
Trent Rivers 1.575 24 - - - - -
Luke Jackson # 1.463 25 - - - - -
Aaron Vandenburg 1.438 26 - - - - -
Charlie Spargo 1.388 27 1.513 -8.26 14.67 35 8
Jake Melksham  1.371 28 2.181 -37.14 -21.42 21 -7
Neville Jetta  1.355 29 2.264 -40.15 -25.19 18 -11
Joel Smith 1.292 30 - - - - -
Kysaiah Pickett  1.283 31 - - - - -
Toby Bedford * 1.250 32 - - - - -
Jayden Hunt 0.908 33 2.092 -56.60 -45.75 23 -10
Mitchell Brown * 0.775 34 - - - - -
Average Team Score -Top 22 52.155   59.623 -12.53 9.34    

# Hit outs to advantage not captured

* One match only, not an average

Stats courtesy of footywire.com

Posted (edited)

Road to Finals / GF - Triple Crown Update (to Rnd 13, 2020)

Vs the Bulldogs

  • Meters Gained Differential (looking for + 200 or more) ? -359
  • Marks inside 50 Differential (any positive is a win but the higher the better) ? +3 ✔️
  • Contested Possession Differential (looking for a +10 or greater) ? +2

Season Averages (the ones that count)

Did i say we were finals bound last week!?? :huh:  Still a bit of work to do!

  • Meters Gained Average Differential (looking for an average of + 200 or more) ? +157

Down from +204 last week but still holding No.4 spot.  Tiger's replacing the Power at No.2  The top five with current ladder positions in parenthesis below.

           Top five ? 1.  Cats 371 (3rd)  2. Tigers 306 (5th)  3. Power 293 (1st)  4. Demons 157 (9th)  5. Bulldogs 148 (8th)

  • Marks inside 50 Average Differential (ideally we need to see a top 6 ranking) ? 3rd ✔️

Holding at 3rd with the same average of +2.5

           Top five ? 1. Cats  2. Lions  3. Demons  4. Tigers  5. Power  6. Eagles

  • Contested Possession Average Differential (looking for +10 or more) ?  +7.2

Holding in 3rd place with the average slipping slightly from +7.7 last week.  Below the required pass rate but no team has hit the required pass mark yet.  The Kangas have slipped out of the top 5 being replaced by the Blues at No.4 & the Power slipping from 4th to 5th.

            Top five:   1. Cats  2. Pies  3. Demons  4. Blues  4. Power

Edited by Rusty Nails
  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Demonland Forums  

  • Match Previews, Reports & Articles  

    2024 Player Reviews: #7 Jack Viney

    The tough on baller won his second Keith 'Bluey' Truscott Trophy in a narrow battle with skipper Max Gawn and Alex Neal-Bullen and battled on manfully in the face of a number of injury niggles. Date of Birth: 13 April 1994 Height: 178cm Games MFC 2024: 23 Career Total: 219 Goals MFC 2024: 10 Career Total: 66 Brownlow Medal Votes: 8

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 3

    TRAINING: Wednesday 13th November 2024

    A couple of Demonland Trackwatchers braved the rain and headed down to Gosch's paddock to bring you their observations from the second day of Preseason training for the 1st to 4th Year players. DITCHA'S PRESEASON TRAINING OBSERVATIONS I attended some of the training today. Richo spoke to me and said not to believe what is in the media, as we will good this year. Jefferson and Kentfield looked big and strong.  Petty was doing all the training. Adams looked like he was in rehab.  KE

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Training Reports

    2024 Player Reviews: #15 Ed Langdon

    The Demon running machine came back with a vengeance after a leaner than usual year in 2023.  Date of Birth: 1 February 1996 Height: 182cm Games MFC 2024: 22 Career Total: 179 Goals MFC 2024: 9 Career Total: 76 Brownlow Medal Votes: 5 Melbourne Football Club: 5th Best & Fairest: 352 votes

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 6

    2024 Player Reviews: #24 Trent Rivers

    The premiership defender had his best year yet as he was given the opportunity to move into the midfield and made a good fist of it. Date of Birth: 30 July 2001 Games MFC 2024: 23 Career Total: 100 Goals MFC 2024: 2 Career Total:  9 Brownlow Medal Votes: 7 Melbourne Football Club: 6th Best & Fairest: 350 votes

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 2

    TRAINING: Monday 11th November 2024

    Veteran Demonland Trackwatchers Kev Martin, Slartibartfast & Demon Wheels were on hand at Gosch's Paddock to kick off the official first training session for the 1st to 4th year players with a few elder statesmen in attendance as well. KEV MARTIN'S PRESEASON TRAINING OBSERVATIONS Beautiful morning. Joy all round, they look like they want to be there.  21 in the squad. Looks like the leadership group is TMac, Viney Chandler and Petty. They look like they have sli

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Training Reports 2

    2024 Player Reviews: #1 Steven May

    The years are rolling by but May continued to be rock solid in a key defensive position despite some injury concerns. He showed great resilience in coming back from a nasty rib injury and is expected to continue in that role for another couple of seasons. Date of Birth: 10 January 1992 Height: 193cm Games MFC 2024: 19 Career Total: 235 Goals MFC 2024: 1 Career Total: 24 Melbourne Football Club: 9th Best & Fairest: 316 votes

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 2

    2024 Player Reviews: #4 Judd McVee

    It was another strong season from McVee who spent most of his time mainly at half back but he also looked at home on a few occasions when he was moved into the midfield. There could be more of that in 2025. Date of Birth: 7 August 2003 Height: 185cm Games MFC 2024: 23 Career Total: 48 Goals MFC 2024: 1 Career Total: 1 Brownlow Medal Votes: 1 Melbourne Football Club: 7th Best & Fairest: 347 votes

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 5

    2024 Player Reviews: #31 Bayley Fritsch

    Once again the club’s top goal scorer but he had a few uncharacteristic flat spots during the season and the club will be looking for much better from him in 2025. Date of Birth: 6 December 1996 Height: 188cm Games MFC 2024: 23 Career Total: 149 Goals MFC 2024: 41 Career Total: 252 Brownlow Medal Votes: 4

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 9

    2024 Player Reviews: #18 Jake Melksham

    After sustaining a torn ACL in the final match of the 2023 season Jake added a bit to the attack late in the 2024 season upon his return. He has re-signed on to the Demons for 1 more season in 2025. Date of Birth: 12 August 1991 Height: 186cm Games MFC 2024: 8 Career Total: 229 Goals MFC 2024: 8 Career Total: 188

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 7
  • Tell a friend

    Love Demonland? Tell a friend!

×
×
  • Create New...