James Magner

[Biffen 12,947]

Jesus, no more photos of Mark Neeld. I just had a relapse

Scary isn't it.

He came highly recommended by Collingwood.

Garry Lyon "helped us out"with that one.

[rumpole 522]

Selective at best...

Quotes from the Sun....

"(Neeld) said he wasn't too happy with the defensive side of my game and I had just had a meeting with the midfield coach prior to meeting who said to me they were extremely happy with defensive side of my game.

"There were a few things that were confusing at Melbourne, but I was a lot more confused that day."

and

"He says he never had words or disagreements with senior coach Neeld, but clearly "the relationship deteriorated" from Neeld's end."

Its inexcusable in a winning or losing side. And Magners issues were not isolated. This has been typical across the playing group.

So you keep telling us, often, ad nauseum and obsessively.

[DemonFrog 1,356]

Jesus, no more photos of Mark Neeld. I just had a relapse

LOL

Let us Never forget what can happen if we get the wrong man!

I have so many more photos for you mate.

I know it painful but without pain we will never fully recover

But here is some more uplifting photos for you.

Bring on 2014.

[Machsy 2,858]

In his very own words Magner stated that Mark Neeld told him why he was dropped after round 9 yet people still claim that Neeld did not communicate properly with his player. Those who have a knowledge and a working experience of football clubs where you can only fit 22 into the main team from a list of in excess of 40 will know that these things are commonplace. It happens at successful clubs but the atmosphere is different because the team is winning.

Fair dinkum. They need to put a bubble over this picture with the caption "I told him I wasn't happy with the defensive side of his game".

Magner was under a temporary rookie uplift at the time and he was due to return to that status within a few weeks. He didn't have priority over the team interests but sadly at this club, we developed a soft[censored] attitude over the years that will continue to haunt us unless we get over some of the stupidity expressed in some quarters over this story.

Neeld communicated with the player, but it seems he didn't communicate with his line coach to make sure the message to the player was consistent. Maybe this is one of the things Royal-banshees had been long searching for?

A solid reason why he should've been given the sack a long time ago!

Who knows? But the mixed messages are there, if you believe Magner.

As you say, Magner clearly didn't understand the gravity of his own situation, that being a temporarily upgraded rookie who was giving an average output at AFL level.

I'd say he got some exposure at AFL level, but not enough to really understand what it took to succeed at that level, overestimating his ability to do that.

[Biffen 12,947]

Neeld communicated with the player, but it seems he didn't communicate with his line coach to make sure the message to the player was consistent. Maybe this is one of the things Royal-banshees had been long searching for?

A solid reason why he should've been given the sack a long time ago!

Who knows? But the mixed messages are there, if you believe Magner.

As you say, Magner clearly didn't understand the gravity of his own situation, that being a temporarily upgraded rookie who was giving an average output at AFL level.

I'd say he got some exposure at AFL level, but not enough to really understand what it took to succeed at that level, overestimating his ability to do that.

Why would anyone listen to Royal at all,ever.

Especially given the results he was getting.

Still-gen Y are wagging the dog at other clubs and they were here.

The last of the gen x crew tried to sack the admin also.

GenX should have shown genY how to behave.

They ended up getting a discipline man like Neeld because the leaders wouldn't take control of the youth.

What a mess.

[Disco Demons 92]

Reality is we will forget about him after round one

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

So you keep telling us, often, ad nauseum and obsessively.

Some people like you need to be told often.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Neeld communicated with the player, but it seems he didn't communicate with his line coach to make sure the message to the player was consistent. Maybe this is one of the things Royal-banshees had been long searching for? .

Hardly Royals fault if Neeld did not communicate with line coach????

[Demonsterative 3,020]

So you keep telling us, often, ad nauseum and obsessively.

Some people like you need to be told often.

The point in rumpoles post RR was to 'shut up!!'

I thought you needed this pointed out to you again!!!

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

The point in rumpoles post RR was to 'shut up!!'

I thought you needed this pointed out to you again!!!

Try following your own advice and take a well earned hike.

And I trust you don't have to be told often.

[Mgdee 322]

Hardly Royals fault if Neeld did not communicate with line coach????

It's also possible that Royal was not listening to Neeld and not sticking by the party line.

A bit like when Dad says No and then Mum says Yes because it is non confrontational.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Possible but proof?

[Demonland 73,161]

Try following your own advice and take a well earned hike.

And I trust you don't have to be told often.

That'll do thanks.

This is a forum and he has a right to say what he said.

You are not a moderator and have no right to tell him to take a hike.

I am and you can take this as a warning. Let's try keeping things civil and on topic please.

And I trust you don't have to be told again.

[Sir Why You Little 37,134]

LOL

Let us Never forget what can happen if we get the wrong man!

I have so many more photos for you mate.

I know it painful but without pain we will never fully recover

But here is some more uplifting photos for you.

Bring on 2014.

I know that Blonde Lady with the 2 girls....The family absolutely bleed for this club....i remember seeing this in the paper..

Made me shed a couple of tears myself and get angry.

[Demonsterative 3,020]

I know that Blonde Lady with the 2 girls....The family absolutely bleed for this club....i remember seeing this in the paper.. Made me shed a couple of tears myself and get angry.

Sad sights indeed WYL. Lets hope such losses are behind us all.

[DemonFrog 1,356]

I know that Blonde Lady with the 2 girls....The family absolutely bleed for this club....i remember seeing this in the paper..

Made me shed a couple of tears myself and get angry.

The picture stood out to me as they appeared to be truely hurt by the Teams performance.

This is the type of supporters we all should love.

Pity our teams was so bad in 2013 and the previous six seasons.

[Mgdee 322]

Possible but proof?

As much proof as you have that Neeld didn't convey his message to Royal.

I was not saying that was the case just pointing out there are two possibilities.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

As much proof as you have that Neeld didn't convey his message to Royal.

I was not saying that was the case just pointing out there are two possibilities.

I was going on what Machsy said.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

That'll do thanks.

This is a forum and he has a right to say what he said.

You are not a moderator and have no right to tell him to take a hike.

I am and you can take this as a warning. Let's try keeping things civil and on topic please.

And I trust you don't have to be told again.

So would it be appropriate to direct Demonstrative's original response at me to you?

[Sir Why You Little 37,134]

The picture stood out to me as they appeared to be truely hurt by the Teams performance.

This is the type of supporters we all should love.

Pity our teams was so bad in 2013 and the previous six seasons.

They are still well and truly on board.

I have met them at the Wharf Hotel a couple of times.

[Demonland 73,161]

Yes.

[Demonland 73,161]

Not guilty.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Thanks for conforming the double standard on civility. Much appreciated.

[brey9186 102]

I can see Brian royal as the old bloke who doesn't know how to dial on his iPhone let alone check his emails..

[Carrot Top 947]

Thanks for conforming the double standard on civility. Much appreciated.

Lol. How does that medicine taste?