Although I am writing this from New York, wasn't Sellar one of the best for Casey last weekend? (And didn't he kick multiple goals in one of our rare wins for the year during the NAB Cup?)

your right

hows ny treating you mate, and are you missing home

Although I am writing this from New York, wasn't Sellar one of the best for Casey last weekend? (And didn't he kick multiple goals in one of our rare wins for the year during the NAB Cup?)

Yes but the point about Sellar stands that he is a very good VFL or Preseason footballer who I think struggles mentally and mightily come AFL game day. The dropped marks that he'd take every day at training are his biggest issue otherwise he'd have nailed down the forward/ruck spot. Lacks the speed for down back I think.

Craig is widely known as one of the good guys of the AFL as in he's true to his word. So maybe he could help Neeld in the fact that he refused to overrule or oppose him as aggressively as he might have wanted to. I think in some ways it's telling that PJ went for Craig. If he thought Neeld and Craig were truly a solid team spreading the same message I think he might well have elected Rawlings and sat Craig on the outer.

Let's wait and see what the results are like for the rest of the year. There were signs against St Kilda of improvement but against a side as bad as the saints you'll always look good in patches. Few predicted Craig would win the job at Adelaide when he took over caretaker did they?

I also think Craig can serve a purpose around the club under Roos or Eade. Possibly not Williams due to history of coaching against each other in a two team town. PJ stressed his desire to revamp the FD with experienced people. Whilst Craig might not fit clearly in his mind for a set position if we have to pay him out his 300k I'd rather have him around.

Darren Crocker at North has proven a very handy assistant coach who helped Brad Scott get the playing group on side when Brad won the job from Crocker as caretaker. With the right personalities it is achievable.

your righthows ny treating you mate, and are you missing home

Can't wait to get back but I suspect that 2013 was an inspired choice for an extended overseas trip during the football season. Hopefully 2014 will prove to be a year when I do not miss a Dees match with vastly improved performance from this year!

Although I am writing this from New York, wasn't Sellar one of the best for Casey last weekend? (And didn't he kick multiple goals in one of our rare wins for the year during the NAB Cup?)

Yep

and how is New York?

Absolutely believe he could be our man. Have seen first hand his relationship with the players. One of the main absolutes of being a good coach is the ability of having the players want to play and win for the coach. I see this in Neil. I just hope he wants it as bad as we may want him.

I have no idea who the best man is - I'm sure those making the choice will leave no stone unturned - but in regard to Craig, to pinch a quote from someone famous .. "I like the cut of his jib"

Should he be the best candidate, all power to him

Although I am writing this from New York, wasn't Sellar one of the best for Casey last weekend? (And didn't he kick multiple goals in one of our rare wins for the year during the NAB Cup?)

Club meetings/lunches now held in NY, CBD? I am sure you could find something slightly better to do in NY than reading Demonland.

Club meetings/lunches now held in NY, CBD? I am sure you could find something slightly better to do in NY than reading Demonland.

Is that possible?

Is that possible?

BF sorry wrong Club.

I think last night definitely adds a bit more weight to this argument. He has the players playing with a lot more freedom and flair straight away which is great to see. What really stands out is the presenting - it has improved tenfold and that stupid bombing long to packs has lessened, but still used when needed.

I wouldn't be disappointed at all if Craig ended up coach, he certainly seems to be able to interact with the players. Listening to Gawn post match last night on SEN, he remarked that Craig is the funniest bloke he's ever met. It's really good to hear these things as the communication seems to have stepped up a notch and the players definitely react to him.

Even if Craigy doesn't get the senior role, I do hope he stays at the club in some capacity.

You're worried about what Williams did at Port, but not what Craig did at Adelaide. Furthermore, Williams has been an awesome assistant whilst Craig failed to steer Neeld. Give him another 10 weeks, and then maybe.

LOL

Funniest thing I read in ages.

Neeld worst enemy was himself, it hard to advise someone who believes he knows it all.

I my opinion MW is too immature to be a Senior Coach.

I cant help be but happy with the performance of Neil Craig so far, since he was installed as care taker coach.

Just watching all his press conferences he is a great speaker, just sounds so much more inspiring and sells a future better than Neeld ever did. Im not surprised the players are responding to him.

If we improve further over the coming weeks, his coaching stocks will rise and then give the club something to think about.

Maybe if they are serious about a Roos, could Craig coach for another 12mths on a yearly contract, knowing he will hand over the reigns ?

Just throwing it out there, cause its looks unlikely Roos is ready this year.

Otherwise your looking at Williams or Eade.

If Neil wins this week end can he get the keys to the City?

If Neil wins this week end can he get the keys to the City?

He can have the city.

I'd say that it will take Craig two years to sort this group out.... Give him too years and then move him to footy manager..... We don't need a premiership coach yet.... Our players aren't ready....

The problem NC will have is if we win a few games against top sides and he puts his hand up Roos might put his hand up too thinking the list is better than he first thought. (Which it is).

If this situation was to arise who would we opt to go with?

Personally I think Craig will be better for the experience second time around.

If this scenario was to play out I'd prefer Neil Craig.

If NC is on a par with other select choices he automatically becomes the cheapest option. Might come into play , might not

If NC is on a par with other select choices he automatically becomes the cheapest option. Might come into play , might not

bb are you steeling my mind? god knows why you would

But I was just thinking the same thing.

He is contracted for next year so we pay anyway.

bb are you steeling my mind? god knows why you would

But I was just thinking the same thing.

He is contracted for next year so we pay anyway.

yepp

bb are you steeling my mind? god knows why you would

But I was just thinking the same thing.

He is contracted for next year so we pay anyway.

Great minds think alike, OD, so they say ...