Dunn, Macdonald, Sellar re-sign

[Nasher 33,246]

where does that leave clint bartram aswell? aperently he hasn't even been sighted at training?

Jetta, Bartram and Davis yet to sign.

[Its Time for Another 4,058]

I am sorry guys but I am also a supporter of MacDonald. He is a hard at it type and has a good presence. I personally consider that he has more consistency about him than Sellars and we must remember that the other two were first round draft picks.

His turnovers kill me. Will never be a supporter while that continues and it will. Not up to AFL standard. The day he goes will be the day you know MFC are starting to turn into a real AFL team.

[hardtack 10,187]

Bartram's retirement has probably saved one of MacDonald/Sellar. I really hope they now sign Jetta.

[nutbean 8,837]

I don't really think it was better than any other season, but whatevs. Each to their own.

I detest the disposal efficiency stat, so I see nothing in that.

Its a horrible stat - inside midfielders get crueled by it as they are always getting possies in tight and need to dispose quickly and that can impact the number. To me a backman's disposal efficiency ( especially since most teams play the extra man down back) should be better than an inside midfielder.

[Gippsland Dee 367]

good to see these 3 re commit to the club. I think Sellar definitely has his best footy ahead of him as he was gaining momentum and more confidence in his body the more he played.

Dunn is a good role player and has his games where he stands up really well. Macdonald is a back who we need imo as he is a big body and has the needed experience for the team.

[red and blue forever 807]

2pm tomorrow we will know the fate of davis and jetta pre the draft.

then I believe we can delist again before list lodgement 3 if we want to participate in the PSD so they both will probably be sweating until the 29th of november...

[titan_uranus 23,254]

Its a horrible stat - inside midfielders get crueled by it as they are always getting possies in tight and need to dispose quickly and that can impact the number. To me a backman's disposal efficiency ( especially since most teams play the extra man down back) should be better than an inside midfielder.

Agreed.

IIRC, a kick which misses the target but is later recovered by the target is also effective. It's just mindboggling.

[Pates 9,562]

Pretty much all depth players, Dunn may have a permanent role but Sellar and MacDonald should be stop gaps.

[bing181 8,359]

I detest the disposal efficiency stat, so I see nothing in that.

= I'd rather stick to my subjective opinion and ignore the facts??

[titan_uranus 23,254]

= I'd rather stick to my subjective opinion and ignore the facts??

Have a read of nutbean's post, then get back to me.

[Harrisonrules 273]

All inconsequential. Good VFL players that occassionally rise to the occasion.

[Deecisive 1,674]

we have pick 3 in the psd so will are likely to use that in preference to a high pick in the national draft.

[red and blue forever 807]

2pm tomorrow we will know the fate of davis and jetta pre the draft.

then I believe we can delist again before list lodgement 3 if we want to participate in the PSD so they both will probably be sweating until the 29th of november...

well list lodgement two is up.. now If i am right, we are unable to delist any players until after the draft up to list lodgement three (23rd-29th of november.) if we use all four picks 4.49.53 and 70 in the draft we may still see one of davis/jetta delisted to make a spot for pick3 PSD

Edited November 15, 2012 by red and blue forever