Who can forget David Maclashan (Sp) who played maybe on e game for us at Vic park and won the game for us. He only played because Mark Jackson was suspended.

Every time I met someone who played a game in the firsts Ive been rapt.

Always buy them a drink, guys!

I continually hope this type of post doesnt put off the old boys.

It seems to come up three times a year.

because even if you DO rate an old player, your dissing their mates.

Just keep it in mind. cheers.

moo kowal. for mine, still the worst player to play 100 games in the red and blue. had pace...shame he couldn't kick, mark, or handball.

You can't be a 5 minute wonder if you play 100 games.

What about His Royal Highness Prince Scott Chisholm?

He got involved with everitt and saw him carve up the crows at the MCG once.

Very hot and cold.

Does anyone remember Johnnie Howatt?

Didn't he subsequently ply his wares at Richmond?

Biffinator.

I really enjoyed the likes of:

Craig Smoker

Leigh Newton

Allan Jakovich

Matthew Collins

Darren Cuthbertson

Andrew Obst

Luke Sullivan

Rod Grinter

Marcus Seecamp

Sean Charles (was dynamite)

Andy "Chopper" Lovell

Remember Jay Viney? What about Brian Stynes?

Martin Pike before he made the trip north to QLD

Darren Bennett (boy could he kick a footy)

Am I showing my age? Not really, I'm under 29 mind you, just passionate about my boys.

Are you in the right thread Melbournefc? How can you consider the likes of Chopper Lovell, Darren Bennett, Balls Grinter, Andrew Obst, etc 5 minute wonders?????

Does anyone remember Johnnie Howatt?

Didn't he subsequently ply his wares at Richmond?

Biffinator.

I remember him and his ears, pretty sure he went to the Tiggers with Northey.

Not sure if this name has been mentioned but David Schwartz was talking about Tom Cavanagh (not sure on spelling), who was Brent Crosswell's son. Schwarter said he was freakishly talented but had some serious injuries which cut short his career.

I remember him and his ears

:D :D :D

GOLD! I remember those monsters too!!!!!

:D :D :D

GOLD! I remember those monsters too!!!!!

Not in "Strawbs" O'Dwyer's (pre-trim) league. I suppose the poor fella copped all the usual "Dumbo" and "taxi doors open" sledges. This is probably why Jeff White had his trimmed down.

anyone remember Trevor Spencer or Andy Goodwin donning the red and Blue?

How about Ted & John Fidge - Big wraps on both but neither delivered long term.

There was a guy we picked up from the Bulldogs late 80's. had a couple of big games then dissappeared.

I cant remember his name - Aidrian Campbell maybe? Wore No. 1

& of course Rocket Rod Owen - Played some decent footy for half a season early 90's b4 wrecking his knee.

Gee there are some major disappointments mentioned in these posts but Darren Cuthbertson is the one that really hurts. He was brought through the system after being zoned from Epping in a manner which suggested the Club saw him as a future star.He had a full season in the Twos and I recall him kicking 4 goals in a quarter in a final against Carlton reserves. He exploded on to the senior scene with 17 goals in 3 games including a b on g against Collingwood and a match winning 5 goals against Brisbane at the G.Then nothing;nothing at all. He had a short spell at Fitzroy and then returned to Epping.Robbie Walters kicked a couple of bags as a fast leading straight kicking full forward but his lack of size was always going to count against him .As an aside, he claimed at his sentence for larceny as a servant from the bank that his financial woes were caused by being delisted by Melbourne.So we get blamed for everything.The Cockatoo -Colins btothers were not disappointing because neither ever looked any good.A bit like the Rugolo brothers.The Cockies show how fortunate we are to have CAC and why Richard Griffiths is languishing with the QAFL

Richard Griffiths...ugh!

Wasn't Walters picked up by Collingwood after he was delisted by MFC? Was his claim that we payed him far in excess of what Collingwood did? I'm pretty sure that his brush with the law came after he was delisted by the filth.

I thought it was a free for all - what ever happened too. I think they should be included in this also!

By the way, I forgot to mention: Shaun Smith and Sean Wight.

I thought it was a free for all - what ever happened too. I think they should be included in this also!

By the way, I forgot to mention: Shaun Smith and Sean Wight.

Sorry mate you have really lost me now. Both those guys were fantastic, Wight for a number of years, a great brave FB. And Smith we picked up at a mature age and he gave us sensational service in a number of positions with better and more experienced players such as Shwarta and Lyon constantly injured

Charles ---Definitely not as good as Davey though.

Sean Charles was awsome when up and going. Physically strong and fast. Not afraid of anybody.

Think he suffered from osteoporosis, which resulted in multiple breakages of the wrist. Nasty. Bloody brave to play on with that arm guard with us then Carlton a year later.

Sean and Jeff Farmer were tandem teamed at full forward by Balme for some time, working from the square. A dismal failure.

I think I recall a final against Carlton where Sean Charles destroyed them almost single handed, he then repeated the dose a year later.

Reckon that Sean Charles also kicked 18 goals for a Sunraysia representative team a few years back. Not bad for an old man.

Does anyone remember a player by the name of David Hone, who played as an amateur ( or came from the amateurs ) and who was a brilliant and courageous standout immediately at centre half back, but then disappeared, virtually overnight ,possibly to continue his studies?

I do remember him but that season is more than forgetable,I think we only won 3 games in 1969 and took out the wooden spoon.

Every time I met someone who played a game in the firsts Ive been rapt.

Always buy them a drink, guys!

I continually hope this type of post doesnt put off the old boys.

It seems to come up three times a year.

because even if you DO rate an old player, your dissing their mates.

Just keep it in mind. cheers.

Are we actually mean't to understand what you have written?

Speak English

Viney JAY 1988, 1990-91 23 Games 4 Goals

Jay Viney returned to Adelaide and played a lot of footy for Sturt in the SANFL - captain for a while as well.

anyone remember Trevor Spencer or Andy Goodwin donning the red and Blue?

Trevor Spencer always gave the impression he had talent ...... but that was about it as far as results went. He just looked like he could take a game by the throat but never did.

Andy Goodwin is still going around - captain-coach of Mooroolbark where he is much loved but equally despised by most other clubs in his division of the EFL. Andy still has the occasional visit to the tribunal but I think his reputation is worse than his record. I believe he recently played in a Richmond corporate game where ex-players play alongside some of the club's sponsors. It's supposed to be a light-hearted exercise but apparently Goodwin's competitive instincts were still well-honed.

You have to admire Goodwin - never the most talented of players but gave everything he had whenever he went out to represent his club albeit occasionally going over the edge. If I recall correctly, he suffers from the additional handicap of being a Pom.

While we're playing this game mickey17seddon, do you remember Big Darryl Cox ? Another "couldabeen" we picked up from Fitzroy.

Trevor Spencer always gave the impression he had talent ...... but that was about it as far as results went. He just looked like he could take a game by the throat but never did.

Andy Goodwin is still going around - captain-coach of Mooroolbark where he is much loved but equally despised by most other clubs in his division of the EFL. Andy still has the occasional visit to the tribunal but I think his reputation is worse than his record. I believe he recently played in a Richmond corporate game where ex-players play alongside some of the club's sponsors. It's supposed to be a light-hearted exercise but apparently Goodwin's competitive instincts were still well-honed.

You have to admire Goodwin - never the most talented of players but gave everything he had whenever he went out to represent his club albeit occasionally going over the edge. If I recall correctly, he suffers from the additional handicap of being a Pom.

While we're playing this game mickey17seddon, do you remember Big Darryl Cox ? Another "couldabeen" we picked up from Fitzroy.

sadly enough I do remember Darryl Cox, got a few games towards the end of 84 when Barass was running out of big men and ideas. Can remember him wrestling with and niggling opponents but dont remember him getting a kick

Quote "Old Man Rivers"

"We had an aboriginal kid in the 70's that promised the world - Colin somebody or that may have been

his surname."

Colin Graham was a very talented aboriginal left-footer. I saw him in Adelaide in the rooms before the game v. the Crows in 2004,wishing "Flash" all the best. Presumably he still has an interest in the Demons, but lives over there.He'd been in a "good paddock"!

He played 35 games for the Demons from '75 to '78 after beig recruited from Kyabram(originally from Penola).

I have wondered for over 40 years what had happened to Glen Swann, mainly because I saw him play just one game but it was one of the most impressive I have ever seen (was it his debut?). Have asked around and checked the web over the years but no luck - great to see discussion of him and others on this message board.

As David Cordner was described previously, Swann was also a "blue blood blonder hair 6'4" adonis", whom I saw play at the MCG in 1973 and boot 8 goals. Moreover, I recall a number of them being torpedoes from 60-70 yards from near the boundary. Quite tall for those days and wonderfully fast and agile and a strong mark plus a monster kick. I assumed he must have gone off to the bush because there seemed no limit to his potential but perhaps he did just fizzle out.

Did anyone else witness his golden day at the 'G and those torps?

here another list that would qualify as 5 min wonders

Matty Collins and that massive arm tat

Ben Beams

Darren Kowal kicking long goal vs hawks