Most Improved Dee

[tooly 0]

We all know it has been a down year for the

Demons this year, but I love the improvement

from so many players this season who has

been the most improved player this year?

[Roost It 1,434]

We all know it has been a down year for the

Demons this year, but I love the improvement

from so many players this season who has

been the most improved player this year?

We've done this, it's Garland

[Chook 15,022]

There may be a thread on this a few pages back, but I'll answer anyway.

Brad Miller

I always thought he was a great leader whose talents and confidence were being destroyed by playing him way to far from goals. In my perfect Melbourne side, I'd make him Captain and plunk him at full forward. Not like a Fraser Gehrig, but pretty much as a center-half-forward who, when he takes marks, is actually some 35 meters closer to goal because of his closer starting point.

[titan_uranus 25,043]

I reckon CJ's also a chance if he keeps this form up.

[Cards13 9,117]

Based purely on stats it is Bucks

Name: Disposal Diff 07 to 08 (min 3games in 08)

Simon Buckley 8.55

Christopher Johnson 7.71

Matthew Whelan 7.23

Brock McLean 5.5

Brent Moloney 4.28

Colin Sylvia 3.69

Paul Johnson 3.69

Paul Wheatley 3.35

Matthew Bate 3.13

Brad Miller 2.95

Jeff White 2.65

Mark Jamar 2.6

Nathan Jones 2.5

Clint Bartram 2.24

Daniel Bell 1.4

James Frawley 1.31

Brad Green 1.07

Aaron Davey 0.98

Nathan Carroll 0.86

Cameron Bruce 0.38

Russell Robertson 0.33

Lynden Dunn -0.67

David Neitz -1.87

Michael Newton -1.97

Adem Yze -3.87

James McDonald -4.98

- Bruce is the leading player for both seasons with a slight increase this season

- Junior has dropped the most by almost 5 disposals a game

- Brock increased his output by 5.5 disposals a game

- Newton ave less than last season. I think if my calculations are correct we are ave 11 less inside 50's a game

[Doggo 32]

We've done this, it's Garland

Yep. By a mile...

[H_T 3,049]

Based purely on stats it is Bucks

Name: Disposal Diff 07 to 08 (min 3games in 08)

Simon Buckley 8.55

Christopher Johnson 7.71

Matthew Whelan 7.23

Brock McLean 5.5

Brent Moloney 4.28

Colin Sylvia 3.69

Paul Johnson 3.69

Paul Wheatley 3.35

Matthew Bate 3.13

Brad Miller 2.95

Jeff White 2.65

Mark Jamar 2.6

Nathan Jones 2.5

Clint Bartram 2.24

Daniel Bell 1.4

James Frawley 1.31

Brad Green 1.07

Aaron Davey 0.98

Nathan Carroll 0.86

Cameron Bruce 0.38

Russell Robertson 0.33

Lynden Dunn -0.67

David Neitz -1.87

Michael Newton -1.97

Adem Yze -3.87

James McDonald -4.98

- Bruce is the leading player for both seasons with a slight increase this season

- Junior has dropped the most by almost 5 disposals a game

- Brock increased his output by 5.5 disposals a game

- Newton ave less than last season. I think if my calculations are correct we are ave 11 less inside 50's a game

Your stats are up the creek without a paddle................................................it misses players such as Garland

Most Improved

Answer: GARLAND

[Dee man 303]

Garland should win, but he has a lot of competition.

Warnock - has been equally as impressive as Garland as a key back.

P Johnson - he just keeps on improving every match, doesn't he?

C Johnson - always had the talent, now he's finally displaying it

Miller - gone from cameo appearances to likely top 5 B+F

Sylvia - improved on last year (nonetheless still has a long way to go)

Buckley - he's hitting targets now

Dunn - reinvented himself as one of the best taggers in the league

[Paul Gardner 6]

My biggest surprise this year are Matthew Warnock's improvement, & the changing of his spots ( ie :- Brad Green) throwing the body into contests & showing leadership through bravery.

[H_T 3,049]

Garland should win, but he has a lot of competition.

Warnock - has been equally as impressive as Garland as a key back.

P Johnson - he just keeps on improving every match, doesn't he?

C Johnson - always had the talent, now he's finally displaying it

Miller - gone from cameo appearances to likely top 5 B+F

Sylvia - improved on last year (nonetheless still has a long way to go)

Buckley - he's hitting targets now

Dunn - reinvented himself as one of the best taggers in the league

Good summary. All improved with the exception of Sylvia but your correct when you say - has a long way to go.

[Travman 0]

Garland should win, but he has a lot of competition.

Warnock - has been equally as impressive as Garland as a key back.

P Johnson - he just keeps on improving every match, doesn't he?

C Johnson - always had the talent, now he's finally displaying it

Miller - gone from cameo appearances to likely top 5 B+F

Sylvia - improved on last year (nonetheless still has a long way to go)

Buckley - he's hitting targets now

Dunn - reinvented himself as one of the best taggers in the league

All of these guys have shown improvement which is good to see. At this point in time across the board improvement is all we can hope for for mine. In this light we should mention Stef Martin and Chip Frawley. Stef has been a very pleasant surprise and Chip (while maligned by some) has definitley taken a positive step this year. Things are looking up!

[Cards13 9,117]

Your stats are up the creek without a paddle................................................it misses players such as Garland

Most Improved

Answer: GARLAND

Garland did not fit the criteria of games played in '07. 5 games in '07, 3 in '08.

[Cheney 38]

We all know it has been a down year for the

Demons this year, but I love the improvement

from so many players this season who has

been the most improved player this year?

what about Warnock?

[darkhorse72 1,925]

I think CJ has been the biggest improver this year considering where he has been sitting.

[Deano74 156]

For me its Miller and Garland as they have made the biggest impact in our games.

[tooly 0]

On the other side of the coin who has gone the

other way and under performed?

[Melbourne_777 0]

PJ gets my vote, the "chase" did it for me

[Beamer 1]

Garland. Looked way out his depth last year and early this year.

C.Johnson. Real quality player now. Needed to step up and did.

[Guest Schtacker]

We already did this and I said GREEN

I'd be tempted to change to either Miller or CJ now though, as they have kept keepin' on

[Guest Schtacker]

On the other side of the coin who has gone the

other way and under performed?

Bartram

Carroll

Jones

McDonald

Davey

Bell

Newton

Yze

White

Bate

[Beamer 1]

1. Bell

2. Newton

3. Jones

4. Carroll

5. White

I think its un-fair to include Bartram. Surely not of us expected him to be great at the start of this season.

[rpfc 28,774]

1. Bell

2. Newton

3. Jones

4. Carroll

5. White

I think its un-fair to include Bartram. Surely not of us expected him to be great at the start of this season.

Being tough on a tagged 20 yr old.

Garland, 3 rounds in was a goner, now he looks like a 10 yr FB. Easily the most improved.

Easily.

[Beamer 1]

I know Jones has been tagged. Its diificult for him, for sure.

I just expected more. Good players break tags.

[H_T 3,049]

Garland did not fit the criteria of games played in '07. 5 games in '07, 3 in '08.

But that doesn't exclude Garland from most improved for 2008!

[H_T 3,049]

For mine Garland the most improved by the length of the Flemington straight, and Jeff White the one who has "dropped off" the radar so to speak!