Dee1987

did anyone c scully before the game encouraging his teammates and being quiet vocal could be a good omen!!!!!!!!!!!!! and did anyone c the holding the tom scully please dont go sign

IN: BATE, PETTERD, CAMPBELL OUT GAWN EVANS BARTRAM

Schwartz is seriously the worst person at predicting things, plus he is hardly ever around the footy club anymore plus what didnt Scully say something like he wants to be a one club player plus Mr Trengove said last night on before the game he belives Scully will stay in the Red and Blue!!!

Gee some people here are ridiculous, dont people remember Tom said he wants to be a 1 club player and leaves contract talk upto MFC and his mangement. Jack Grimes on 3AW a couple weeks back was asked wether Tom Scully will be in the red and blue next year? his answer ABSOLUTLEY!!!! Plus Darren Jolly a couple of weeks back believes GWS will struggle to attract top players and GWS also believes they wont gain any reasonable players until 2012.

heres mine B: Morton Frawley Bartram HB:Grimes Garland Rivers C: Davey Moloney Trengove HF: Jurrah Dunn Green F: Wonna Martin Petterd Foll: Jamar Scully Gysberts Inter: Bail Jones (sub) Sylvia Tapscott

Ill have a stab, 38,150

Cambpell will play most of the year provided his knee holds up, Jamar looked tired after rnd 15 this year so i think they will have both rotating between fwd line and ruck ( hence thats why we chased Hale for the same reason) Spencer Gawn and Fitzpatrick are a long way away. A premiership ruckman i would never say no to

Honestly forget Hale now and Trade week, our main option right now is to get Scullys contract extend so GWS cant get there hands on him and that would nearly make our whole side off limits to GWS!!!

Useless statistic really, the fact of the matter is that we have been down there since 2007, completley rebuilt our list into young kids that are still learning. Compared to all the other vic sides all bar Richmond are physically more stronger than us!! i belive we can play finals next year, but maybe another 2-3 years before we become a genuine threat!!!

Really hope melbourne lock scully in for a much bigger contract soon, i belive he has a 2 year deal atm and Trengove has a 3 year deal? I like most feel he is very vulnrable with GC, and GWS coming???

I thought he was a bit stiff a couple of weeks a go to get dropped, i like the way he attacks the ball and his strength, accountability and he can also run! i would be a bit dissapointed if he got dropped this week thoughts?

id say the reality of these boys in the red and blue next years is done. 1- Scully 2- Trengove 11- Black/Jetta( i hope) 18- Ball 34-Grimes 50- Thorp 66-Pass PSD 1- Macdonald

Ill have a crack 1- Scully 2- Trengove 11- Griffiths 18- Ball/Vardy 34-Grimes 50- Thorp PSD 1- Jurrahs cuz!!

Agree with jacey, in 2 years time TJ, Black, Power will more than likely be gone and Fevola and Browns best footy will well and truly be behind them

Ill have a crack and say: Bell, Newton,Valenti and Buckley

I doubt they will cuz all those blokes i mentioned are at twilight of their careers, in the nxt 3 yrs most of their spine will be gone! Blokes like Brown n Fevolas calibre are hard to find and take years to develop!! They will be lingering in the 8 but no cigar

Honestly, they r an ageing list now just look at there over 28s, Fevola,Brown,Bradshaw,Johnstone,Charman,Buchanan,Power,Black. Aside from Rich, Merret, Sherman, Rischetelli and Clark, i dont think they will land another flag within the nxt 5 years? Who did they get in trade week? Buchanan- Just a handy player Raines- Injury prone, poor disposal Fevola- Good on when song but will be 29 nxt year and carrys too much baggage Staker- Just like Buchanan Clarke- Soft and no 1 rates him Plus they dont enter the draft until pick 27 and considering this years draft is shallow, they will get jack!!! Thoughts??

I reckon a strong pre-season and a good run with injuries there is no reason why we couldnt finish in the 8!! But realistically i think we could finish with 9 mayb 10 wins!!

Bit of a stupid question but after todays game will we get too much confidence or will Bailey make sure we get it?

wasnt butcher meant to be our second choice?

Carlton in 2007 got priority picks 1 and 3 no team gets 2

Correction picks 1 and 3, pick 2 should be going to Freo I Thought it would be Scully at 1 and Butcher at 3, didnt Bailey say we want an elite mid and a Key Position?

YES, we do deserve picks 1 and 3 considering we couldnt nab Judd and Warnock

Ok, assuming we end up with picks 1 and 3 what do we go get? Pick 1 ( Scully) pick 3 (Trengrove, Lucas, Butcher) I think we should get another quality speedy midfielder, cuz lets face it all top teams at least have 2 gun midfielders in there side. Geelong- Ablett, Bartel Saints- Montagna, Hayes Hawks- Mitchell, Hodge Dogs- Cooney Griffen Pies- Pendlebury, Swan Blues- Judd, Murphy Thoughts??

Hey, i think we are being too harsh on Brock, the guy hasnt done a pre season in 2 years so of course he is out of sorts, slow, going backwards etc. Give him a full pre season working on speed and what not and you will notice the difference! ease up ppl