Ted Lasso

Someone like poppy might hold some value to a team like the giants who don't really have a genuine small forward but is contending for a flag, I suspect they should try and get at least 2 top15 picks this year if they can need a quick injection of young talent onto that list

Agreed petracca watts kent jeffy hogan nibbler/hannan speed will trouble the tigers

I think they need a re build and will probably trade a couple of players at years end.

I think today was more about touch than match fitness for hibberd and he looked our best to me

After round 4 I rate the teams 1. Crows 2. Giants 3.cats 4. Tigers 5. Power 6. Eagles 7.demons 8. Saints

I would go with just hogan and watts as the tall forwards, tigers like the cats I think struggle to defend the smalls and we play better when we lower our eyes out weideman, bugg in: Trengove, hibberd

So you attack a posters view for suggesting it may be an issue and then admit he needs an entire pre season to maybe fix this issue but really don't know. No one wants trenners to fail, you imagine that because you take criticism of players personally, some posters are just a bit more honest about where players are at.

Trengove is getting the ball but having little impact on the game, I think he will really improve as a player when he is more attacking with his ball use, he is a beautiful kick and very smart

Rose coloured glasses I'd say saty, pretty hard to miss the lack of speed. I have also seen him 6 times love this year but have this wonderful ability to have a balanced view on players without letting emotion dictate that opinion.

Attacking a posters view without offering your own again beyond " FD might see it differently" how do you see that issue being improved? if it's easy to improve why has he not to this point been able to do it?

Brayshaw looks good but he is to quick for his team mates with disposal

I suspect when we have a fully fit hibberd in the side and Lewis back Vince will become a very handy midfield rotation half back doesn't suit him but I think Goodwin would rather keep Salem in the midfield for his development and not sure who else could play that role

I think you're right dazzle, we are a team in transition so we have to balance playing young guys so they develop and trying to win as many games as possible. Weideman is the future and pederson is not so I think there is some logic there, in saying that hogan coming in and weid having a rest would be a good move for now I think

Tigers haven't been tested by a really strong opposition so far this year, they've beaten he pies, blues, pies and a very wasteful west coast (admittedly a good win) i view us even with our injuries as the best opposition they've faced this year so it'll be a good test for both sides.

The tigers have had a very good draw so far. I think we will beat them pretty comfortably

a lot of it was just frustration I think mate but I do have some minor concerns. The biggest thing is now how we respond, does our season go into free fall or do we bounce back?

I'd probably give weld a rest and being in hogan, i wouldn't rush hibberd in unless he dominates

Our intensity is far more consistent. The Carlton game is an example, we played awfully and still found a way to win, could easily have done the same against the dockers and the cats we just didn't kick straight. My biggest concern is how easy we are to score against and the form of some of our players

Our defensive game plan relies on pressure and a lot of our players drop off and stop applying it when the opposition has momentum because they go into self preservation mode and worry about themselves

One concern I have is how easy we are to score against. Averaging 96.0 points against so far in 2017 my views on the jack Viney captaincy decision are well known. I think there are some question marks emerging and granted they aren't huge but we saw with the pies when Malthouse had a strong foundation for what should have been a strong period for the club, Nathan Buckley came in through a similar path to Goodwin, made changes to make it "his team" and the side went backwards i don't think that will happen with us but I am not as sold as other posters on goody just yet

My expectation was that we'd lose to Geelong and be 3-1 and even despite injuries should have been able to beat freo at the g so I am disappointed. Hopefully it fires the boys up to roll the tigers next week

Crows scoring power is amazing even without an absolute a grade midfield, i think they are the team to beat this year.

Hogan and Lewis have cost us two wins with their stupidity in my opinion.

I think the obvious thing to me today was weideman wasn't able to compete. Frost I think is ahead of oscar for now, he has a bit more speed and agility and a bit more grunt we really need hibberd to come in and play a role so we can push Vince up onto a wing. Id consiser playing Viney as a forward

Just heat of the moment comment to be honest mate