-
The Cooper Harvey Thread
Care to elaborate why?
-
Cats wobbles
To be fair, I'd prefer their run of success than ours. At least they have their culture right and all cogs appear to be moving. We have to content with Richardson and Lamb screwing FD and list up.
-
Trade Targets
Agreed on Will Brodie if available. I'm also a big fan of Cooper Harvey if available.
-
The List Manager Tim Lamb
This trade and draft period, particularly the former, I'll be watching and judging Lamb's performance closely. I feel we've made some excellent inroads to get club back on track. I commend Green on his work as president, am pleased to see Steven Smith elected to the board late last year, a change from Gary Pert to Paul Guerra, and of course the appointment of Steven King as coach. The one thing I've been critical on these last few years is the state of the list management. While drafting lead by Jason Taylor has been second to none, trading critical replacements after the loss of Jackson (Fee), Brayshaw (med.ret.), ANB (Ade), Brown (ret.), Hibberd (ret.) has left a lot to be desired. Grundy, McAdams, Schache, Billings, Sharp. If we look to the Todd Viney and Josh Mahoney list management prior, they built that premiership winning list around the midfield via trade (Lever, May, Brown, Langdon). I attribute much of the current list woes to Lamb, and to a lesser extent, Richardson. My other gripe is Lamb's inability to negotiate (trades and player contracts), or at least that's my perception. Having been in multimillion dollar sales for a while, I get the impression that he has a tendency to promptly go straight to floor price and then try to pick up pieces when he encounters the inevitable push back (I see it all too often in my line of work). With all that said, I can't be too harsh, I certainly acknowledge and commend his knowledge and contribution to the player selections associated with the draft (alongside Taylor). I believe his pros outweigh his cons. Perhaps he needs to read 'Never Split the Difference' (to start) and/or get some 3rd-party help for his negotiations. To me this trade period is critical if we genuinely believe that we can win another premiership with the likes of Gawn, Petracca, Oliver, Lever, Langdon, McDonald, Melksham, and Viney on the list. I certainly think it's possible. So where to now? We still need that tall forward and Charlie Curnow is allegedly on the market, but do we have the salary cap available (an A+ list manager would make it work)? Sure there's Mihocek, but his best is well passed and at what cost? Flanders is also rumoured, a great get for the right price. Which prospects with some upside are available for silverware (Harvey?)? I just hope that Lamb and the MFC are successful during this trade period as it appears to be inflection point for the premiership-capable vererans on our list.
-
The List Manager Tim Lamb
Agreed, and my mistake having worked off my phone. I will send my previous post over to the other one.
-
The List Manager Tim Lamb
[Redacted] See 'The List Manager Thread'
-
The Cooper Harvey Thread
Cooper's game against us in Round 18 was excellent. He was one of North's best on that day. Currently out of contract, with North not guaranteeing him a contract and shopping him around. His other games showed he has development to come, but, if we can get him for silverware, he's worth it!
-
May to Tribunal
The AFL and their outcome doesn't suprise me. But let's face it, if this were the week before or the first week of finals with May being in the #1 ranked side, he'd get off scott free (e.g. Maynard). If the ball had bounced forward to May's advantage and Evans still collided with him for the same outcome, again, he'd get off scott free. The AFL spoke of May having 0.56 seconds to react to not contact, how much time did Evan's have to react to avoid contact which wasn't taken?
-
Welcome to Demonland Matthew Jefferson
Does a one-legged duck swim in a circle?
-
The Bayley Fritsch Story
Ahh... Fritta... just love him. He's my favourite player. Said it a few times here, there's only one problem with him, we don't have two of him. I remembered his draft year. I was excited to see him come via Casey. That year I had started a new job, well career path, and made a new mate who was a country boy Queenslander. I asked him, do you have a footy team, he said "I'm thinking about the Bombers" (there were two reasons, we were both in aviation and he had an old bombers mate). I responded in a joking yet scarily serious way "Mate, if you're going to be a bombers fan, we can't be friends". I then said, "I'll take you to your first game, my shout". So off we went to the MCG. He was so intrigued and perplexed by the size of Spargo (also in the same draft year as Fritta), simply because he too was short and had grown up playing rugby, stated he had the heart but not the physic. To cut a story short, we won, he became a Dee and for the rest of the year while we we at the academy, we just spoke Dees. He'd often whisper " Spargo...." through the comms to which I'd reply "Fritta....". These days he's back in Queensland but he's a Dee for life and each week when the footy is on we frantically write to one another through the match.
-
Welcome to Demonland: Aidan Johnson
I'm thrilled with this one. For a good 1-2 years I've hoped (and proposed on here) that the Dees target who they deem the best forward across the state league competitions so at minimum we have more tall forward depth. I hope he promptly adapts to the AFL environment and can step straight into the main lineup for an immediate impact to help us contend another premiership while we have the likes of Gawn, May, and Viney still making an impact.
-
Gary Pert Quits as MFC CEO
I found it perplexing that he was a part of the internal review, yet all roads seemed to lead to him (at least there needed to be some form of accountability from a culture perspective).
-
Pending Announcement
Beat me to it :D
-
Pending Announcement
Clint Bartram, Cale Morton, .... heck Mark Neeld?
-
Marty Hore Re-Signs for 2025
I'm thrilled with this one. I genuinely believe he is a Best 22 player that's capable of holding his own in a premiership side. I just hope he can have a great preseason, some luck with with injury or specifically lack there of, and secure his opportunity for a spot in the side where he can string multiple games together.