Alcho Dee

Ok but the list has changed for the better with the addition of Tyson, Cross,Vince and Georgiou these players have contributed much to our improvement. I think Neeld would of had more success if he had the current list.

They beat us last year and they beat us this year, let's be honest the scoreboard flattered us last week.

How does Panozza go compared to the Melbourne listed players?

Richard Tambling....Darren Gaspar???

good for you champ

And we would have been thumped if the had Hayes, Steven, Montagna etc etc etc etc

Looking at the positives in our performances is one way to go, but unfortunately t.u the numbers tell a different story!!

And watch if we get beaten over the next 5 rounds and we will see the same "tough love" given out just like Neeld did. Not much has changed so far apart from a slightly better list, agreed? Neeld didn't have Dawes for the first half of last year, and didn't have Frawley for part of it, and in their place had James Sellar and Jack Fitzpatrick.

Roos talked about our percentage representing our improvement but so far Stuie we have played majority bottom half sides and our percentage sits at 69.3% so you have no facts to back you up. What C&B says is true you just don't want to accept that.

Richard Tambling. End thread.

Jamar and Salem are both good ins in my opinion, but Byrnes will need to do more around the forward line than just get on the end of a couple of cheap ones, hopefully Byrnes is sub because he doesn't have the ability to play well for 4 quarters.

Forget O Rourke ATM, he needs to show he can play at the top level first. Much better options than him. Plenty if we are considering given out pick 1 or 2. O Rourke was expected to go in the late teens and he isn't exactly the player we need.

We have spent big on KPF's with Clark, Watts, Dawes, and Hogan. Looks like we need to get another. Our midfield is still needs another hard inside midfielder and it would be looking good, we have the foundations of a great midfield with Jones, Viney, Tyson but we need another hard running tough inside mid who gets heaps of it and then the midfield would be formidable.

He had a good year last season and played a big part in some of their wins. And he had a better career for us compared to many.

Funny how Barrett initially said "Hogan won't play again" until Lyon stopped him and made him be more specific in saying this year. Especially after Clark's retirement, what a thing to say. He loves feeding off other teams and peoples misfortunes. I know it's his job but he doesn't have to be such a [censored] about it.

There is no doubt Watts, Toumpas can play but it's around the stoppages that we need to win the ball to get it out to them. Dangerfield, Mundy for example are fast running inside mids who win the hard ball and would feed it out to Toumpas and Watts.

We have heaps of outside mids on our list.

We need a strong fast inside midfielder with our first pick. And a forward who can do time in the ruck with our second pick or a ruck who can go forward.

Neeld said the same thing.

Judge us after round 5.... 4 losses 1 win Less than 34,000 members 17th on the ladder Percentage 69.3% And are yet to play the better sides.

Lucky it was only a jeep.

Hmmmmm

Good grab in 98 against the tigers

Well unless Cameron Ling is coming out of retirement.

Play O Keefe as a small forward...