thaipantsman

Ok! Thought bout it. Sheedy. He knows more about football than anyone. Obviously would make some extremely unpopular decisions at first but let's face it we need a complete cultural change.

You are right bj. Am sur they have someone in mind. Lineage is good . Jim Stynes would of fit the role. Let me think about it! Greetings from chiangmai

Did yu see the address by Neeld before bombers clash. LAME!

Half baked. He's not the only Melbourne media person to do us. G. Healy's another and not talking Greg. Connolly has also contributed.

Perhaps a sheedy /shwartz no 5 revival?

GWS are hot off the press and doing ok. Fortunes don't come into it.

Not ideal but far better option than Neeld in 2014. Would of been better tn Neeld in 2012 as well.

Gee hard track. You learnt to swear without being moderated. Clever man!

Heavy [censored] by Jaded......but pretty true when it comes to Melbourne. Dean Bailey and Mark Neeld are living examples.

thought you had a scoop. Gary is a media personality now. End of story.

Like the keeness The latter 4 left because of Neeld . The other 4 were the only players willing to play under him. Liam Jurrah would arguably be our best forward option right now.

gawn better than the spence

Not watts fault. Simply a scapegoat goat. Put hi chf..another week in the magoos for pedo. I like gawn. Not bad.

Agreed! If Gawn is fit get him in! Any wise people have some answers re: the following... 1/ Will Sylvia and Toumpass be retained for WC. ( I feel both should play R 3 especially Sylvia) 2/ I know this is contentious but here goes? How many games will Neeld survive if Melbourne continues to be flogged. (Flogged = 50 point loss). Note: I like him and he obviously has passion but does he have anything else? After reading all the commentary on this one I'm torn. 3/ What's the progress on Taggert and Gawn. A Fit Gawn similar to the one I saw V Tigers 2 years ago is badly needed to replace an ageing and slowing Jamar. IMO. Taggert looked very promising before getting injured. 4/ Is Barry any good and if so is he ready for a call up given desperate times?

Is Viney OK?

1/ Will Sylvia and Toumpass be retained for WC. ( I feel both should play R 3 especially Sylvia) 2/ I know this is contentious but here goes? How many games will Neeld survive if Melbourne continues to be flogged. (Flogged = 50 point loss). Note: I like him and he obviously has passion but does he have anything else? After reading all the commentary on this one I'm torn. 3/ What's the progress on Taggert and Gawn. A Fit Gawn similar to the one I saw V Tigers 2 years ago is badly needed to replace an ageing and slowing Jamar. IMO. Taggert looked very promising before getting injured. 4/ Is Barry any good and if so is he ready for a call up given desperate times?

Why don't you write something constructive DD..Put up an alternative rather than confrontational crap.

Bailey was a superior speaker, strategist and communicator. If he had Neeld's Hairstyle would still be in charge.

It's the Ned Kelly look. In at the minute.

Good one titan! Jamar's best is well behind him. He has a height disadvantage and is very slow. Doesn't have the leap required and versatility that White had...another shorter ruck man. GAWN!!

In taggert gawn magnet barry

Agreed . Rawlings or Viney?

Go for lineage. Todd Viney. Hopefully the players can turn out like Jack.

Neeld hunted Dawes, Rodan, Pederson, Byrnes, Gillies. Dawes may still show something but highly doubtful. How slow would Dees be with both Jamar and Dawes on the ground? Jamar appears to be playing with weights attached to his arms and legs. In fact he makes Mick Nolan look like a speedster. Back to Neeld. Under his command we lost Jurrah (not guilty), Moloney and Martin ( both playing well with Lioms, Petterd (fitted in beautifully at Tigers.) Rivers ( at least twice as good as Gillies). All Neelds mature imports are extremely suspect though granted it,s early days. Neeld's Melbourne play without any semblance of pride, courage, common sense and seem void of any skill. Even J. Howe has lost the confidence to hold that big screamer. Neeld's address's are without passion and are watched by a bunch of kids of which two are Captain. Trengove is not much faster than Jamar. Jack Grimes is Captain and together with Jones are two guys proud of the red and blue. Neeld doesn't inspire the group. He can't coach. The longer he stays the worse things will get for Melbourne. Bulldogs, Kangaroos, Dockers, Power in fact any other team would thrash us now including Gws and Gold Coast. This is clearly the worst state Melbourne has been in since I can remember and that includes Melbourne teams of 66, 67 through to 74. Ridley's Melbourne played with fire in the belly. This team of hand picked players, carefully drafted selections are barely interested and with no fire or pride of pulling on a red and blue jumper. Neeld's extremely boring. Everything he says in the media and in his rev ups boring. He's a boring guy with a boring plan who never should of been given license to coach and license to recruit players.. The question is. What to do now? Caretaker coach is required immediately. Do we look to the guy who brought us Sellar, N. Craig , Todd Viney perhaps or some other Melbourne Old boy with some lineage.? Any ideas? Todd looks a great choice