rjay

If Phillips is on the table we should still go after him...

Love Clayton, great get by the MFC. Didn't think it was his best year to date but... Taking from these 2 posts if we can get the midfield chemistry right, better spread, we get better use of his ball winning talent. I think he will also hit the scoreboard more as he learns when to take his shot & have the confidence to do it.

No, this has Gubby all over it... He's been brought in to shake up the list and he's doing it. Whether it's successful or not time will tell.

With due respect Ellis and Tomlinson are hardly in the same calibre as Tom Lynch. The argument doesn't hold up, anyone with half a brain knew that FA would work in favour of the stronger clubs. A few morsels going to the smaller clubs does not change this...

Hogan was part of that forward line so the answer doesn't carry a lot of weight... Maybe we have another tall forward in mind. ????

Maybe a little on the small side but I get your thinking...haven't seen enough of him to know whether his foot skills are good.

Why is he perfect for us 'Nev'? He's not a small forward but an undersized mid from what I see...has some skill, nice player but hardly perfect.

Got a bit of Stephenson about him...

What else could they give us?

I think we would have a better idea on the first & second year players ' @DeeSpencer '... Personal opinion is I only see Jordon, Sparrow & Petty as the chances to make it and that's probably not a bad hit rate given where we had the picks. The other kid we haven't seen yet is Nietschke so the jury is out on him until we see some game time.

A: Max Gawn, Clayton Oliver B+: Jack Viney, Tom McDonald B: Nil B-: Nathan Jones, Christian Salem, Angus Brayshaw, Michael Hibberd, Kade Kolodjashnij, Jake Melksham, Bayley Fritsch, Steven May C+: Christian Petracca, Jake Lever, Sam Frost, Aaron Vandenberg, Jayden Hunt, Alex Neale-Bullen, Marty Hore, Josh Wagner, Neville Jetta C James Harmes, Billy Stretch, Mitch Hannan, Oscar McDonald, Joel Smith, Corey Wagner C-: Jay Kennedy-Harris, Braydon Preuss Developing*: Sam Weideman Developing: Charlie Spargo, Oskar Baker, Harrison Petty, James Jordan, Tom Sparrow, Toby Bedford, Aaron Nietschke, Austin Bradtke, Kade Chandler Here's mine on expectation for the next season: Developing: Only ones I see with a future are Petty, Jordon & Sparrow Developing* Weid...I'm... "Wishin' and hopin' and thinkin' and prayin'" C-: Omac, Smith, Wagners, JKH,KK, Preuss C Frost, Hannan, ANB, Tomlinson C+: Jones, AVB, Hore, Hibberd B-: Viney, Langdon, Salem, Trac, Jetta, Melk, TMac, Harmes, B: Brayshaw (if he stays) B+: Lever A: Gawn, Oliver, May We've got a bit of work to do...I hope we haven't finished trading when the Langdon deal is done...

You sure love your little calculator 'Nev'...

Fritsch has the 3rd tall role locked down to my thinking... Where does Smith fit?

Simple, then we keep pick 3... That's what I'm saying. If anyone doesn't read your posts and want to give us 2 picks then we take them. ...but as you say, it's not going to happen. So...why should we trade down if we can't get what we want!!! Makes no sense to me.

Agree with you 'Wise'. I think we keep pick 3 unless we can deal 2 picks in the top 10. On average this is where most talent comes, yep you get some exceptional players in the teens but for every Lynch you get a Cook. ...and as for those quoting points. Points don't play footy for you, it's a nice little side line to keep people with too much time on their hands busy. The only time they are of value is if you can trade into a good deal (player).

He's been tried in the ruck and forward before and failed. It's just not his go. If he's going to play anywhere it's as a lock down defender. Anything else and he's lost, even Clarko can't fix that...

Wood is a 3rd tall if that, not a key forward. I think we proved at the end of the season that Fritsch has that spot covered...then we also have Trac, Hannan and even Melk. Not a player type that we need I would think.

Me

Brown paper bags...

Just out of interest... Has Jennings got another job yet. I know he was looking to coach his won team.

Didn't want him anyway...will be injured most of the time.

He's been told...my info is not a rehash of Mahoney.. ...but you don't lock anything in.

Tomlinson has been told he's being brought in to play wing... Whether that ends up being the case who knows but that's the position we've targeted him for. Howe was brought in to C/Wood to play forward and...things change.

I'm guessing 2019...but 'bin' can talk for himself.

Last time I looked 11 isn't in the top 10 so I would think something a bit earlier and 9 would be more like it...