rjay

I don't know about haranguing but the question must surely be asked and answered, not avoided or brushed over.

...not just you 'dazzle'. It's most definitely my preference.

I think he is way off the mark with our defence. A fit May pushes us up a few more places than 13th, Lever adds another place or 2. The structure of our defence will be interesting this year but I really rate May, next to Rance I think he's the best in the business.

It's nearly like you're shifting the blame to the players here 'Dee' Ryan most definitely didn't open himself up to these comments. Prevention would be to name and shame the people who make these comments then let's see how many are willing to make them when they are fully exposed.

We might be deeply flawed 'Jako' but I prefer not just giving in. Things do change no matter how slowly, the optimist in me is hopeful.

In this particular case (Liam Ryan)...do you think it's ok for someone to say what he or she said or under freedom of speech are they free to say whatever they want?

What is political correctness 'Biffen'? Can you define it? To me it seems like some catch all for anyone who doesn't like a particular view.

Why do you feel more exposed 'old dee'?

Let's just say if he didn't intentionally touch cocaine he probably would have been in the minority.

Looks like we're going around in circles a bit here. Changes have been made and quite significant ones. Do I care about the Crowes? No... Whilst I don't think we were in crisis we had major issues. Do I think our preseason surgeries were an issue? yes Do I think we had other issues besides those? yes and we've started to address them which is good. Do I think there will be further shake ups prior to the start of the season? yes

Very true 'Gonzo'...we have a new CEO who is yet to make his mark on the club. It will be interesting to know how much input he had into the changes made. The structure is there but there have been significant renovations.

No brigade of coaches sacked, that was an overstatement by 'steve' but also your take was an understatement and didn't account for the significance of the changes made. Some pushed and some moving on, who knows where each falls... Viney, MIsson, Rawlings, Jenning, Macca...it's not a small exodus, these were major players.

A little like the politician that steps down for family reasons... Spin it anyway you like 'bin' but there have been significant changes made in the FD as there should have been after a disastrous 2019.

This you don't know... Some of these things take time to fix. There are no magic bullets, it may take us a few draft/trade periods. Maybe the changes made on and off field already have been in answer to these problems.

I didn't want to quote the whole post again 'Goffy' but you make your point well. I like to make opinions on what I see but I'm not stupid enough to deny that stats, particularly well analysed stats are an invaluable aid. I mean at the end of the day the scoreboard is a stat...in most cases it tells us who was the better team on the day. If we can break that down with well considered stats & some smart analysis it should help us in every facet of the game including building the list and yes improving the goal kicking...

I rate him too, he's a slow burn but plenty of talent. Still only 21yo.

Hi Mel, I might have got you in this a little bit deeper than we expected...we could have a discussion on drugs and creativity another time. My thinking is it might have more to do with the temperament of the artist in a lot of cases and may not have helped and could have indeed hindered their creative process. It certainly screwed up a lot of them, Brian Jones, Peter Green, Jimi, Sid Barrett and many others... Good old Satch and Bing were know to have many a recreational smoke together. The culture police would be surprised to know that... Zappa by the way had the Roos policy in his bands, the opposite end of the stick. As for not having any drug users or former drug users playing for the club then I don't think we would be a hope in hell of getting anywhere & would struggle to put a list together if that was the case. Drug use is rife in the whole AFL system, our club is no different. I heard of a prominent recruit who was surprised to find at least 70% of his team-mates into it. So, that horse has long bolted. It's only those with their head in the sand that would see it as a problem to club culture. It's not changing anytime soon, it's why the AFL have a harm minimisation policy. Not for the players, but for their brand.

You mean the 2 players that paid for their own personal training camp o/s during the break? ....and the number 2 pick who was spotted training for a couple of hours early on a Saturday morning looking in peak condition with his own personal trainer before the kids took over the ground for cricket? They're both working hard... For some it's better they stay away from the club, do the work & come back refreshed. They're all going to be in each others pockets soon enough.

Who are you talking about???

I think that comment might just show a little ignorance also 'Mel'... Not all great art has been created in artificial altered states.

Edwards is the only premiership player there in the first list and he's inside and out... Burgoyne, let's not make the argument. He's a gun inside and out as a premiership player. I haven't seen anything of Stephens bar his highlights (I'm not saying he's soft by the way), the club would have a good insight. If he can win hard inside ball to go with his outside ability then good. ...but I would be wary of rating him on SANFL form, it's a very open style of footy they play. Again, I'm sure the club are aware of this...

It's not so much about the state... It's well known that contested ball winners are more likely to make it at AFL level. Despite what many complain about on here on here about drafting contested ball winners, it is the smart option. The highlights show lots of nice stuff but I don't remember seeing him win any contested ball. I think the consensus on here is we go for Young at 3, he can zone off for the cheap kick and also win his own ball on the ground and in the air. I would rather we take that type of player. Outside runners from SA, who was the last really successful one of those...Craig Bradley?

Not just Toumpas 'BAMF'...as 'Skuit' mentions above but there are more.

Once bitten...always wary of outside players from SA.

All clubs whose coaches spend time in the US and other places in the world to make sure they are at the top of their game...