Moonshadow

Well, in case you haven't realised, we are aiming to win a flag. Keeping a player who might not want to be at the club isn't smart. Trading for players who do and fill specific needs that will improve out team is smart when we are aiming for a flag. That's the objective. There are probably other factors at play that we don't know about that will effect the outcome. Could be medical, could be personal. I trust our list guys to get the job done to improve our list. They've done a great job over the last 4-5 years. They will get value.

Yeah sure, that's exactly what I'm suggesting... FMD.

Your opinion, of course. I think Mahoney, Todd Viney and Taylor will have a more pragmatic view and will not get bogged down by numbers. In fact they probably use a completely different set of criteria to us punters when assessing the outcome. Will they achieve 5+6 or 5+ Langdon or just 5? Don't know. However, will our list be improved with May, Preuss and KK, all of whom want to play in red and blue? F#*% yeah!

I don't think you do, but that's ok. If Hogan leaves, his value is whatever the FD believe is sufficient to achieve what they wanted to improve our list.

I still think our FD will look at it more from objectives and outcomes POV rather than what pick we might get or give up. They want May, Preuss and KK. That much appears clear. Perhaps there is something else in the pipeline. But if Hogan wants to leave, I highly doubt we'd hold him to his final contract year. Whether we get 5+6 or 5+2019 1st rounder or just 5, it's about achieving our objectives to improve the list and moving on. I'm not suggesting the club roll over, just that we have bigger fish to fry in 2019.

Sounds to me like you're assessing Jesse's value to the team and weighing up whether or not we might improve the list if he was traded

So does family loyalty

Is it too much to expect you might understand that a player cannot be traded to a specific club without their consent?

Or...... They could just give us every pick for Vanders No, really. FMD.

Let's hope he's not Jack Watts 2.0

The meds only help if you take them

Now I've heard it all! Paranoia full throttle...

Shai Bolton re-signed with tigers

4) Hogan reaffirms he's settled and re-signs with us.

I think Burton is a good player and should get them a high 2nd round pick

Didn't we draft Petty for a similar role?

Yes, I fear Hunt will become Casey depth KK improves our backline, assuming he passes medical by Richmond doctor

Which chap are you talking about?

No he didn't. He made a joke of how his mum reads everything on social media and it makes for an interesting tuesday family dinner. He said watch out cause she'll hunt you all down, partic Demonland4276 It was clearly a joke

Of course. Who is it though?

Everyone was poor in our last game. Not everyone was as good as Lewis the two games before. It's easy to cherry pick individual games

And yet he was amongst the best in the 2 finals we won. Funny how we only see what we want when our eyes are half closed.

If he stays it may explain why we asked the AFL for permission to trade next years 1st round pick, which goes some of the way towards potentially getting May and KK.

Who wasn't?