demon3165

You are kidding injured? will take 4th round pick for him all he can do is tackle cannot run cannot kick and has no football upside people are now starting to see this but we will keep playing him.

Endeavour is one thing, skill, pace and football brains is another and unfortunately Viney does not have them he is predicable in wanting to play on without thought and has no right foot such is why he gets caught and turns the ball over too often.

Out: One trick pony Viney, Omac and JKH In: May, Hore and Salem

Viney goal kicking practice...lmfao 29 goals in what seven seasons how about he learns to put depth in is kicks instead of helicopter kicks over 30 metres.

Lets give the kid a chance for gods sake looks to have better skills than Viney who can only tackle, slow as a snail and no football awareness and cannot kick over a jam tin anyone will do for me.

Well he could replace Viney surly he would have more football smarts than Viney.

Spargo has one advantage over Viney he has a football brain one trick pony can only tackle.....

Oh well with Viney in that makes it 21 v 22.

Pirlo: If you're suggesting he's been a "servant of the club" then I have to wonder why you'd bother supporting us Settle down junior take a bex and lie down for while oh do I have to tell you what a bex is....

The swans play the same way we did and were are they on ladder? Jones has been a servant of the club no doubt but he is to slow cannot think his way through in the modern game time for him to explore other options.

Viney to half back he cannot kick over 30 metres is slow as hell might as well not pick him and leave us one short.

OUT Bambi =Jones One Trick Pony= Viney Anyone who can run.

OUT Bambi and One trick pony IN Anyone

Fan of myself just because I have a different view, gee at least I can say they had did alright so don't be a [censored] sunshine!!!!

Whilst i am not a huge fan of Viney or jones football wise and I have even posted this even I must admit both have played well in both matches and as a supporter I hope that continues on in Perth next Saturday. Go dees.

Stand corrected.

Let me put it this way Viney like Jones is a one trick pony yes he hard at it but lacks football awareness no opposite side of the body yes I am not a fan and I hope he plays well but being out of the game for two months is different to training has been proven in the past. As I said If he plays well I will be the first to say so but I would have taken Wines before him.

Hannan in, no Viney for me taking a big risk if they do.

I hope they don't play him it would be a big mistake playing him would not be conditioned enough for a Final plus you cannot have two players of the same ilk (Jones and Viney).

History is also to be remembered not lived.

Why Viney is the same as Jones only younger.

If Viney was sole skipper we would get the same as Jones but younger TMac for mine with Gawn as Vice and for the sole purpose other than learning Brayshaw and Oliver as D/Vice.

Midfield you can take out Jones and Viney two players hard at it but no football brains just try to barge through or bomb it long to no one we need a Gaff type players around the ball.

So it appears Jones thinks the same way as he plays football panicky as much as it appears a brain fade from Gaff these incidents are pretty rare introducing a red card would be an over reaction in my view just like the AFL with them wanting to change the way the game looks.