monoccular

Great work again guys - so much appreciated. How do you feel that our incoming players NB McAdam, Fullerton and maybe Billlings and Tholstrup will impact our forward transition and connection? It has appeared to have been our biggest weakness 2022 & 2023.

Like so many before him (Sylvia, Watts, Morton etc) just one good preseason away from superstardom

I guess there can be career averages and recent form. Ant And then there is disposal efficiency which you don’t quote. Frittata and Melksham don’t count then? And positions don’t matter eg if it was, say, from our top 15, heaven forbid Rivers and Langdon, it would be far less impactful than Petty, Melksham, Frittata (Brown even) all at once. There was no key forward structure left.

“WouldGrundy have done better than a non-utiliesdSchache? Almost definitely.” Absolutely 100% without any shadow of doubt could not have done less - and not blaming Schache at all for that.

Drones anyone?? Sorry, but Josh is still nailed to the bench, never to be released.

Quick …. knee jerk reaction coming from the global leading experts in knee jerk reactions, AFL HQ ….. Weagles need immediate compensation with their choice of any player drafted by another club who originates from ….. Esperance. 😡🙄😮

bluey - you know this for a fact, or speculation, or rumour?

Back - meaning in defence, back on the bench unused, back at Casey?. Only one player in any team (and happens to be Collingwood) to whom I would wish any serious injury and I guess we all know which piece of scum that is.

How exciting would that be?? Looking forward to the season.

JJJ - I hope you mean by 'a lump of clay' that he is ripe for molding, rather than being an inert blob which is how some could misinterpret it 🙄

Hope that is a typo and we aren't getting another arrogant <person who tosses> Mason Cox 🇺🇸 😎 My post wasn't meant to be negative in any way - purely a question as I don't remember a lot of detail about season 2019 Must have been away working a bit

IMVHO Woey would have been a far better sub than Laurie when Angus was assaulted so early in the game. He is already ahead.

Mr Neitz says “hi”!

1964 Melbourne Premiership player, Don Williams? I guess, she either is, or is not.

If we miss the final 8 next year then....... the pessimists will feel vindicated I, however, will choose to remain optimistic.

But BT would really miss his “wow, Richo, another Hunter special, underground handpass, JB”. PS : BT, all of Hunter’s low handpasses remain above the ground.

So did Hames’ most memorable ever kick, across the corridor I guess, breach team rules? 🤗

Q3 seems easily answered. Do they really want or need good umpires or do they only want compliant ones? 🙄

So we lose access to Mac Andrew (if we really ranked him) as a knee jerk reaction to JUH, and now there is a partial reversal by the world experts at making big decisions on the run, aka AFL. Sounds about the way they run things.

I have very little knowledge of Martin Hore, so have absolutely nothing against him, but can some in the know please enlighten me as to just what he offers, what gap he fills, on our current list? Thanks.

Langdon surely was a “dream wingman” 2021 though he hasn’t repeated that form. Blake Howes has been highly praised but has not had a chance yet through injury.

Chandler seemed to just run out of puff after a great start to season 2023 - hopefully another preseason will see him last a good deal longer in 2024.

MEL ASP 2h 50m MEL BNE 2h 10m MEL PER 4h 10m

1/ How much input does Goody have in the drafting process? Obviously some, but does JT have the "final say"? 2/ where do Bailie Laurie and Blake Howes stand now given the two picks this year, Viking and Windsor?

He [Sestan] came from nowhere, has had one preseason at AFL level. Really looking forward to seeing him develop after a year on our list and two preseasons.