Everything posted by monoccular
- 
	
		
		TMac Finals Return?
		
		Yes, hoping, but more realistically wishful thinking. Definitely must formulate a game plan without him.
 - 
	
		
		CHANGES: Rd 16 vs Adelaide
		
		I am glad someone else has also considered this. I am not complaining at all but I am not so sure we have (for very good reasons) not been told everything about who had covid and how badly.
 - 
	
		
		Jack Gunston
		
		Even if Jacko stays and stars, we still need a significant extra ruck. In other words he covers Max but who covers him? Agree re desperate need for a strong marking forward KPP.
 - 
	
		
		De Goey is the New Story
		
		Seems to be a requirement for Magpie Presidency
 - 
	
		
		Majak Daw Retires
		
		Lovely to hear Jack Bell acknowledging Majak’s input. On the subject - as a Casey listed player does Bell gat any chance to be exposed to Max at training?
 - 
	
		
		Jack Gunston
		
		“… JVR's development over the course of the season is one to keep track of. With our backline depth pretty well covered his best chance atm is developing as a forward. At 193cm if he can put on more size he could really develop to come in as Brown and Tmac start to slow down.” Surely a big bodied marking forward must be our first priority this recruiting season, then a back up ruck.
 - 
	
		
		De Goey is the New Story
		
		And Thomas says the Saints should add de Goey to the mix. I suppose he would fit in the club culture. Warning to dwarfs - keep fire extinguisher handy.
 - 
	
		
		De Goey is the New Story
		
		…… the UAE, where women know their place.
 - 
	
		
		Majak Daw Retires
		
		Good luck Majak - so sorry that injury hit at just the wrong time when a replacement ruck was needed for Max. Still your contribution to the whole team effort in Perth for the 2021 finals campaign was invaluable, providing a valuable foil for Max in trying drills and scratch matches. Thanks for your contribution.
 - 
	
		
		NON-MFC: Round 15, 2022
		
		We would need to run both pasta good sports psychologist to see why they have not been up to scratch. Discontent with their current environment vs general indifference or apathy.
 - 
	
		
		CHANGES: Rd 16 vs Adelaide
		
		What a simplistic "analysis" - Langdon didn't score at all, Oliver scored only 1 behind, so would their absence make no difference. BBB is not in form, but he did a lot of work up the ground throughout the game not all of which appears on standard publicly accessible stat sheets. Yes, his missed shots at goal were incredibly disappointing and frustrating. I just hope he is not rushed back prematurely - even if he does need to miss the Geelong game, which I am sure we all hope he won't, his importance at the business end of the season is immeasurable.
 - 
	
		
		NON-MFC: Round 15, 2022
		
		Does having a full genetic match between a coach and a AFL operations manager have any influence? Just asking.
 - 
	
		
		Kozi hurts
		
		Does anyone here have access to these pressure act and wok rate stats? OMG Uncle Byron was so solid as well as quick and aggressive. Would be intimidating knowing that he was in the area if you had the ball. Nephew has the speed and aggression and still tackles well above his weight and his presence intimidates.
 - 
	
		
		CHANGES: Rd 16 vs Adelaide
		
		There is still a lot of water to flow under the bridge for 2022 - sure they have him [Rivers] covered, for now. But Hunt, Rivers are there and applying pressure. And even poor Joel Smith, if he ever gets an injury free run, is in the mix.
 - 
	
		
		NON-MFC: Round 15, 2022
		
		It was certainly a deliberate decision to bump - which we keep getting told condemns you to whatever the outcome may be. Meanwhile, eye gouging is apparently only worth a $1k fine, both for the perpetrator and the victim.
 - 
	
		
		Kozi hurts
		
		Toby and Koz though very similar seem to complement each other rather than compete. Having those two and Spargo, who is a slightly different but equally important small forward is a luxury - I hope we can find a way to keep them all involved. Until and unless we can find 2+ genuine tall marking forwards this seems the best option.
 - 
	
		
		Kozi hurts
		
		Your reference to inferred pressure is very apt - they just don’t know where he is and when or how he will pounce. And I love his second and third and fourth efforts. I well remember at least two goals in 2021 where he ran from half back, gave, received, gave again and received and goaled. One was v North and the other at the G may have been v GW$.
 - 
	
		
		POSTGAME: Rd 15 vs Brisbane
		
		Maybe saints could relocate to Tasmania. (And North way up north to NT)
 - 
	
		
		NON-MFC: Round 15, 2022
		
		Turned off after ¾ time. Awful spectacle.
 - 
	
		
		CASEY: Rd 14 vs Gold Coast
		
		I would be interested in the opinions of those who know a lot more then me if either (or both) Bell and Valentine are in the age mix / physicality / skill set to make it at AFL. Thanks in anticipation.
 - 
	
		
		NON-MFC: Round 15, 2022
		
		OMG the Saints look really really poor - how did they get so high up the ladder earlier one the season?
 - 
	
		
		NON-MFC: Round 15, 2022
		
		Blind Freddie could see that he was concussed ... as you say, where is he duty of care? Conversely, on Thursday night they held up play when the Brisbane guy who took on Frittata front on and injured his chest (Lyon?) walked from the field. Why the difference? AFL please explain.
 - The Jack Viney Made Me Cry Thread
 - 
	
		
		NON-MFC: Round 15, 2022
		
		% Would have gone down actually.
 - 
	
		
		NON-MFC: Round 15, 2022
		
		Loading or old age? ✔️ MRP - “one week or two? Who are they playing in two weeks? OK. One week then”