old dee

I cannot see what is wrong with this position. Would be my expectation.

I think we all understand the basic idea But if the players bought in cannot justify their position in the side then we have achieved nothing. The media people I have heard are suggesting that the idea is not wrong but the players selected are poor choices. IF last Sunday is the level of their contribution during a real game we might as well play kids. Now I know it was one game but the players picked looked very ordinary.

Believe it or not I am doing the same thing right now. Coffee and Banana cake that is. Enjoy bb much better there than here

Agree 100% Redleg particularly Pedersen. I watched his highlights reel and it seemed to be all one game which made me wonder. All these selections concerned me at the time. I said a number of time over the summer that Roden, Brynes, Gillies and Pedersen were players who were past it or struggled to get games with there previous teams. Now it is only one game but they do not look flash so far. Why with us?

It will be interesting to see how Mr. Magner plays this week at Casey!

My "like This" button is working again wonderful. Thanks Nasher or whoever

Did not see any more from Gillies, Nasher God knows how he is still in. Admittedly it is week one but they all played as their 2012 form would suggest Crap

Another 43 like Sunday rpfc and I will retire long before no. 43

Yes it probably was foolish Robbie

Gee tatu you make me look like the supreme optimist.

Very good Robbie I like it a lot

Very good Robbie I like it a lot

Yes I understand stuie, glad to see it is just not me. The way the electronic world has been treating me over the last month I am getting a little paranoid about it.

The only person I have seen drop their head as badly was Bennell in 2010 vs The Pies I knew he was no good that day and guess what he wasn't. Pedersen fits the same mould, does he have a one or two year contract?

Guys do you realise how bloody boring your little fight is after numerous pages on numerous threads. Get over each other PLEASE

Yes correct Excuse me if I am a little thick tonight but isn't that the same result?

RPFC he was terrible last sunday. He had four years at Geelong and was ordinary the whole time from what my Geelong friends tell me.

I worry about our future too Older Demon but I don't see the AFL doing what you suggest. After failed meagers , they would wait for the club to go belly up. That in my worst dream is a few seasons away. If nothing much improves by year end there will be a s--- fight at years end. I dread the next five months it is IMO not going to be pretty.

100% agreement rpfc

I agree with a couple of your points however there are a few I cannot accept How could we be worse than 2012 and Last Sunday? Crowds and membership are crap now That will happen if we don't start winning games and right now we don't look like fixing the problem any time soon, if we changed coaches I find it hard to believe we could win less games than current. The media have been circling us for five years, nothing new there. Changing coaches would be far from a good look. But we look Irrelevant now I struggle with how we could look worse.

Ever since the crash my "like This" button has not worked. Anyone having a similar problem?

How on earth does Gillies / Nicholson stay in and Jetta out again?

I agree 100% Maldonboy38 Most will say they know more about it than both of us. But I am getting a bad feeling about all this it just makes you start to wonder about how smart is our FD

GiG this not meant to having a go at you But are we supposed be scared or something? If he reads daily. I hope he gets some of the points people are raising. EG. the troops are very restless Cameron, it takes a lot to get MFC members up but last Sunday achieved it. To much more of that and we will be looking for someone's blood before mid year.

GiG Forget him he is off at the end of 2013 You don't need to be a rocket scientist to work it out. Just looks uninterested to me