old dee

Could easily happen at the end of 2012!

I promised myself I was going to ignore this thread but here I am! Agree BB, he is no longer at the dees Can we all forget about him. Lets concentrate on Positives at the MFC for 2012

Best high number pick must go to Shane Woedonin 1996 PSD 18 and then he won the Brownlow. Are there any better high number picks than 1997 Nathan Brown 66 and Guy Rigoni 77.

2001 Luke Moylan not a trade but nil games. when you look through the list there were some poor ones, I guess it is not an exact science.

2011 has finally started to show a good side to me. Went to the Basketball last night. The Tigers are coming together beautifully. 5 wins from 6 games, it is not hard to see why patrick mills is in the NBA ( when they are playing ) The guy is brilliant. Such a contrast to the Dees, most of the team have only been playing together 10 weeks and they are already looking good. As well i don't have to wait 3 years till they develop ( I know it is a different situation. ) Finally something with "Melbourne" in it that is doing well. Roll on summer 2011 /2

I think you have covered him perfectly in 6 lines RR. Hope it is not the case But I think his best is well behind him.

Talk about GWS and jobs for the boys. This looks a little "old boyish" to me

I have listen to him most weeks in the last month and the guy has a downer on all manor of things believe me it is just not the MFC Eg. today it was the irish game, poor fields on Oaks day and not interested in the last day of the carinval at Flemington. He has IMO a fairly negative view of life in general. Perhaps he should go back to WA because it seems little excites him in Victoria.

Sorry DC but you led with your chin and I could not resist.

Oh no not another Davey!

IMO WJ the Thai will be more enjoyable

Billy he is from WA.

Any chance of an introduction DC!

Here I go again sorry RR that was not what I meant see above comments. Believe me everyone I like him a lot.

That was not intend see my reply to WYL I think he was one of the bright spots of 2011. really like him.

So do I see what I said on his review topic. Must look different above to what I entended. I was making the observation that I was not surprised that he trained so well. Sorry if does not read that way.

So who are the candidates? does anyone know?

Not sure why you are surprised by Nicholson He is fast normally and he is a rookie who is into his second year on the rookie list. He will be looking to follow up his 2011 good showing with a better 2012. It is 2012 or never for this guy. Hope he makes it. Probably did not take a holiday wants to impress the new coaches straight up.

IMO the kid Has a great sense for where the goals are, I think it would be a waste to leave him in the back line. I like the way he takes the game on. Appears fearless. One thing you can be sure of he is not going to die wondering. He appears to give it 100% every week. I hope he makes it

Might even pick someone who can play this side of 2015 Do you think? No that is probably asking a bit much.

WJ I am devastated you are not going I was so looking forward to your review of the game.

I heard him this morning at approx. 9.30 he was asked why do you hate the MFC so much? His answer: Some CEO's go out of their way to help and provide info and others lie! So there, now we know what the problem is!

I remember him WJ I think he was on the list for 2 years but never got beyond ordinary seconds player. Was about the same time as Jimmy and Sean were playing.

Well said WJ I am a regular SEN listener and all he has achieved in my opinion is to make him self look silly. "Better to be thought a fool than open your mouth and put it beyond all doubt"

I heard approx 75% of the show this morning and there was no mention of it. Not saying it did not happen but I did not hear it.