old dee

No RB we made that mistake with DB. I have no idea if Neeld is a good coach or not. Lets not back ourselves into a corner lets at least wait till the start of 2014. Why rush this decision?

Oh no not the dreaded JD!

You have my vote jurrahcane with one very minor change Spencer will not be an emergency. With the current state of our list i.e injuries and not yet fit players I think that is about as good as we can pick. Big statement coming up "That team should be able to match Brisbane"

I am not certain on wyl, you may well be right of course he may be going to both. If you are trying to bait me DC it works every time with N0.7 I am going to the Brisbane game with my brother who is a Gabba Member so we get to eat and sit among the upper crust of Brisbane. It will not look very good to be seen lying on the floor in a fetal position crying. So please No.7 at Casey this weekend. PS Once again I forgot to use chrome!

I think he only left on Monday DC Said he was going to the game on sunday. Also think he was going to Thailand

I agree Monoccular and his form before that was ordinary

Spot on Jaded a lot are conviently forgetting this fact

Not sure that Fitzroy fans would agree with you Redleg. They got dealt some pretty crappy hands in their last two years.

I like Nicholson He has two big attributes IMO - He gets the ball, that is a good start to being a good player - He never leaves anything on the park, his is never going to die wondering "if only...." Play him ever game between now and round 22.

HG I think this is the reality bit

Well covered Nasher. Spot on the money

Seriously Big Jim You have to stop smoking that stuff. It is truely altering you understanding of reality.

You cannot get him till the end 2013 at the earliest. We need to focus on recruits to play at the start of 2013. Cameron is a pipe dream at this point.

LJ has been 2 - 4 weeks for the last 3 weeks. Looks like we are playing the Geelong game Nominate 2 - 4 weeks for as long as it takes!

Oh my god RR you will not believe it I am having the same flash!

Not sure how you work that one out IRW He has been out injured half of the games this year and is only now getting fit via Casey. It is a bit hard to improve if you are not playing!

Not unless he holds out and we take him in the draft and run the risk of GCS or GWS taking him before us.

That is exactly my point we played watts too early and imo it held him back. I don't think Cook looks as ready as Watts looked. Only my opinion McQueen I do not think he is ready physically.

The kid is a goer it is as simple as that. You will not get him away from GWS. Conduct the search somewhere else.

I do!

Good judges agree with you he got the Rising Star award for sundays game.

Chook I am not sure what has got up your nose so badly. I just said I disagree with you. Calm down.

Total 100% disagreement

I don't agree with you McQueen They are not as big or as strong as at AFL. I would suggest the average VFL player is not up to the same level as the WAFL or SANFL. The current VFL is not like the old VFA. There are way more kids like Cook playing from AFL squads. In the old VFA days you had a lot of players who did make it at AFL level or guys who went to the VFA after their AFL days were over. The average age of VFL players is much younger with less mature bodies. It is the breeding ground for new draftees from the AFL associates. I will maintain my thought Cook Is not ready for AFL.

Glad to see that they keep coming DC. 8.5 score