Everything posted by John Crow Batty
- POSTGAME: Rd 23 vs Gold Coast
- POSTGAME: Rd 23 vs Gold Coast
- POSTGAME: Rd 23 vs Gold Coast
-
How typically Melbourne Brodie Grundy
Could not have been any worse than Tmac, six touches and none in the last plus no scores for the game.
-
An external review of the Melbourne Football Club is required!
2023 average losing margin was 9 points. This season it’s been 29 points.
-
Trade Targets
Ben Hobbs from the Dons. 21 years old midfielder, reported on the outer over there. Any interest here?
-
Trade Targets
In the current environment Melksham might get another season.
-
When you knew 2024 was over?
I assumed the Brisbane loss was an aberration but I saw the West Coast loss live and it was ugly and disturbing. Harked back to the Neeld days.
- Angus Brayshaw Forced into Retirement
- Angus Brayshaw Forced into Retirement
-
Angus Brayshaw Forced into Retirement
- Farewell Alex Neal-Bullen
Maybe because no deal has been finalised, so he plays. If no deal I reckon he stays and makes other arrangements for his family. The money is too good to forgo especially with a new baby.- Best Presser Ever!!
Been a perfect storm of everything that could go wrong has. Despite several bad games and enduring controversies we have been up for the fight even up to last round.- Farewell Alex Neal-Bullen
With all the [censored] going on will Houston now want to come to us?- Farewell Alex Neal-Bullen
yeah, exactly the kind of player we need to keep during hard times.- Farewell Alex Neal-Bullen
Adelaide is a limited market for value.- MEMORIES by Whispering Jack
“an extra goal per game could have seen the club still vying for a qualifying final appearance”. Misuse of our only viable key forward likely cost us a finals spot. JVR’s forward time was interrupted far too much playing second fiddle in the ruck. Gave us many stillborn goals IMO. No other club as I am aware uses their best big forward to be the regular ruck relief.- POSTGAME: Rd 22 vs Port Adelaide
- POSTGAME: Rd 21 vs Western Bulldogs
- Moving The Goalposts
- Moving The Goalposts
If a player deliberately tried to hit a goal post they will sure miss every time.- The Ruck Conundrum
Goodwin seems to be obsessed that the 2nd ruckman has to able to play forward as well. We had Jackson who could play the role but he was a unicorn. Tried and failed with Grundy. We recruit Schache and Fullerton who are just jack of all trade hacks. Max is a big fail tried in both roles. Even Majak Daw was recruited because he could ruck and play forward/defence but we never used him. The last decent 2nd ruck we had was Preuss. Even in the Jamar days we had a young Gawn, Fitzpatrick, Pederson and Spencer who could be reliably called up to ruck compete out a game. Now we mostly rely on VDR which I believe almost certainly costs us several goals a game from his absence from the forward line every game.- Oliver Trade Rumours
- Allen Jakovich’s 30th Anniversary
Our defence in the Balme days was terrible The archetypical Swiss Cheese defence.- Allen Jakovich’s 30th Anniversary
He kicked 8.7 before 3/4 time then went quiet. Game was already done and dusted by then. He gave Danny Frawley a bath and upstaged Tony Lockett. Saints fans were shocked because it was an early game for Jako and still a relatively unknown. If only he was as disciplined and committed like his brother. He could have been an all time great. Burned too many bridges with his chaotic nomad lifestyle. - Farewell Alex Neal-Bullen