Jump to content

John Crow Batty

Life Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by John Crow Batty

  1. WC had had horrendous injuries but they rarely have had a go for the past two season. Surprising Adam Simpson isn’t under serious heat for his job yet. The club is a shambles.
  2. Having 50% more handballs than Geelong in wet conditions lost us the match. At the longest and narrowest ground in the AFL it should have been about gaining maximum territory at speed instead of passing the ball around in circles in tight slippery conditions. Most times we went forward we came across a well set defence and difficult to penetrate due to slow ball movement. Very poor tactical coaching to allow this to happen. Geelong at the start of last quarter went all in pushing the ball forward which gave them momentum from the centre. And yet again we lost the centre clearance battle badly. A couple of frees to us there made it look slightly better than it actually was.
  3. Gawn 1 mark for the game in the last minute of play. Worst game from him in a long time.
  4. 158 handballs to their 103 on a wet night. Game lost there.
  5. Cat are tough to beat at home but even tougher in cold wet conditions over there. It will be a win for the ages if we pull it off.
  6. An infection that requires IV antibiotics and a relatively long hospital stay for these days would be quite severe and debilitating. He must have had a whopping fever, weight loss and risk of septicaemia and internal organ damage. His appears the type of infection that killed many healthy people in the days before advanced antibiotics. I believe the severity has been downplayed somewhat by the club.
  7. The reality is that now the AFL should be considered as a cultural sports entertainment industry. Creates revenue for media, tourism, employment, airlines, caterers, other ancillary services as well as a public distraction to genuine problems in society. Just another successful business and quasi political tool. The equivalent of Roman circuses hence run by qualified elites.
  8. Kossie averages 1 more kick a game and 30% more tackles a game than Weightman. Both average around 1.5 goals a game. Kossie certainly needs a form and discipline adjustment at this stage of the season. Weightman also had a lean patch up the previous round. Hopefully Kossie turns things around in the second half of the season. Though I wouldn’t mind seeing him start next game as the sub to fire him up a little.
  9. You are right. The ball had to be over the line and the boot still in front of the line to be a goal. I remember doing this myself on a couple occasions. It was a clear rule that every player knew. Kind of has been forgotten now at least at AFL level. Perhaps to do with e frenetic pace and pressure of the modern game. Almost impossible to pull off a delicate tap and keep the foot in front of the line under pressure. The player will be severely crunched.
  10. Port reverting to type. Shades of 2021 prelim so far.
  11. Gunston 32 years old and Rich 33 years old. I say more of a case these guys reaching their use by date with age related form and injuries. Still an odd thing to do. I’d say it’s by arrangement with the coaches and selectors to avoid the indignity of once great players being dropped for the majority or entirety of the remaining season.
  12. nor his suntan.
  13. I think he is currently general manager of Casey Demons.
  14. Peter Maynard played 8 games in the 1970’s for us before going on to play around 200 games for Glenelg in the SANFL.
  15. And his father played for us as well. Likely grew up a Dees supporter.
  16. John Crow Batty replied to TRIGON's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    The Sicily tackle is complicated by the other Hawthorn player falling over Sicily and McLuggage mid tackle. Looks to me it may have had an effect on how the tackle ended up.
  17. Smith’s career has been ruined by injuries. Plays 2 or 3 games then out for months with injuries. Never had a chance to establish himself as a regular.
  18. To be fair their midfield has been a bit light recently.
  19. What kind of bird is a Spargo, maybe a type of seagull?
  20. I heard that Cox sucker punched one of our players.
  21. Kozzi should be made sub next game to hopefully make him think about his approach to the game from the bench. Replace him with Jordan who got more ball in one quarter than Kozzi did the whole match. Too good to drop at this stage but needs some time out.
  22. Too many Yank sportsmen are sore losers by nature. When they lose it’s because they haven’t cheated hard enough.
  23. Not the player since his contract renewal.
  24. Ginnivan out McInness in. Jordan our sub.