hardtack

I would rather a club that is prepared to take a stand against these sorts of neanderthals. If we do what is morally right, that will only enhance our chances of gaining a new sponsor as it will benefit their brand to be associated with an organisation that has sound principles.

+1

And where were all of the critics here last year when EnergyWatch were brought on board as a sponsor? I don't recall any of these issues being brought up on here at that time... hindsight is a wonderful thing.

Huh???

We sometimes hear of sponsors dumping clubs for bringing their brand into disrepute... if it happens and the MFC ditch EnergyWatch, could this be the first time a club has dumped their sponsor for bringing their brand into disrepute?

Was Leigh Williams training with the main group and if so, was he looking sharp? I notice that he will debut at Casey this weekend.

Not sure if it counts as being part of the rebuild (it was DB's first season?), but I would argue that our best win was not that against the Swans, but rather, the come from behind win versus Freemantle (Round 7, May 2008). team was: Bartram Bruce McClean McDonald Wheatley White Green Davey Miller Robertson Moloney Bate Wonna Bell Morton Jamar Garland Warnock Carroll Frawley Rivers Jones Green, Davey. Moloney and Bate were the best of our current crop in terms of possessions.

Dunn on a wing might be a good move? At least if they persist with long bombs to the forwards, he may be able to clear the lot and score.

You singled out Sylvia as using injury as an excuse for his poor performance, when that was clearly not the case according to the article you cited. He was using that as an incentive to improve, and improve he did. I consider your use of "excuse" in that instance to be demeaning of Sylvia and hence my use of the term "rubbishing".

To tell the truth, I didn't even notice Bartram's mark when watching the game :-) As for the Miller mark, yes, that was a great effort... the fact that he missed the resulting shot at goal was raised as a pivotal point in the game on AFL360 by David King; he was saying that if he had slotted that, the Tigers would more than likely have gone on to win the game.

Well, I'm tipping against us in the Tipping Comp... so on that basis, I might go out and have a few dollars on us to win - and that means we should end up with a draw.

Of course it was a reason!! Are you telling me that osteitis pubis would not hinder your development? Are you saying he should make no mention of this in an interview where would have been asked about such things? The main thrust of that article was that he was using those setbacks he cited as motivation to improve himself and he is spot on when he said it was time lost that he wished he could have back - it wasn't an excuse, it was a very honest piece of reflection on his part. As I said, that article is two years old and the past two years have probably seen the biggest improvement in his game - so he was as good as his word. Unfortunately fate has intervened and he has been struck another injury blow... but I suppose you will take the view that he is likely to use that as a reason for any substandard performances he puts in later this year.... sorry, but I really do get sick of all of the unjustified rubbishing that players get on this site.

Thanks for the link (to an almost 2 year old article)... after reading that, I would argue that he was NOT using those early injuries as an excuse at all... he was stating facts and was using that time he had lost as an incentive/motivation to improve himself and indeed it was at about that time that he did start make big steps towards improving his game... osteitis pubis early in his career and more recently interruptions in the form of a broken jaw/cheekbone(?) and now a major back injury are hardly fabrications to be used as excuses - for some they would be almost career ending.

I don't recall Sylvia using early career injury as an excuse... do you have a link to this information?

Either way, we're shot!

Just another forward, but Kurt Tippet's contract is up at the end of this year.

Ok, ok... this is just a distraction, but I woke up this morning with the burning question in my head, "why is a win worth 4 points and a draw 2 points? Why not 2 points for a win and 1 for a draw?" This naturally led me to start thinking (dangerous, I know) but an idea that struck me, and one that I actually think could be worth consideration, would be to have a bonus point for teams that win by a margin of 50 points or more; if for no other reason than to see teams playing the game out and minimising the possibility of those annoying junk time goals. Maybe silly (stupid even), but feel free to discuss if for no other reason than to take a moments respite from the doom and gloom.

The problem is that no matter what the MFC does, there will always be supporters (and I use that term very loosely) on this site that will find something to [censored] and moan about.

I'm dreaming of a repeat of the opening rounds of 2010... please don't wake me up.

Neeld hasn't considered taking action: http://www.afl.com.a...42/default.aspx

Haha... I knew who you meant OD, but in this case I really hope he is picked. After seeing the way our forwards were crashing and bashing (each other mainly) and the amount of ball that was going to ground with no-one there to take advantage of it, I believe Bennell with his great ball handling skills, pace and agility could have something to offer; he is definitely a big step up from what Green and Davey are currently offering in the crumbing department

"IN"?

Robbo was just restating what Caro had said obviously, so I'm not sure why you are having a go at him here. And I don't think we should move on in this case... justice should not just be seen to be done, it MUST be done... heads must roll... Misfud and Thomas must pay and our club must be completely exonerated of any involvement.

I suppose to some extent, this could have had an affect on Davey's performance on Saturday evening if this was already coming to light at that time... if he was the alleged source, then I expect he would have known what was coming. You have to wonder how much pressure these guys can take when all they really want to do is play footy.

I'm sure I just heard Robbo saying on AFL360, that the rumoured source was a senior indigenous player at the Dees... how many senior indigenous players do we have? The alleged player apparently denies saying any such thing.