Bobby McKenzie

And what about one particular bone crushing tackle he applied against the Cats. Ouch!!!! I bet the Geelong player thought he had been hit by a tram. Gee, this kid is going to be something indeed. Yet many are saying that Petracca is even better! Must be bloody good that's all I can say.

I agree. Maybe jazza would like to nominate the two so called 'clangers'. I bet one is where he started to play on, then cooly handballed to ANB for a goal. If he had have been caught with the ball then that would have been a clanger but this simply didn't happen.

He did win their B&F one year. So he must have been fairly useful.

Sure Jack played on, BUT wasn't he so super cool with that handball to ANB for a goal. He certainly is a prime mover in the thought department. Some would call it having a natural footy brain.

I think we all are Jaded. I'm doubly happy though. I missed on putting my tipping in on time. (Forgot the bloody Thursday game). They gave me the AWAY teams and I scored just as well as my original tips. The big bonus was getting the mighty Demons right! Gained on most rivals here. What about Vince's Left foot goal from a long way out?

Absolute ecstacy from our wonderful warrior skipper. Gee, has he earned this moment.

We did play them at the G last year and got walloped! It is very unfair however that we have to play at the cattery so often in recent years. Does not help a team trying to rebuild.

You have hit the nail on the head here dazzledavey. Give the poor bloke a chance to show his true form. Very unfair if he is dropped after one game AGAIN!

Reported that he did it during a spoiling attempt.

Not trying to be clever Wiseblood, but fractured and broken are exactly the same. Bad luck for Cam.

Very tough call.

And making it yet another visit to the cattery. In the last six seasons we have played Geelong at Geelong 5 out of 6 times. One solitary game at the MCG. Where is the fairness here?

When you think about it, giving away a free kick could easily be classified as a turnover. Confusing isn't it?

I agree with these examples but where in the hell are the other eight? So we kick the ball to Howe who marks it and kicks a point. They kick it in and with a chain of unbroken kicks and handballs score a goal at the other end. Therefore Howe's miss is counted as a turnover? Come off it jnrmac! Surely turnovers can be classified into two categories. Forced and unforced. Much the same as tennis has unforced errors and forced ones.

Repeat. Cite the 13 so called turnovers if you can Harrison. Watch the replay of goals scored and the chain of events leading to them. I'm buggered if I can see 13 Collingwood goals out of 17 set up by 'turnovers'. Don't like the term turnovers by the way it's a basketball term.

My thoughts exactly. This kid is going to be a true A grader.

Watch Garlett's second goal. The commentator said, "Lost his footing" which I guess is much the same as falling over. Should be a goal of the round nomination.

Watching the replay and the game I am sure that Jeff Garlett's second goal was absolutely brilliant. The commentators said that he fell over. I don't think he did, I think he deliberately propped to elude the guy on his hammer. What do others think?

Laxman was a beautiful stroke maker with perfect timing. Jack is a beautiful kick as shown by his long, penetrating kicks to a teammate. A very good analogy.

I don't! Comment about Watts and Jack Fitzpatrick in very poor taste.

Don't you believe that jnrmac. I would like someone to nominate the so called 13 turnovers that led to goals. Cloke scored most of his 7 from strong marking and one snap.

Who was your old man Beetle?

Jeff comes over as a very happy and pleasant young man who has put the past behind him. I too rate him as a great pick up this year.

Actually in the last 4 QB games Jack has been pretty good. 2011 19 disposals 7 tackles!!!! Yes, 7! 2012 18 disposals. 2013 16 disposals. 2014 21 disposals. I don't think that this game should cause him to have nightmares.

Answer my question Clint. What do you think?