jackaub

Except that he doesnt lead enough

Soon as Goodwin became coach JW was gone He wouldnt put up with that type of player and his lack of application Hogan is different but he does need to work hard on the poorer parts of his game No body is untradable if it is in the best interests of the team and the club It is the business of football !

Agreed Dr that's was what I was trying to point out

See Below Dr Well I guess any half descent forward could have kicked 35 against GC -4,WB-4,FREO-2,SK-3,WB-5, AD-5,CARL-1,GC-3,SK-3. as against SYD-1,AD-1,GEE-1,PA- 0,CW-0,ESS-2,RICH-2,HAW-1,NM-1,GEE-3 Total12

Maybe not its not broke at the moment is it.Hogans absence has been well and truely covered. But anyhow we wont know if playing without Hogan is working or not due to the many other factors. But it appears to be working.

Thats the bit they are missing Good Dr See above Goals analysis

Well I guess any half descent forward could have kicked 35 against GC -4,WB-4,FREO-2,SK-3,WB-5, AD-5,CARL-1,GC-3,SK-3. as against SYD-1,AD-1,GEE-1,PA- 0,CW-0,ESS-2,RICH-2,HAW-1,NM-1,GEE-3 Total12

So if Hogan were available for first final who do you drop to put him in? I presume Weiderman.

My problem is if Weid and T Mac are firing Melks and othersare on fire Where do you play him? Petraccas' position at half forward? On the ball?Whose position does he take? Perhaps forward pocket.

Hogan???

Want to see him holding some contested marks yet to show what he can do in this regard.

The team at the moment has very low footy IQ dp Total bfrustration watching it happen over end over and over again This lot dont seeem to learn Hope they do soon as it makes us easier to beat even though we win all the stats

Why does Goodwin insist on playing two slow pokes on the wings If they are no good inside, dont play them. Jones and Tyson on the wings is a real weakness that good teams exploit

The Irony in all this is listening to Mathhews join the band wagon of over the top commentary. He of all people should Shut the F#*K up Maybe we should just let the existing AFL process play out and comment then when there is actually something to comment on Herald sun showing multiple pages of the incident is appalling abuse or process and is encouraging mob rule ensuring an in consistent reactionary penalty When you have airheads on morning TV making inflamatory comments regarding penalties, without having the enquiry by the ruling body, you know who is running the agenda How about we just let the established process commence and play out

If we get less than 24000 at the G for a home game it actually costs the Club money. That is break-even in the existing structure. So transferring home games to NT where we are given a Sh*^tload of cash makes perfect commercial sense

So who are the Kangas going to trade to make this happen Will not be easy. Hope CW match the payment and sends them broke Just don't see how Degoey moves without the Kangas losing picks and players

Fortunately trees do grow In fact the begin life grow and die to be replaced What's the problem with trees?

Happy we have recruited true footballers not basketballers or plain old athletes This guy is pure footballer Love watching him play

Who will make way for Gaff in starting 22 Vince? Tyson?

Couldn't agree more A gun who plays 4 quarters is fierce and attacking Its great to see him back to his best

And the relationship to the performance of the club is described? Showing up on crap like masterbeef does nothing for the club and will not translate to memberships so why do it. You have presumed to have some idea about my view of the club.You obviously have no idea and are presuming a lot Just as easily I could draw all sorts ofwrong conclusions about a person who amongst 910000 other people get something from a show like masterbeef. Anyway mate enjoy your reality tv.

YES Rocky this was exactly my point Wasted on some on here couldnt agree more

Doesn't matter really it's a diversion we can do with out Let some other chump team do it Adds zero to the season in my opinion

Col (Just need a big pre season ) Silvia mark 2?? The Vegas pool party group always looking for new members CP5 come on down

Why cant this club stay away fro m this type of Bu$%*hit promotion Adds nothing to the club and diverts attention Concentrate on Playing and training for the next Game Carlton will not be easy and we need to put 100 % effort in to beat them