jackaub

Play Fritter down back he is very skilled and easily replaces Hibbo

Yes agree on Harmes He has palyed well for a few games now Hard nut but needs to hurt the opposition more

Quietly re-signed until end 2019 unfortunately

Agree that's the type we should look at.

The trouble is Dr we need a back up ready now and I agree we should trade for one If Max misses we are forced to sacrifice T Mac's game or play Pederson as stop gap. My point is we dont have a back up ready to go NOW!

YES mandee except that none are ready to fill in for max

Bermagui for me only 20 miles to the shelf

I think its been tragic we havent been able to develop another quality second string ruck at Casey in the time Max has beeen developing should have 2 or 3 devloping prospects in work at the moment Shoild be part of an overall strategy

Similarly the Dees are on a roll I'm hoping it continues

Totally agree Wise The weekend proved a lot I have the following: Tigs Win 4 Total 16 First Eagles Win 3 Total 15 2nd CW Win 2 Total 13 6th Syd Win 3 Total 14 5th Power Win 3 Total 14 4th Dees Win 3 Total 14 3rd Giants Win 3 Total 12.5 8th Cats Win 4 Total 13 7th More and More optimistic

No Change in my opinion Hannan is going ok. He needs to clean up his kicking for goal. No poroblems with his endeavour. He gets plenty of opportunity to score butneeds to improve accuracy. He will kick a small bag soon. No Tyson please!

Couldn't agree more Werri Man up the talls with Oscar and Keilty and allow Hibberd to play his natural run off game he is not a one on one defender The zone is not working how long before the coaches do something about it The set up and coaching plan is a major problem The players know it and as you say it's obvious

Yep Spargo works his arse off and agree totally on your other 3 ins Colleagues who are not dees supporters at work are mystified at the Frost exclusion It appears to be that the selections are either dumb or stubborn I hope it's not both as that is the worst possible case.

So who are the Kangas going to trade to make this happen Will not be easy. Hope CW match the payment and sends them broke Just don't see how Degoey moves without the Kangas losing picks and players

Why hasn't this been addressed by the coaching staff OD? Beyond belief. Not fit enough what the hell does he do all week?ohhhh that's right preening must take considerable time.

Trade out CP 5 before he becomes CS and worthless

Fortunately trees do grow In fact the begin life grow and die to be replaced What's the problem with trees?

Good summary Chookie

I speculated on that 4 weeks ago Gorgon 12 wins is all I can see we had to win pA and CW to really figure I have learnt that you just cannot trust the demons in any game but I am now used to it i have zero expectations now sad but make it easier to support them

Mate they failed themselves Always up to the indivigual just very very poor selections by a management looking for mesiahs and solutions to poor cultures thank god that is over with Goodbye jackie

PA had as win now loss 8/5 SK JUST A WIN 9/5 Freo loss 9/6 WB loss 9/7 GEEL JUST A WIN 10/7 ADEL WIN 11/7 SUNS JUST A WIN 12/7 SWAN LOSS 12/8 WC LOSS 12/9 GWS WIN 13/9 Also hard to see big % games in our wins so maybe only percentage gets us in Still optimistic though

No John we just lost the crucial match V Collingwood was a must win if we wanted to figure in September Even more disappointing we lost 10% in the bargain Won't get a better chance 15/7 to me is wildly optimistic 13/9 miss out on percentage Losses PA and GWS

His disposal under pressure hasn't been good enough to date to have him down back Hard to know where to play him based on his output this year

Wonderful analysis Skuit Thanks for that. We bring our A game and it should be a good win

Wow we are a very even team across all stats and more even than I feel the lid loosening ?