Curry & Beer

we lost by 2 points muppet

He's pretty damn good

well presumably we would have lost by even more if they were full strength it's a very simple and obvious concept mate, I'm surprised you have the aggots to even argue it

let's continue to extend your logic, what if we had injuries to our best 22 and thus the Casey side ran out in MFC jumpers.. would this also make no difference? FCS there is a reason you have the concept of a best 22, you don't just chuck one out and say 'meh our 23rd is just as good' it is illogical too many people just disregarding our injury list, it is hugely important

exactly, we kicked 6 in a row in about 20 minutes to take the lead by a couple midway into the third, we were dominating the same exact thing happened last week too we just need to sustain it for longer

St Kilda Attribute Melbourne 186.8cm Height 187.2cm 85.7kg Weight 86.6kg 24yr 9mth Age 24yr 5mth 77.6 Games 72.0

also lost Pedo during the game, that's TEN on the list, I would play about 8 of them if selecting a best 22

fair crack of the whip, he has had 66 touches in the last 2 weeks. Vince has had 72, these guys are not the problem.

the positive is of course that our current midfield stock does not represent what we will have going forward 2016 group: N.Jones, Vince, Tyson, Viney, Brayshaw, Petracca, Trengove, Toumpas, Cross, Vandenburg... others perhaps: Salem, Kent, JKH, ANB, Stretch, another high draft pick/imports from other clubs That's 16 good prospects from which we take the best 10 or so into battle. Most of them are kids who we naturally expect to improve. Things are looking OK for mine

Yes it sucked but I am pretty amazed at how much grown adults are having a sook about it. It's not like we are going to miss out on finals now. Our first year KPF kicked 5, could have been 7 or 8 - he is the biggest asset in the comp and he is ours. Toumpas, Watts and Grimes were all good. We already know Brayshaw, Kent and Salem will be good. Next year we get Petracca, Trengove and another high draft pick or import from another club. We have a huge injury list and a very hard draw so far. I still reckon we will win 5 more. Things are so much better than 2 years ago. Chill out everyone.

He did also play on from that free and miss a goal from 5 metres out.. and he dropped an uncontested chestmark inside 50 late in the game just sayin

Well at least Hogan broke this one today

He's kicked 21 goals in 11 games, he is doing his job

Has he played all year?

you don't believe we would have been two points better today if we had those 9 players available ?

agreed, he didn't do a single thing wrong. Some folks just make their minds up about players and ignore what actually happens on the field

we'd have won the last 2 if we didn't have an injury list with 9 names on it and that's just a fact

peed your panties in the NAB cup FFS the problem is you have absolutely no spine you'll be the first one back on the bandwagon after our next win

Grimes Cross Toumpas Watts Hogan Vince

With Garland, Jones and Jamar as the only ones left that played under Daniher - the survivors

just on that.. he's listed as 4th lightest on the list 30 Neal-Bullen, Alex 182cm 76kg 36 Garlett, Jeff 180cm 75kg 15 Stretch, Billy 180cm 71kg 24 Kennedy-Harris, Jay 173cm 68kg

Neal-Bullen to debut against Saints

correct - and what naturally follows is a far better run home: 14 Saints Etihad Stadium 10 Cats Simonds Stadium 3 Eagles TIO Stadium 13 Bombers MCG 16 Lions MCG 14 Saints MCG 4 Magpies MCG 12 Kangaroos MCG 11 Bulldogs Etihad Stadium 17 Blues MCG 1 Dockers Domain Stadium 5 Giants Etihad Stadium 4 games against teams in the top 5 (one of which is the Pies who we weren't far off from beating last week) 8 games against teams in the bottom 9 note also it is 6 at the G, 3 at etihad, one skilled, one in WA and one at Darwin, very advantageous geography also