Radar Detector

Just hard to watch. Numbing stuff, that. There are a lot of players who looked way out of their depth. Hannan back to his 2 games on, 4 games unsighted formline. Jackson and Weid both struggled to get near it. At least Weid kicked a couple I guess. Brayshaw and Harmes are a mile off their 2018 selves and on form, neither deserve to be in the side. Both being played out of position and both killing us with their disposal. TMac and Jones are both washed up. Kossie buzzes around and I think will be a player but lacks discipline both with and without the ball. But not sure who I’d be excited to bring back in either... Bennell and Tomlinson are at least up to the level. Vandenberg, ANB, Spargo etc are all seriously flawed players too. At least Vanders would give us intensity though. Selection this week will be a lottery. Pleased to have a Friday to recover so that crap doesn’t ruin my weekend.

Putrid doesn’t feel like a negative enough word to describe this performance. Any suggestions?

Putrid lack of effort from OMac there

Pickett has to stop that stupid push in the back.

This feels like 186

If only the umps were the problem.

Poor skills and poor discipline. This is unwatchable.

Harmes is useless

We look disinterested honestly.

Why do we keep kicking deep into the pocket?

Lever was hopeless in both those i50s.

He definitely needs a spell, isn’t offering anything right now. Wing is definitely not his position either. Their has to be someone else to play that role. Can’t imagine that Tomlinson, or even TMac would offer less roaming a wing right now.

If Geelong win tomorrow we’ve lost to 3 of the top 5 plus Richmond. We’re a chance against any team from here on in with all the bottom four to come. Don’t give up just yet.

I’d consider bringing in TMac for Brayshaw and letting him have a crack at the wing role, Richo style. He’s one of our best endurance athletes and would provide a good marking option roaming all over the ground. Also gives the team some flexibility like a rich man’s Tomlinson. Brayshaw would be unlucky though as he improved through the game. I’ve got no idea what will actually happen but the selectors have their mojo back the last couple of weeks so I’ll back them in.

Petracca Gawn Oliver Langdon Viney Weid

Does Vanders ever hit a target?

Need him to do a job in Sicily next week. Wouldn’t be the first time.

I went down to training a couple of times in the pre season - seems like years ago now - but he was surprisingly quick in the sprint work. I’ve never thought he was ready but he looks primed to become a key pillar in our defence now. Has the physical attributes to hold a big forward and is a calm user of the footy. I think our backline looks much more stable defensively with the three talls, especially as Lever doesn’t play as a genuine key back.

Pretty sure he struck Rankine with a swinging arm. Pretty iffy but suspect the umpire called it as a strike

This is like a teenager picking on the primary school kid. Collingwood or Hawks supporters would [censored] their pants laughing if they saw this. Let’s become relevant first...

6. Gawn 5. Viney 4. Trac 3. Oliver 2. Hannan 1. Langdon

Be careful of average stats Nev, after Carlton, Jayden Hunt led (or almost led ?) the AFL for average goals at 3.0 per game.

On today’s performance, I’d rather have Harmes in the contest than Oliver. In fact, we played our beat footy in late 18 once Harmes was swung into the guys. having said that, I’ll back Clarry to come good. Not sure about 17 or 18 others though.

Footy is dead to me for 2020. MFC can’t select the right side. Can’t dispose of the footy. Terrible coaching. Low scoring. We’ve had 2 years to correct this rubbish disposal. Only thing that would save the year for me is a new coach.