Everything posted by JJJ
-
Who will be the Judd McVee of 24?
Woewodin or Howes. Woey II can do a lot of different things well which should give him more opportunities. Howes is the type of player we could use in terms of physical traits. If he can stay healthy he might surprise as he offers a point of difference.
-
2023 Player Reviews: #4 James Harmes
I loved him but I donât think it was any secret that he and a couple of others were seen as net negatives with their off field lifestyles. Shame, he was great with fans of all ages at club functions and worked his backside off to get where he is now. As mentioned his kick to Fritsch in the GF was top shelf.
-
Dees Young Core Ranked 15th for 2024
We donât. We 3 young backs who help form an elite backline.
-
Dees Young Core Ranked 15th for 2024
I disagree with that. We knew internally what we had on our hands, hence why we stuck with him for so long. All a journo would have to do is ask someone for an off the record type comment on Gawn. Job done. But back to the article, whilst I do find the article a little confusing when they talk of recent draftees and their ranking, the rest of it is ok. We havenât had a lot of access to early picks of late and the results show.
-
Dees Young Core Ranked 15th for 2024
Is it the words or the ranking that people are not happy with? The ranking is about right when you think about where we have finished and our very small rotation of players over the past 2 seasons in particular. On exposed VFL and AFL form, youâd only circle a few of our players as genuine future/potential A-Graders; Kozzie, JVR & Rivers. If we still had Jackson our outlook would be a lot better. Plenty of quality AFL types on our list but the next Petracca, Oliver, Gawn, May, Lever et al I donât think are on our list, hence the desire to get the 1st in the draft this year.
-
Welcome to Demonland Koltyn Tholstrup
Definitely the former. There are plenty of inert blobs when the former players catch up though.
-
Welcome to Demonland Koltyn Tholstrup
Up close the kid looks like heâs got a lot of upside physically once he gets into an elite program. I was expecting him to be thicker through the hips and legs based off his highlights but he is just a lump of clay. Thatâs pretty exciting to think about given heâs already played senior WAFL footy.
-
Welcome to Demonland Kynan Brown
Had a beer last night at Bad Shepherd with the same fella. We chatted the draft amongst other things and I asked him if he was surprised that we got Brown via the Rookie Draft. He reckons Brown dropped later in the year due to some disposal issues and limited scope for improvement. Under pressure missed some targets by foot and his contested work is scrappy, not clean and momentum building. Also wondered about his ability to get bigger. In saying that, he did say his club didnât put a lot of effort into Brown as they try to avoid non WA players at the later stages of the draft. On a positive note, he also said if Goody told Brown to run through a brick wall he would and is very coachable. He thought we had a pretty good draft as Windsor and Tholstrup are good enough to play round 1 next year.
-
Welcome to Demonland Kynan Brown
Every time I see footage of Kynan I see someone who can run, hard at the contest and tackles well for his size. I like his work in close too. To me he projects as a small defender if he can make sure his DE% is up to par. I like the idea of someone with Pig level intensity starting their journey back there. The timing could work well for us as McVee should be looking to move up the ground by the time Kynan could be ready if his development is on track.
-
Farewell Brodie Grundy
He does seem like a reasonable fella. He couldâve joined the party and got stuck in but declined. Good post!
-
Farewell Brodie Grundy
I think the mutual talks to leave were earlier than we think. My mail is that he was the only player on the entire list who didnât attend a 200th game party for the skipper. A time that lines up with him getting dropped I think. I also heard he bailed on a club event around the same time but that source is not so good⊠Maybe a coincidence. Personally I wouldâve rolled the dice and selected him for the Carlton game. It was clear our forward line was dysfunctional but we needed targets who could at least bring the ball to ground effectively.
-
The Pick 1 Thread
Pretty sure I mentioned that. Just saying that WC were telling clubs thatâs what they wanted.
-
Welcome to Demonland Kynan Brown
If he doesnât make it, it wonât be for lack of trying nor will it have anything to do with supporter sentiment. Heâs a goer and would be an extremely popular father-son pick. I hope he makes it. His old man used to do my head in a bit as a player but is one of the nicest blokes youâll ever meet.
-
The Pick 1 Thread
I should mention, I donât blame North for not wanting to give up 2+3. Theyâd want something pretty good back. Like Geelongs future 1st and WC future 2nd etcâŠ
-
The Pick 1 Thread
Very good source told me WC are trying to turn pick 1 into 3 top 10 picks. Also told me that the stories about WC are wanting the WA tall are a tad embellished. The stumbling block is North Melbourne. they want Pick 1 and to keep 2 or 3 so they get either the better Tassie mid or Duursma. My guess is that it could look something like belowâŠ. Which is 3 inside top 11. There would be some additional bits and pieces thrown in to balance it out. WC 3, 8 + 11 North 1 MFC 2 Geelong 6 Personally if that were to eventuate or something similar I would be ok with it.
-
Nate Caddy
I watched a lot of TAC Cup and state footy in 2014-15 with a friend who was working for a Melbourne based club as a talent scout. Any comparisons between Caddy and Charlie Curnow are way off. Caddy doesnât have the explosiveness nor the ability below the feet like Curnow did back then. I thought Curnow was Kouta II. I also thought Harry McKay was a future all-Australian CHB and that Weitering was overrated. Anyway⊠Not to say we shouldnât draft Caddy, rather the Curnow comp is not a good one in my eyes.
-
The Pick 1 Thread
Curious to hear that people consider Jefferson as a future key forward. I donât think heâs viewed that way internally. Whenever I see him I see him as a classic 3rd tall who can mark and create something out of nothing. Similar to a young Cam Bruce without the running capacity. In any case, Essendon really rate Caddy as does StKilda. Not sure about us but if he draws the footy and can knock a few blokes over as a forward, we should consider him at 6. Seems to have a bit of x-factor too which I like in tall forwards.
-
Farewell James Jordon
Quality person. His effort and commitment was never in question. I hope he goes on to play plenty of senior footy at the Swans.
- Welcome to Demonland: Tom Fullarton
- Trade Rumours 2023
- Trade Rumours 2023
- Trade Rumours 2023
- Trade Rumours 2023
- Trade Rumours 2023
-
Welcome to Demonland Kynan Brown
The below sounds a bit nebulous but thought Iâd share anywayâŠ. I asked a mate who is a part time scout for an interstate club if heâd seen Kynan play. He has. âShredded, slightly undersized inside mid who goes unnoticed for periods in a game due to his work at the contestâ Reckons heâs got some elite traits that will translate to AFL. Ball winning, mental toughness and vision but also thinks he should play half forward as he could be elite in that role. Pressure, tackling, vision and hard running. He thought Kynan wouldnât be a pure mid in the AFL and is not a 1st round talent at this stage. (For context thereâs 10ish players he feels are definite 1st round locks with 20-30 players including Kynan to follow) He also had no idea where the club he reports to rated him but they consider it a lock that weâll take him in the 25-40 range which he thinks would be pretty good value from what heâs seen. on a separate note, is Trav Johnstoneâs kid still playing? I remember seeing a pic of him at the David Neitz Academy.